Private Management Vs Public Administration Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Public Administration Type: Essay Paper: #34425949 Related Topics: Management, Government, Public Sector, Public Administrator
Excerpt from Essay :

Overview

To some, the difference between public administration and private management only lies in definition. From the onset, it would be prudent to point out that while there is some overlap between public administration and private management, the two are largely distinct on multiple fronts. In the first part of this text, I will demonstrate that the two discipline fundamentally differ on multiple aspects. In the second part of the text, I will assess the implications (for the public administrator) of the differences between the two disciplines in the realms of decision making, human resource management, as well as accountability.

Part 1

1. Definition

To begin with, and perhaps most fundamentally, the two disciplines differ in terms of definition. According to Waldo (as cited in Khan, 2008), public administration could be conceptualized in terms of “the organization and management of men and materials to achieve the purpose of the government” (p. 3). On the other hand, as the author further points out, private management could simply be defined as the organization as well as management of private business enterprises.

2. Goals and Objectives

The motives and scope of public administration and private management differ significantly. According to Milakovich and Gordon (2013), the overall motive of public administration is the provision of essential services to the general public. Thus, the key mandate of public administration is the promotion of public good. Public administration could therefore be linked to the larger political process. Private management is apolitical. This effectively means that private management is largely concerned with the advancement of activities of an economic nature with the overall objective being the maximization of shareholder wealth (or maximization of stakeholder wellbeing). This essentially means that it does not involve itself with public governance issues.

3. Accountability

Third, the two discipline differ when it comes to accountability. It is important to note that as Horn (1995) points out, accountability to the general public could be deemed the primary basis of public administration. This effectively means that those in power are ‘answerable’ to the general public. The public could, thus be seen as the ‘boss’ in this setting. Public accountability could, for instance, be explained in the manner in which funds are utilized in public administration. Indeed, as Horn (1995) observes, “the government is accountable to the citizens for the manner in which it manages and uses public funds” (p. 139). On the other hand, in private management, accountability happens to be to certain clearly identified stakeholders (Rabin, 2003). The said stakeholders could be inclusive of, but they are not…– in which case decisions are firmly rooted in management theory. A public administrator’s driving force should, therefore, be the promotion of the general public good. While the public administrator could still apply certain management theories and concepts in the execution of his roles, he is largely beholden to the overall agenda of the government of the day and, thus, has to ensure that the decisions he makes seek to advance the said agenda.

3. Accountability

As it has been pointed out elsewhere in this text, the public administrator’s main role is the further advancement of the wellbeing of the public. It therefore follows that a public administrator is accountable to the general public and must not seek to derive an unfair benefit from his position or advance an agenda that would essentially hurt or be against the interests of the general public. He ought to be guided by the relevant principles of good governance and ensure that, amongst other things, public funds are properly deployed and utilized. The table below summarizes the implications highlighted above:

Human Resource

Public administrators should rely on techniques such as persuasion so as to advance certain agendas

Decision Making

A public administrator’s driving force should be the promotion of the general public good

Accountability

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Fry, B. & Raadschelders, J.C. (2013). Mastering Public Administration: From Max Weber to Dwight Waldo. CQ Press.

Horn, M.J. (1995). The Political Economy of Public Administration: Institutional Choice in the Public Sector. Cambridge University Press.

Khan, A. (2008). An Introduction to Public Administration. University Press of America.

Milakovich, M.E. & Gordon, G.J. (2013). Public Administration in America. Cengage Learning.

Rabin, J. (Ed.). (2003). Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy: A-J. CRC Press.



Cite this Document:

"Private Management Vs Public Administration" (2020, December 19) Retrieved May 8, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/private-management-vs-public-administration-essay-2175920

"Private Management Vs Public Administration" 19 December 2020. Web.8 May. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/private-management-vs-public-administration-essay-2175920>

"Private Management Vs Public Administration", 19 December 2020, Accessed.8 May. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/private-management-vs-public-administration-essay-2175920

Related Documents
Public Administration the Ultimate Aim of a
Words: 3062 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 17902854

Public Administration The ultimate aim of a public administrator is the provision of best facilities to the public and to make decisions in a way that have a positive influence on interest of the public. It is important for a public administrator to identify the problems that are being faced by the local people and then to devise strategies that are helpful in solving that problem. In this paper we will

Public Administration Public Personnel Administration
Words: 1043 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 33867515

A great coalition of smaller firms aimed to defeat patronage and create an acceptable, predictable, regulatory environment; in other words, a credible commitment mechanism was needed, and politicians could supply this. This confluence of monitoring problem, change in political parties, and demand for security led to demand for a merit system that would offer legal security via impartial public agents, and that was less vulnerable to political manipulation (Shepherd,

Public Administration Woodrow's Public Administration and Politics...
Words: 589 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 91640201

Public Administration Woodrow's public administration and politics dichotomy is not workable. Politics cannot be practically divorced from public administration. In fact, there cannot be effective public administration without politics. Political institutions like the parliament engages in policy formulation while the public administrators' primary responsibility is to implement the policies that have been instituted hence the perception that public administration is a detailed and systematic execution of public law. Public institutions cannot

Public Administration Core Competency Final
Words: 4914 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 33397838

This is what is affectionately known as cutting through the red tape. Politics and Administration 2. Whether or not administration should be separate from politics is one of the abiding controversies of our field. Describe Woodrow Wilson's and Frank Goodnow's positions (and why they argue what they do) on the matter. Then compare and contrast their ideas with those of Luther Gulick and Leonard White. How does Jane Addams conceive the

Public Administration in Brazil Public Adminstration in
Words: 4752 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 56238291

Public Administration in Brazil PUBLIC ADMINSTRATION IN BRAZIL The grassroots and rural development happen to be the main concern and responsibility of any responsive government in a political system. This because the power of political participation is significant in any developmental process of a country which has persistently eluded many people at the grassroots level. Brazil as a developing country needs to take into consideration the significant of efficient administrative responsibilities in

Public Administration Budgeting PA Budgeting for Public
Words: 1677 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 74205891

Public Administration Budgeting PA Budgeting Budgeting for Public Administration Budgets are used in addressing various purposes including management and control as well as communication of goals, successes, the public entity's philosophy and explain the various departmental functions. Public administration professionals must be able to analyze the financial health of an entity by examining the budget. This work will assess how well available budget documents and auxiliary information address each of these functions on