Verified Document

Schumacher, Gunter & Wasieleski, David M. 2013 . Article Critique

¶ … Schumacher, Gunter & Wasieleski, David M. (2013). Institutionalizing ethical innovation in organizations: An integrated causal model of moral innovation decision processes. Journal of Business ethics 113:15 -- 37 DOI 10.1007/s10551-012-1277-7

A business' financial survival and pursuing an ethical course of action are often seen as mutually incompatible. However, according to the article "Institutionalizing ethical innovation in organizations: An integrated causal model of moral innovation decision processes," by viewing ethics as part of the process of business innovation, ethics is likely to be viewed in a more positive light. Just as organizations must change with the marketplace, so must their ethical schemas. Ignoring ethics can put a business at profound risk, just like ignoring other aspects of organizational innovation.

Ethics has usually been seen as separate from the process of innovation in the past: "managers are expected to...

Stability and change are seen as mutually incompatible, rather than as complementary. The processes of change must be built into the structure of the organization, including the processes of ethical change (Schumacher & Wasieleski 2013: 19). The organizational culture must support ethical conduct as well, rather than view it as anathema to the firm's survival.
Ethical systems have multiple components, including ontological imperatives "in the form of fundamental moral values" that are unwavering; functional imperatives which are defined as organizational necessities; and finally as 'grand options' which are "integrated in a context of choice" and exist in a "long-term" both of "non-permanence and particularity" (Schumacher & Wasieleski 2013: 22). In other words, there are certain aspects of an ethical system which are stable…

Sources used in this document:
Ethical systems have multiple components, including ontological imperatives "in the form of fundamental moral values" that are unwavering; functional imperatives which are defined as organizational necessities; and finally as 'grand options' which are "integrated in a context of choice" and exist in a "long-term" both of "non-permanence and particularity" (Schumacher & Wasieleski 2013: 22). In other words, there are certain aspects of an ethical system which are stable and unchanging, but this does not mean that the system must be insensitive to the day-to-day workings of the business. There is a need to be flexible with future market conditions and other environmental pressures which could affect the organization's evolution.

The authors integrate this philosophical view with the ethical worldviews of the social sciences (their emphasis is on organizational culture and structural functionalism) and also with an evolutionary view of change from the natural sciences. They have created their own ethical model called ICM (Integrated Causal Model) which embraces the fact that change is a constant process, but which also emphasizes certain stable values. From the natural and social sciences it offers a simultaneously objective and subjective view of reality: organizations must acknowledge 'hard data' but they must also reflect upon how decisions will filter through the unpredictable, subjective lens of human agency (Schumacher & Wasieleski 2013: 26).

The article concludes with a presentation of how the model would work regarding decision-making in the 'real world' through a series of stages: Stage 1 (time horizon of the decision); Stage 2 (degree of ethical sensitivity of the decision); Stage 3 (integrating the decision into the company's value system); Stage 4 (making innovative decisions taking into consideration influencing variables for the organization) (Schumacher & Wasieleski 2013: 27). Every decision is slightly different in terms of the significance of its ethical implications for the organization in the long and short-term, and the far-reaching nature of its effects. This approach integrates a combination of mechanisms: every ethical action is evaluated in an individual fashion; long-term implications are important but do not dominate purely technical decisions; and situational scanning is ever-present. Ethics is integrated into all business processes in an equal and realistic fashion.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now