Poor Argument Fallacies Essay

Length: 2 pages Subject: Black Studies - Philosophy Type: Essay Paper: #99496702 Related Topics: Argument, Black English, Math

Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … Reasoning

The narrator provides a few different reasons why Jack "is silly to think he can win the math contest." The first issue of course is that "silly" is entirely subjective, and that nothing the narrator says has anything to do with silly. It is not unreasonable to reframe the argument as that the author does not think that Jack can win the math contest. Never mind the silliness.

The first piece of evidence provided is that Jack has only won awards for writing essays. This is logical fallacy in that one has nothing to do with the other. The two types of contests test different skills, but where the narrator assumes that these skills are mutually exclusive, the reality is that they are not. Thus, it is possible that Jack can be good enough to win both types of contest.

If anything, Jack might have an edge if there is any sort of written component, Jack may well be at an advantage, given that he has a particular skill in this area -- it would depend on whether his math was in the range of the math students, and if his English advantage was better than their math advantage, a comparative advantage in writing if you will.

The narrator uses this as his support for this claim: "English majors aren't good at math." Now, a claim like this needs some sort of evidence, because without evidence it is unsupported. Resting one's argument on an unsupported claim is not going to result in a strong argument. The narrator could easily...


In order for this merit to have any merit, it has to be taken at face value, which is simply not good enough when engaged in a rhetorical exercise. The argument is stated, but it is not made.

The final part of the claim is that Jack is arrogant and insists he will win. Neither of these points has any relevance to the argument being made. It does not matter one iota whether or not Jack is arrogant. What he does or does not insist is also irrelevant.

What we are left with here is a completely unsubstantiated argument. The narrator in this case has an opinion, but supports this opinion with nothing. In short, it is not even an argument is the truest sense of the term -- even a bad argument must have some sort of base on which it is constructed.

To recap, the soundness of the logic is awful. None of the supporting points are either accurate nor are they relevant to the discussion at hand. To substantiate one's view that Jack will not win the math contest, one would have to present evidence that Jack lacks the requisite math skills in order to win. The author never even attempts to do this, but rather throws up a couple of weak, cliched red…

Cite this Document:

"Poor Argument Fallacies" (2015, May 28) Retrieved March 26, 2023, from

"Poor Argument Fallacies" 28 May 2015. Web.26 March. 2023. <

"Poor Argument Fallacies", 28 May 2015, Accessed.26 March. 2023,

Related Documents
Fallacies Fallacy 1: On His
Words: 785 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 96447552

My erections are at a healthier state from using VolumePills™, as from before to now they are a lot stronger and healthier." WHY THIS IS a FALLACY: This is begging the question because the writer (assuming a real person actually wrote that testimonial) is expecting the reader to accept on faith that this is true, without any way to check its validity. It is also an appeal to ignorance because

Fallacies in the Business World
Words: 1133 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Black Studies - Philosophy Paper #: 86430440

Fallacies in the business world can be fatal when making a decision. Fallacies can impede the critical thinking process, causing the decision maker to focus on solutions that are not the most appropriate, or confuse the issue at hand. For these reasons, it is important to understand what fallacies are out there and how they affect the critical thinking process. Only by being aware of them is a person able

Logical Fallacies
Words: 1320 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Black Studies - Philosophy Paper #: 89125900

Poor people should have their welfare cut off, because this will make them work harder. Right now, there is a disease in society, a moral outrage, and that is sloth and laziness. The Bible says that sloth and laziness are sins, but every day we see this in society. We have welfare queens and drug dealers getting welfare paid out of your tax dollars, and if that doesn't get your

Global Warming Argument Fact or Fallacy Critical
Words: 2496 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Weather Paper #: 22340910

Global Warming Argument FACT OR FALLACY Critical Thinking World Health Organization (2013) reports that, in the last century, the earth's warmth increased by approximately 0.75 degrees C. And further at more than 0.18 degrees every decade in the last 25 years. This phenomenon, called global warming, is said to result from the greenhouse effect whereby deleterious gases, such as carbon dioxide, trap heat within the earth's atmosphere instead of getting released. A steady

Critical Thinking Action Project Finding Fallacies in
Words: 686 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Black Studies - Philosophy Paper #: 41836752

Critical Thinking Action Project Finding fallacies in the prior assignment In the Introduction the statement was made that because the two offices of ExtraVert are in different locations and have "different objectives" that strategic situation will "create tension and conflict, which detract from the objectives and mission of ExtraVert." This phrase could raise the question as to the possibility that a "sweeping generalization" (Fullerton.edu) was made. Is it likely that "tension and conflict"

Logical Fallacies and False Appeals in the Media
Words: 341 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Philosophy Paper #: 82450189

Appeal to Authority In one advertisement for a skincare product, the company claimed “most dermatologists recommend...” the product. This is an appeal to authority: a classic logical fallacy. With an appeal to authority like this one, the speaker bases its claim solely on the authority of an individual or institution. In this case, the company uses dermatologists as their symbol of authority on skincare. While dermatologists are experts in the medical