Realism: Kashmira L. Jones The Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: History - Asian Type: Term Paper Paper: #32749714 Related Topics: Hermeneutics, Asian Philosophy, Positivism, Moral Relativism
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Additionally, it is important to note that the perceptual nature of truth, even as it is unexamined does not in itself make truth genuine -- and that all is not relative. Instead:

Bhaskar contrasts a relative and developing ethical naturalism with a rational moral realism. Ethical naturalism is at the level of moral rules designed to guide actions, and these change over time with changes in our ethical concepts (for example, "slave," "person"). Underlying these is a moral realism which grounds our ethics and which can be rationally discovered via analysis of the changing nature of ourselves, our needs and our society. Bhaskar speaks of "ethical alethia, ultimately grounded in conceptions of human nature" (DPF 211). It is moral realism that prevents ethical naturalism from being an arbitrary matter internal to a culture (Irwin, 1997).

If then, there is a way to view the "facts" or events according to this moral realism, then how is it that these facts are constructed as true? For example, of key -- or perhaps, in many eyes outside of the conflict, or of paramount importance in the Kashmir controversy is the fact that people are suffering and dying as a result of the discord there. Further, even more suffering, perhaps globally is likely to result from the continued clashes between India and Pakistan over the issue (remember, both sides have nuclear capabilities). Is this suffering a crucial "fact" that must be taken into account?

Again, according to Lewis Irwin in his interpretation of critical realism, "...Critical realism conceptualizes events and situations in relation to the real mechanisms which generate them, rather than conceiving them as atoms that determine our knowledge of them without any kind of mediation." Thus, the individual observes events, and interprets those events into facts. Further, the degree to which each individual understands the social mechanisms that lead them to their factual conclusions, the more critically "real" they will be. Again, this is the key that guards against "willy-nilly" relativism -- for according to Bhaskar, "...perspectives are real and are parts of totalities in which agents are embedded (Irwin). The challenge here is being able to get some kind of grasp upon that totality.

Critical Realism: The Kashmir Solution

Given the perspectives of each side in the Kashmir conflict, it is clear that the "real events" are war, conflict and violence that "result" in poverty, injury, starvation, economic hardship and death. We know that these are real and they are...

...

Further, we also know that these states are socially undesirable as agreed upon by virtually every societal system on earth. Of course, it is obvious that by removing the dispute from the land of Kashmir these effects can be eliminated, but which side is closer to the answer?

If on a cursory examination one examines the rational explained by both sides above, especially with regard to a willingness to view the human suffering as a fact, one sees that the Pakistanis side seems to be more "in touch" with their perceptual bias in their ability and willingness to "show" the world the results of the conflict on the ground. Of course, this is not to say that they do not share a bias in their unwillingness to relinquish Kashmir to its own sovereignty. However, given India's control over much of the territory, this point may be moot.

India, on the other hand, refuses to even acknowledge the suffering that the conflict as exacted on the people -- with particular emphasis on their unwillingness to acknowledge their specific role in that misery. Instead, they focus on "rule" based thinking, i.e., "legally it's ours, the Maharaja signed it over!" which, according to critical realism is not a "reality" resulting in an effect. Further, they also refuse to allow independent observes into the area, perhaps as a result of their fundamental (if unspoken) cognizance of the falsity of their position.

Conclusion:

According to the realist approach, the Pakistani side seems to be more on track with regard to "reality" in Kashmir. Not only do they recognize the on the ground truths, but they invite others to do so as well -- a definite point in their favor. Although many might argue (and rightly so) that the situation is much more complex than believing the Pakistani position on Kashmir is the correct one, the official perspective of the Pakistani government (as represented by their public concerns and calls for international observers) is certainly more encompassing of the "totality" of the situation than the Indian view. Again, this is not to say that the Kashmir problem would be necessarily solved by a transfer of all land and power to Pakistani control, however, it would certainly (according to a critical realist interpretation), be a vast improvement on the status quo.

Works Cited

Basden, Andrew. (2004). "Bhaskar's Critical Realism." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.isi.salford.ac.uk/dooy/ext/bhaskar.html. Copyright BBC. British Broadcasting Company. (2002). "Q&a: Kashmir Dispute." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/353352.

