Verified Document

Motivation: Intrinsic Vs Extrinsic Motivation Plays A Essay

Motivation: Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation plays a critical role in the success of an organization. Employees who are motivated to achieve organizational goals and targets leave a positive impression on the overall performance of that organization. While there are many theories and strategies concerning motivation, the one that is most critical is the debate regarding intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. Motivational theories like Maslow's theory or Vroom's expectancy theory fail to completely answer the question of which kind of reward is more important for motivation: intrinsic or extrinsic. For example can we truly motivate a person by showing him how extra effort on a task can enhance his knowledge or do we really need to attach a monetary reward with it? A student may be motivated to study harder for intrinsic reward like more knowledge and higher learning but without appreciation and recognition, will he continue to put in the effort simply for the sake of intrinsic reward? Before we delve deeper into the debate, we need to understand what is meant by each term. We shall then discuss if intrinsic rewards are really more important than extrinsic rewards for employee motivation.

Intrinsic Rewards:

Intrinsic rewards come from within. This would the most basic definition of the term. Intrinsic value of a work refers to the inherent quality of the job that excites or motivates a person. A student who studies for at least two hours a day and is deeply motivated by the idea of learning more and gaining higher knowledge in the subject is said to be intrinsically motivated. But the same student would be extrinsically motivated if he is looking for better grades or more recognition from professors and fellow students.

According to Weinberg & Gould (2003), there are three types of intrinsic motivation:

Knowledge

Accomplishment

Stimulation

A person who is motivated by knowledge factor would be interested in mastering the task he is assigned. He would want to be the best in the field for his own satisfaction and pride. Accomplishment is a related factor and a person is motivated by sense of accomplishment when he knows that doing a job perfectly gives me an internal sense of fulfillment. Stimulation refers to the...

They don't come from within a person. A man does a job well because he wants recognition and reinforcement from others. He may also be motivated by tangible rewards like more money, better title and enhanced power. There are four types of extrinsic rewards as identified by Weinberg & Gould (2003). These are
• Integrated regulation

• Identified regulation

• Introjected regulation

• External regulation

Integrated regulation is when a person chooses to perform a task to achieve another purpose. A person working out very hard to lose weight and not to master the routine itself is involved in this kind of extrinsic reward.

Similarly when a person is interested in identified regulation, he is basically attached to a task because it is considered of high value by others in his social circle.

Introjected regulation is a more forced type of reward where a person seeks extrinsic rewards because of various kinds of pressures like impressing others, getting recognition, and basically being the best for extrinsic rewards and not intrinsic value.

External regulating is the most common type of extrinsic reward like performing a task for money and bigger title.

Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Rewards Debate

It is now being debated that while extrinsic rewards have their own place in motivation strategy, they cannot outweigh the power and force of intrinsic rewards. It is believed that for employee motivation, intrinsic rewards are now more important than extrinsic rewards. But that is not entirely true or even valid. There is no way an organization would develop a motivation plan and not involve extrinsic rewards. Every person needs some kind of recognition for a job well done. Even if he is performing the task for his own sense of fulfillment, it is an established fact that sooner or later he would want recognition for his good performance in monetary or non-monetary terms. For this reason, it is much better to link the two rewards and instead of undermining the role of one, we can say with certainty that intrinsic value of a job is enhanced…

Sources used in this document:
References

Weinberg R, & Gould, D (2003). Foundations of Sport and Exercise Psychology:

Human Kinetics.

Deci, E.L. And Ryan, R.M. (1994). Promoting Self Determined Education.

Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research. 38, 3-41.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Motivation in Sport
Words: 19272 Length: 70 Document Type: Thesis

Motivation in Sport Take a look at the animal world and you will find the proof that game is an inherent feature of the virtually evaluated species. This has an important part in literacy and evolution. We witness many a mock fights between kittens and pups so as to enhance their stamina, speed, tolerance and will. Through such hatred free games, they rub their hands for survival and satisfy their urge

Motivation Is Regarded As a Measure of
Words: 728 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Motivation is regarded as a measure of internal drive to achieve a goal. It is an essential human instinct, because without motivation people would lack the ability to progress. The amount of internal drive an individual has is influenced by a variety of factors such as personal gain, individual need, attitude and consequence of actions, to name a few. While capturing and classifying all of the different types of motivation

Motivation Organizational Behavior Has Long
Words: 2654 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

These performance appraisals are usually given to employees by managers. Such appraisals occur once or twice per year, depending upon the industry and the position of the employee. In some cases, performance appraisals are carried out by colleagues. Regardless of how feedback is given most organizations recognize it as a legitimate and productive way to judge performance and present employees with ways to improve job performance. Examples of Employee motivation According

Prime Gold Motivation the Leadership
Words: 6329 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Proposal

" (Herbig et al., 563) These motivational priorities, manifesting concretely in such terms as pay rate and personal interest, are relatively common throughout the working world. However, a point of distinction in this discussion may be raised from the fact that different cultures often produce distinct motivational forces. To this extent, the differences that are accounted for betwixt nations and demographics may be seen as directly pertinent to specific cultural

Edit Motivation Research in Organizational
Words: 5350 Length: 18 Document Type: Term Paper

Equity theory recognizes that individuals are concerned not only with the absolute amount of rewards they receive for their efforts, but also with the relationship of this amount to what their peers receive (Ramlall, 2004). Adams (1963, 1965) posits that individuals are motivated by the perception of inequality, as measured by "input" and "outcome" ratios in comparison to others. Equity theory draws from multiple empirical theories and is utilized to

Organizational Behavior, Motivation Western Motels
Words: 1540 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

At Western Motels, when maids quit their job, they refuse to give a reason for this. Such a situation may occur because they do not feel comfortable talking to their superiors. This is connected with the organizational problems discussed above. In order to improve communication, it is important that managers build the right infrastructure and to communicate openly (Smith, 2003). 7. There are many problems that must be addressed at Western

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now