School Boards Will Be Obsolete Essay

Length: 13 pages Sources: 100 Subject: Teaching Type: Essay Paper: #49396030 Related Topics: School Funding, Law School, School, School Administrator
Excerpt from Essay :

While a relative handful in number, the attention given to these districts has caused some to conclude that the nation's 14,350 school boards overall might not be needed or equipped to provide a 21st-century education.

School boards, like an old car past its prime, need attention and that the status quo will not suffice for those who want improved student outcomes.

Teachers, especially in connection with collective bargaining, have assumed many of the prerogatives that school boards once reserved for themselves.

Some commentators have implied that school boards are really not necessary any more.

New governance models threaten to make school boards in some locales obsolete; financial pressures leave school boards less and less leeway in their spending decisions.

In America of the 21st century, many school boards struggle to attract top-flight members who are willing to put up with the grief that comes with the job.

Interest in and support for the public schools have ebbed as the percentage of households using the public schools has declined and the portion of public school students who look different from the people who pay most of the taxes has increased.

The neighborhood school is no longer the focal point of the local community as people are less attracted to what it offers. School boards continue to consume the largest share of local taxes, but they find less support from taxpayers for what they try to do.

School boards oversee too many complex activities; their governance extends to personnel, curriculum, and instruction -- not to mention transportation, food services, and facilities.

Every school board -- whether it governs a district of 1,500, 15,000, or 150,000 students -- is supposed to oversee the same conglomeration of duties.

Furthermore, a great deal of the work of school boards is little more than window dressing, taking votes on matters on which the school board has no genuine authority.

During the past 60 years, school boards have experienced increasing incursions on their authority and power.

The very complexity of school systems and challenges to education make it increasingly difficult for school boards to master their roles.

School board members are no longer a match for the experience and expertise of superintendents, central office bureaucracies, and unions.

School boards in the United States are frequently passive or reactive.

School boards' lack of initiative in addressing issues of equity and achievement has given rise to myriad state and federal laws and regulations that now constrain local education governance.

By acceding to pressures to favor some constituencies over others, preserve educators' prerogatives, and focus more on operations than education, many school boards are parties to their own impotence.

School boards are being replaced by school-based decision initiatives that provide teachers at the school level direct control of the key variables in the learning environment, including the characteristics of the staff, the use of teacher and student time, classroom management techniques, assignment of students, curriculum and learning materials, as well as the use of equipment and space.

These changes directly and fundamentally affected the roles of central office staff which had been responsible for many of the things that are now being delegated to the local school.

The role of the school principal has also dramatically changed, from that of administrator to that of collaborator and instructional leader.

Attacks on school boards will continue and escalate, thus diminishing what credibility school boards have managed to retain.

There will be sporadic efforts in state legislatures to circumvent and/or diminish the roles and authority of school boards.

Multiple political pressures will result in increasingly dysfunctional school boards.

There is growing controversy and confusion surrounding the role of school boards.

A debate on whether or not the nation's school boards serve a useful purpose continues.

Particularly in rural areas, school boards appear not to have a powerful influence on the academic life of their schools.

School boards and their administrators are at an important crossroads; some suggest that school boards should be dissolved or at least their membership composition radically changed.

School boards have become defenders of the status quo. . .[and].their members display the same rosy-tinted complacency as do the administrators they hire.


better, because it would give the process a unified direction and help establish national priorities.

Local school boards encourage social promotions, polarization and economic castigation of lower achieving students.

Success in school determines student's future social and economic success; local school boards are apt to embrace untested theories, thereby traumatizing and confusing teachers and students alike.

Local school boards are obsolete.

State Trends

Policies regarding shared decision-making at the school level currently vary significantly across the country.

In California, the state board of education policy mandates that training be provided to parents to become more effective participants in the school-based shared decision-making process at each of the state's individual school sites.

The shared decision-making process now includes teachers, administrators, students, and other community members regardless of school size or student population.

The approach being used in California will expand the role of individual schools by providing them with charter-school-like authority and flexibility.

While addressing issues of equity and accountability; the reform initiative will incorporate weighted student funding, an initiative envisioned for years at the state level, by providing more money for low-income and high-needs students.

The current system used in other school districts in California assigns a great deal of accountability to school principals for academic achievement but they do not have corresponding authority over school funding.

Funding for the majority of school districts in California is based on the curricular offerings and educator salaries; however, the process is highly secretive.

By applying a weighted approach to school funding, though, parents, teachers and principals have all experienced increased decision-making authority concerning how these funds are used at the school level.

Likewise, the state of Tennessee has been in the vanguard of those states implementing school-based decision making in its public schools.

In fact, as early as the 1989-1990 school years, school-based decision making was implemented in public schools in the Memphis City School System.

