Superintendent Politics The Political Pressures Thesis

Length: 10 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Government Type: Thesis Paper: #19152717 Related Topics: Political Parties, Politics, Political Aspects, Job Description
Excerpt from Thesis :

With the difficulties of resolving budget controversies, contending with myriad resource shortfalls and enduring a federal economic perspective toward education that is today, inconsistent at best, criminally negligent at worst, the superintendent must sometimes make decisions which are responsible but reprehensible to those without a full appreciate for the centricity required of the position. To this end, one journal published superintendent conceded that "partisan politics sometimes forces the superintendent of schools into a dilemma in which he must champion disgusting leadership in his party simply for the sake of being regular and therefore to hold his position as a school leader and through this leadership to do what he can to carry forward a decent program for education in his community." (Hall, 241) Such is to say that the superintendent must be conscientious of and willingly participatory in the political process if he is to survive in the position.

Even still, it has become a problematic inherency in some districts that the superintendent's role is generally seen as a conflictive one. The responsibility of resolving both practical and political priorities from diverse parties is not just a defining aspect of the role but is, even further, a confounding issue considering the core importance of educational development. To this point, a survey from 2001 of active superintendents revealed a troubling level of reported discontent with the ability left to satisfy the practical demands of a job impeded upon so heavily by political imperatives. According to the study, "over half of superintendents (54%) say they have to work around the school system to get things done, and one in 10 say the system actually ties their hands. Over half of principals (57%) say that in their own district even good administrators are so overwhelmed by day-to-day management that their ability to provide vision and leadership is stymied." (Hasan, 1)

Indeed, when we look at the responsibilities of the superintendent in such contexts as the administration of statewide school-districting concerns, it is apparent that public-impression, regional differences and statewide cultural realities also all play a crucial role in molding the political horizon for the person holding this position. One recent example demonstrates how politically difficult it can be to appease a diverse range of parties, all with a vested interests in the decisions which fall upon the shoulders of the superintendent. The notions of both dilemma and compromise have been touched upon in this discussion, and in the 2004 case of Georgia's statewide education policies, the state's school superintendent confronted a difficult dilemma with a compromise that in its attempted centricity has earned extensive criticism for its originator. In January of that year, state superintendent attempted to deal a middle-ground resolution to what has long been a sensitive and thorny issue concerning the content taught in public schools. With many of the religious Christian disposition objecting to the use of the term or instruction on the concept of evolution, a theory which many creationist devotees find to be blasphemous, there has long been pressure on school administrators and elected officials to push for some solution which might satisfy what comprises a statistically significant population of school parents and is becoming an increasingly powerful lobby group. The result of this is that the superintendent of schools in states such as Georgia, where such demographics are well-concentrated, is under pressure by segments of the public who wish to see part of the curriculum banished while, in response to this disposition, the superintendent is under equal pressure to defend this part of the curriculum. This constitutes a true dilemma because essentially any conceivable compromise will provoke vocal response from both parties for a failure to meet the totality of their demands. To this end, in Georgia, offering a prospective compromise to parties on all sides of the issue, "superintendent Kathy Cox said the concept of evolution would still be taught under the proposal, but the word would not be used. The proposal would not require schools to buy new textbooks omitting the word evolution and would not prevent teachers from using it."...


Instead, she has sought to administrate curriculum in a manner that she believes will straddle the middle ground and thus allow teachers the autonomy to teach scientific concepts absent of the elements which may be considered implicative of blasphemy. The result has been the outright hostility of parties on both sides.

The superintendent has been roundly criticized by opponents of evolution for failing to take any meaningful action, with most regarding this semantic approach as an essentially empty gesture. By retaining the concept while simply removing its key terminology, many believe that her response to political pressure has been negligible. In exact parallel, those applying political pressure requiring schools to defend theories which have been lent considerable scientific credence view the recent proposal as an undeserved nod to the interests of those actually demanding that schools bypass empirically verifiable education at the behest of religious extremists. The intensity of rhetoric and the transcendent nature of the issue illustrates that this is in impasse by which a superintendent may be hard-pressed, indeed, even unqualified, to resolve. Such is to suggest that the saddling of a school district or state system with the pressure to exemplify certain beliefs, ideals and cultural characteristics in turn burdens the top executive figure to find ways to temper this responsibility with the demands placed upon the office to do what is best for the school from an educational perspective. As we see here, when the paths to this dichotomy of roles diverges, the political pressures tend to force a lose-lose situation for the superintendent.

It is thus that we return to the notion that sometimes it must fall upon the superintendent to take a hard-line stance in the interests of preserving what is best for the course of the educational system. Of course, the requirement for job-preservation and the desire to achieve a consensus amongst members of the school board, the educational community and the general public on how to accomplish this both have the real effect of limiting the options availed to the superintendent.