Irwin, Louis. (1997). "Critical Realism." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.raggedclaws.com/criticalrealism/index.php?sitesig=WSCR&page=WSCR_060_WSCR_Glossary&subpage=WSCR_130_Ethical_Naturalism_and_Moral_Realism

Kaboub, Fidel. (2000) "Roy Bhaskar's Critical Realism: A Brief Overview and a Critical Evaluation." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://f.students.umkc.edu/fkfc8/BhaskarCR.htm

Walsh, Christine. (2003). "The Kashmir Conflict." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.indianewengland.com/news/2003/04/15/Community/Kashmir.Conflict.In.N.h-410521.shtml

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Basden, Andrew. (2004). "Bhaskar's Critical Realism." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.isi.salford.ac.uk/dooy/ext/bhaskar.html. Copyright BBC. British Broadcasting Company. (2002). "Q&a: Kashmir Dispute." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/353352.

Irwin, Louis. (1997). "Critical Realism." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.raggedclaws.com/criticalrealism/index.php?sitesig=WSCR&page=WSCR_060_WSCR_Glossary&subpage=WSCR_130_Ethical_Naturalism_and_Moral_Realism

Kaboub, Fidel. (2000) "Roy Bhaskar's Critical Realism: A Brief Overview and a Critical Evaluation." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://f.students.umkc.edu/fkfc8/BhaskarCR.htm

Walsh, Christine. (2003). "The Kashmir Conflict." Web site. Retrieved on November 21, 2004, from, http://www.indianewengland.com/news/2003/04/15/Community/Kashmir.Conflict.In.N.h-410521.shtml


Cite this Document:

"Realism Kashmira L Jones The" (2004, November 21) Retrieved August 11, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/realism-kashmira-l-jones-the-59024

"Realism Kashmira L Jones The" 21 November 2004. Web.11 August. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/realism-kashmira-l-jones-the-59024>

"Realism Kashmira L Jones The", 21 November 2004, Accessed.11 August. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/realism-kashmira-l-jones-the-59024

Related Documents
Pakistan ISI
Words: 1273 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 75256824

Pakistan's ISI: 'A Kingdom Within a Kingdom'? Pakistan is one of the indispensable allies of the United States in the war on terror, especially in the current struggle against Taliban and other extremist movements in Central Asia. But the American relationship with Pakistan has remained precarious, partly because of the shadowy activities of Pakistan's main intelligence service the Inter-Service Intelligence (ISI). According to Sean Winchell, until the Pakistani general and the

Pakistan Economy Currently There Is
Words: 4110 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 49598907

In addition the continued decline of the fiscal account will affect both debt sustainability and external balances ("Monetary Policy Decision"). As it pertains to medium term fiscal sustainability which must be present to achieve necessary overall macroeconomic stability, the tax-GDP ratio must be increased ("Monetary Policy Decision"). Additionally government expenditures must decrease ("Monetary Policy Decision"). The article also reports that the revenue deficit, which represents the difference between total revenues

Pakistan Is Currently Ruled by
Words: 828 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 83172635

S. In Pakistan, especially in the border areas. Any attacks by the U.S. forces inside Pakistan, which would invariably entail "collateral damage," are likely to fuel further anti-Americanism. The current policy of Musharraf to seek co-operation of the local tribal chiefs in the border areas against the Taliban and Al-Qaeda should be supported by the U.S. A political, rather than a purely military solution to the problem, is the only

Pakistan ISI and GWOT
Words: 753 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 46776110

Pakistan ISI and GWOT Described variously as a U.S. ally in the war against terror, Pakistan's actual commitment to the U.S. As a reliable partner in the global campaign against terror has in the past come under scrutiny with some accusing the South Asian State of aiding militants in the region. Matters have been made worse by the latent support the U.S. has received from the ISI, the state's foremost national

Pakistan Is Pakistan the Most
Words: 1740 Length: 6 Pages Topic: History - Israel Paper #: 34121

Foreigners wishing to travel in large parts of the country are required to take along a government-appointed armed guard. Pakistan's numerous intelligence agencies are a brooding, malevolent presence in the nation's life. President Musharraf has survived a couple of assassination attempts (the first in December of 2003, when Musharraf's convoy was attacked twice within two weeks. The second one, on Christmas Day, left 14 people dead and dozens injured).

Pakistan FDI and Portfolio Investment
Words: 1239 Length: 5 Pages Topic: History - Israel Paper #: 42439028

McQueen's research in 1990 demonstrates just how little progress has been made. McQueen noted in 1990 that, "Pakistan has had consistent growth averaging 6.7% over the last decade, placing it among the fast-growing third-world economies. Some apprehension exists regarding deterioration in the law and order situation in Sindh Province, where in recent months ethnic and politically motivated violence has claimed a number of lives and slowed industrial activity. Regionalism, ethnic