Violence In College And Professional Research Paper

Length: 9 pages Sources: 9 Subject: Sports Type: Research Paper Paper: #64834206 Related Topics: School Violence, National Football League, Sport Injury, College Sports
Excerpt from Research Paper :

"

Professional sports operates at a higher level than college sports, but these athletes are more likely to face legal action. Dale Hackbart of the Denver Broncos attempted to block Charles Clark of the Cincinnati Bengals during an interception by throwing himself on the ground in front of Hackbart. Hackbart, out of frustration, hit Clark with his right forearm on the back of the neck. The force of the blow was so powerful both men fell to the ground. Three of Clark's vertebrae were broken in the assault.

The United States District Court for the District of Colorado interpreted the incident as an "involuntary reflex," stating,"The violence of professional football is carefully orchestrated. Both offensive and defensive players must be extremely aggressive in their actions, and they must play with reckless abandonment of self-protective instincts." They also pointed out that the only disciplinary actions available in the game were penalties and game expulsion, and that players carry an assumption of risk when they play. In addition, fouls were often missed during the game, since it was played in a noisy, emotionally fueled environment and referees could not see everything each player did. Lastly, it would be pointless to try to apply injury tort law to this case, since charging each player with a duty of care would be impossible. In the end, they concluded that the Bengals were not responsible.

The plaintiff, of course, appealed the decision. The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals had a different point-of-view, stating that there were specific rules in football that prohibited such behavior during play. These rules were put into place to avoid having players intentionally hurt each other. Because of this, football players should be held responsible for injuring an opponent if they are acting with a reckless disregard for safety. They overturned the original decision and the plaintiff was awarded damages.

So what can these incidents teach us about sport law? As with any other area of law, the decisions made by judge and jury can often vary depending on the region, the level of play, and the type of injury sustained. Players who have a history of inappropriate or violent behavior may find themselves in more of a bind than those who are first time offenders. In order to stay on the right side of the law, players must not let their emotions get the better of them; their focus needs to be on the game itself, as opposed to playing to win.

Granted, many fouls and other issues...

...

And many coaches and schools can be so focused on winning that they can easily overlook an elbow in the ribs or a strategically placed foot. However, if a violation takes place and is discovered, players could end up with more than a simple fine or expulsion from a game or two-- they could end up in court.

Even if a lawsuit is brought against a player, team or company, there is no guarantee of winning the case. As pointed out earlier, not all courts will award damages to a plaintiff based on their injuries. Courts must carefully evaluate the incident, the rules of the game, the culture of the sport, and the laws of the land in order to make a fair and unbiased judgment. This can be an extremely difficult task, as can be seen by the number of situations where verdicts have been overturned by higher courts. Sports law makes this easier to do, since its focus is specifically in the area of sports. This avoids confusion between regular civil injury cases and sports injury cases, since there is the assumption of risk when one plays.

Sports law is continually being shaped and changed by the type of incidents and court cases. It is, however, malleable; not only is it attempting to work within the rules of the games within its jurisdiction, it must avoid being at odds with state (and sometimes federal) laws as well. Its goal is to force players to abide by the rules, and to be sure that they are disciplined when they do not.

Fair discipline does not go above and beyond in order to make a point; it successfully sends a message to the player that his or her behavior will not be tolerated. Ideally, the player will then modify his or her behavior, which would send a message to other players who may be considering doing something similar. This method would definitely cut down on the need for retaliatory action on behalf of other players, which should never be part of the game. It would also cut back on the number of frivolous lawsuits, since the line between accident and deliberate action would be much clearer.

Sports law will always affect the rules of the game. It must; in order to stay within the law, rules will change to fit it. However, the purpose of sports law and game rules -- the bottom line -- will always be the safety of the players and the preservation of the game. To that end, sports law will always have a place in society.

"NFL Rules Digest: Summary of Penalties." NFL.com - Official Site of the National Football League. Web. 14 July 2011. .

Sport and Violence: A Critical Examination of Sport. p.4. Butterworth-Heinemann, 2009. Print.