It is therefore incumbent upon the effective superintendent to outwardly pursue a role that is politically savvy while remaining steadfast in the philosophical approach taken to maintaining and improving the school district or state system. This means that a superintendent must accept the politicization of the position and work hard to engage in open dialogue the various parties with which he must be interactive in order to craft budgetary and curricular standards that might best reflect the desires of the greatest diversity interested parties. Of course, as this effects such topics as the evolution debate, there may be no real way for the superintendent to satisfy the political requirements of the role while remaining true to core educational values. Thus, it falls upon this individual to make a meaningful decision to one end or the other. This might either mean suffering the political consequences of making a correct but unpopular decision or sacrificing one's value system in order to reflect in the schools that which is seen as culturally desirable to the publics thereby served. Much is it the same on the budgetary front, where the superintendent must work the economic and human resources available in order to create a sensible spending plan, and must likewise absorb the lion's share of blame for failing, within these parameters, to satisfy the needs or interests of all parties. To these ends, the position the superintendent of schools is one which is already difficult in professional practice, and is made all the more so by the microscope held over the office's holder.

Still, the superintendent is a very public position, and one upon which many to look to lead the charge in improving educational standards as well as seeing that they reflect the cultural tendencies of their geographical contexts. Thus, there may be some justification, and perhaps even a real social value, to the watchful eye placed upon this important position by teachers, parents, school board members and local politicians, all of whom must seek accountability in ensuring that the future our children is in capable hands.

Works Cited:

AP. (2004). Georgia considers banning 'evolution.' CNN. Online at

Bjork, L.G. & Kowalski, T.J. (2005). The Contemporary Superintendent. Corwin Press.

Danitz, T. (2000). States Confronting School Superintendent Shortage. Stateline. Online at

Edwards, M.E. (2006). The Modern School Superintendent: An Overview of the Role and Responsibilities in the 21st…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited:

AP. (2004). Georgia considers banning 'evolution.' CNN. Online at

Bjork, L.G. & Kowalski, T.J. (2005). The Contemporary Superintendent. Corwin Press.

Danitz, T. (2000). States Confronting School Superintendent Shortage. Stateline. Online at

Edwards, M.E. (2006). The Modern School Superintendent: An Overview of the Role and Responsibilities in the 21st Century. iUniverse, Inc.
Hasan, S. (2001). Politics and Bureaucracy, Not Lack of Funding, Are Chief Irritants for Superintendents and Principals Trying to Stay Ahead of the Game. Public Agenda. Online at
Niles, H. (2009). Front Door Politics: From the State House to Your House. The Wire. Online at
Stanley, J.A. (2009). Classroom Politics. Colorado Springs Independent. Online at

Cite this Document:

"Superintendent Politics The Political Pressures" (2009, May 29) Retrieved November 30, 2021, from

"Superintendent Politics The Political Pressures" 29 May 2009. Web.30 November. 2021. <>

"Superintendent Politics The Political Pressures", 29 May 2009, Accessed.30 November. 2021,

Related Documents
School Finance Its Economics and Politics
Words: 4783 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 94298009

School Finance: Its Economics and Politics School financing in America Revenue sources for federal and state governments Judicial reviews of school finance policy with evolving standards of equality School-based decision making Family choice of schooling Reform of schooling-finance Providing equality in educational opportunities to all is one of the cornerstones of American democracy. The founding fathers of America were aware of the necessity of having a population, which is educated since it enables an opportunity for all

Leadership in International Schools
Words: 29649 Length: 108 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 20990082

Leadership Skills Impact International Education CHALLENGES OF INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION Practical Circumstances of International schools THE IMPORTANCE OF LEADERSHIP IN EDUCATION What is Effective Leadership for Today's Schools? Challenges of Intercultural Communication Challenges of Differing Cultural Values Importance of the Team Leadership Style LEADERSHIP THEORIES Current Leadership Research Transformational Leadership Skills-Authority Contingency Theories APPLYING LEADERSHIP IN AN INTERNATIONAL SETTING Wagner's "Buy-in" vs. Ownership Understanding the Urgent Need for Change Research confirms what teachers, students, parents and superintendents have long known: the individual school is the key unit

School Boards Will Be Obsolete
Words: 3586 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 49396030

While a relative handful in number, the attention given to these districts has caused some to conclude that the nation's 14,350 school boards overall might not be needed or equipped to provide a 21st-century education. School boards, like an old car past its prime, need attention and that the status quo will not suffice for those who want improved student outcomes. Teachers, especially in connection with collective bargaining, have assumed many of

United States Is the Diversity
Words: 5913 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 62722507

Because of the newer mobility of a significant amount of suburban America, driving to national parks was even more an option. The more people visited the Parks, it seemed, the more of a synergistic effect upon their funding and use (Jensen and Guthrie, 2006). By the Johnson Administration in the 1960s, coupled with more media attention, there was increased public awareness of America's natural treasures. This was now that "Parks

Standardized Tests Truly Reflective of
Words: 6649 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 86850476

OCR recognizes that colleges and universities are under a lot of legal and political pressure to stop using racial and ethnic factors in admission," Clegg commented. "[In response,] the agency wants to intimidate colleges and universities to continue using these preferences." (Black Issues in Higher Education, 1999) The National Association of Scholars, while raising doubts about the reasoning behind the OCR document titled "Nondiscrimination in High-Stakes Testing," pointed to what it

Democratic and Republican Parties Have Been Able
Words: 603 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 74051877

Democratic and Republican parties have been able to maintain their strength and their membership numbers since the Civil War for both structural and ideological reasons. The ideological reasons are the most obvious to an observer and to many members of the parties; indeed it is because of the ideological positions of the two parties that people align themselves by party. The ideologies of each party are complex; a better