In Kentucky, changes in the responsibilities of local school personnel included the introduction of school-based decision making and school councils.

Although many functions of central office professional staff have been changed in Tennessee, school board members are no longer be involved in personnel decisions beyond hiring a superintendent.

In New York, imprudent delegation of authority to subordinates is especially problematic for school boards, where the average tenure of board members is less than five years.


Global trends in education all indicate that a new skill set will be required in the 21st century.


These trends are being driven by innovations in technology.


National curricula are becoming increasingly commonplace.


The U.S. remains one of the few industrialized nations that does not have a standardized, national curriculum.


The waves of reform that have reshaped the American public school system have introduced new calls for increased accountability and responsiveness to local needs.


In the U.S., school boards are increasingly being viewed as archaic relics of a past age where limited transportation and communications required such localized oversight.


At the state level, a growing number of states are opting for school-based decision making that controls funding and other issues previously overseen by school boards.


School-based decision-making approaches are becoming increasingly popular alternatives to school boards.


School boards are viewed as being out of touch with the needs of students in the 21st century and have failed to consider the needs of all stakeholders.


A growing consensus discerned from recent and current trends suggests that not only will school boards be obsolete in the United States by 2050, in many cases, they already are.

Spring, J. (2001). Globalization and educational rights: An intercivilizational analysis. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, p. 1.

Uko-Aviomoh, E.E., Okoh, E. & Omatseye, B.O.J.…

Sources Used in Documents:


Pankratz & Petrosko, p. 63.

Manley, P.J. & Manley, R.J. (2005). School boards don't need state oversight. The CPA Journal, 75(4), p. 11.

Cite this Document:

"School Boards Will Be Obsolete" (2011, February 26) Retrieved October 3, 2022, from

"School Boards Will Be Obsolete" 26 February 2011. Web.3 October. 2022. <>

"School Boards Will Be Obsolete", 26 February 2011, Accessed.3 October. 2022,

Related Documents
Rural School Boards
Words: 6015 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 67295453

evolution of perception of the role of school members over the past 2 centuries or so and how the analyses of these perceptions also changed over time. This discussion is followed by an examination of the antecedents of tension for school board members in general and for rural schools board members in particular in the United States and how these tensions have been described and reported in the relevant

Reforming Urban Schools
Words: 13440 Length: 49 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 79283099

School Choice Program This study aimed to determine the impact of school choice through a comparative study of two private schools, which serve primarily, or exclusively African-American students, and a public school. Data in student achievement in math and reading and data on student attendance were used to determine the impact of choosing a school. Qualitative data derived from interviews with administrators and faculty as well as classroom observation were used to

Public School Finance the Williams Case
Words: 2724 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 44381103

Williams Case Settlement Mr. Governor, our youth represents our state's future - addressing and correcting the discrepancies that will be addressed in this memo should be a main priority and maybe even the ultimate objective of the Williams Class action lawsuit educational budget adjustments. The Courts have spoken and have obviously concurred that the California Educational System has been broken for quite some time and is in need of serious financial

Leadership in International Schools
Words: 29649 Length: 108 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 20990082

Leadership Skills Impact International Education CHALLENGES OF INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION Practical Circumstances of International schools THE IMPORTANCE OF LEADERSHIP IN EDUCATION What is Effective Leadership for Today's Schools? Challenges of Intercultural Communication Challenges of Differing Cultural Values Importance of the Team Leadership Style LEADERSHIP THEORIES Current Leadership Research Transformational Leadership Skills-Authority Contingency Theories APPLYING LEADERSHIP IN AN INTERNATIONAL SETTING Wagner's "Buy-in" vs. Ownership Understanding the Urgent Need for Change Research confirms what teachers, students, parents and superintendents have long known: the individual school is the key unit

Elementary School Principals and Job
Words: 6342 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 71664710

According to Copland (2001), although the following job description is a parody, it is not too far from the truth concerning the current set of responsibilities that confront the nation's elementary school principals: Position Opening: Elementary School Principal, Anytown School District. Qualifications: Wisdom of a sage, vision of a CEO, intellect of a scholar, leadership of a point guard, compassion of a counselor, moral strength of a nun, courage of

Framework of Implementing the Z. Mathematical Model to a Sixth Grade...
Words: 18348 Length: 67 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 66274868

Nature of the ProblemPurpose of the ProjectBackground and Significance of the Problem Brain Development Specific Activities to engage students Data-Driven Instruction Community Component of Education Research QuestionsDefinition of TermsMethodology and Procedures Discussion & ImplicationsConclusions & Application ntroduction The goal of present-day educational reformers is to produce students with "higher-order skills" who are able to think independently about the unfamiliar problems they will encounter in the information age, who have become "problem solvers" and have "learned how to learn,