NHL.com -Rules, Official Rules-Rule 48: Illegal Check To The Head. (18 July 2011) http://www.nhl.com/ice/page.htm?id=64063

Robert Crown Law Library, Stanford Law School, Avila Vs. Citrus Community College District. (18 July 2011) http://scocal.stanford.edu/opinion/avila-v-citrus-community-college-dist-33615

SCOCAL, Avila v. Citrus Community College Dist., 38 Cal. 4th 148 available at: (http://scocal.stanford.edu/opinion/avila-v-citrus-community-college-dist-33615) (last visited Tuesday July 19, 2011).

Kavanagh vs. Trustees of Boston University & another. Argued April 8, 2003. -- September 19, 2003. Available at: http:masscases.com/cases/sjc/440/440mass195.html. (last visited Tuesday July 19, 2011).

ROSS BERNSTEIN AND MARTY MCSORLEY. THECODE:THE UNWRITTEN RULES OF FIGHTING AND RETALIATION IN THE NHL, 4

Ibid, p. 206

Hackbart v. Cincinnati Bengals, Inc., 435 F. Supp. 352, 355 (D. Co. 1977), rev'd 601 F.2d 516 (10th Cir. 1979), cert. denied 444 U.S. 931 (1979) (last visited Tuesday July 19, 2011).

Sources Used in Documents:

ROSS BERNSTEIN AND MARTY MCSORLEY. THECODE:THE UNWRITTEN RULES OF FIGHTING AND RETALIATION IN THE NHL, 4

Ibid, p. 206

Hackbart v. Cincinnati Bengals, Inc., 435 F. Supp. 352, 355 (D. Co. 1977), rev'd 601 F.2d 516 (10th Cir. 1979), cert. denied 444 U.S. 931 (1979) (last visited Tuesday July 19, 2011).


Cite this Document:

"Violence In College And Professional" (2011, July 19) Retrieved October 22, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/violence-in-college-and-professional-43413

"Violence In College And Professional" 19 July 2011. Web.22 October. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/violence-in-college-and-professional-43413>

"Violence In College And Professional", 19 July 2011, Accessed.22 October. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/violence-in-college-and-professional-43413

Related Documents
Violence in Pro-Wrestling Does It Cause Violence in Children
Words: 2095 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 96750260

professional wrestling in America today. Specifically, it will include the question: does pro-wrestling cause violence in children? Pro-wrestling is a violent sport, and one of the most popular in America today. Many people in the public and the media question whether pro-wrestling, especially popular with children, causes violent behaviors in them. There are many documented cases of children's violence being caused or aided by actions they saw pro-wrestlers make

Violence Risk Assessment and Serial Homicide
Words: 1846 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 1187931

Violence and Risk Assessment and Serial Homicide The objective of this study is to examine violence risk assessment and the type of tools and their effectiveness for determining violent reoffenders. Lurigio and Harris (2009) reports in the work entitled "Mental Illness, Violence, and Risk Assessment: An Evidence-Based Review" that the link that has been presumed "between violence and mental illness has long been an ongoing subject of investigation." (2009) The question

Violence in Public Schools the Recent Violence
Words: 4632 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 87654295

Violence in Public Schools The recent violence on school grounds (including elementary, middle school and high school violence) has created a climate of fear in American public schools, and the literature presented in this review relates to that fear and to the difficulty schools face in determining what students might be capable of mass killings on campus. Television coverage of school shootings leave the impression that there is more violence on

Violence in the Media and
Words: 2389 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 71281500

The industry knowingly takes advantage of this recent cultural shift in parent-child relationships. And finally, the industry knows that children and youngsters are more likely to be influenced by violent movies, TV shows, and games and are more likely to get addicted to violent imagery, becoming potential customers for future media products and games that glorify violence (Mean world syndrome, 2009). It is fair, therefore, to say that bombardment

Violence and Victims Journal: "Violence and Victims"
Words: 2270 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 65907596

Violence and Victims Journal: "Violence and Victims" by Springer Publishing Company Violence and Victims is a social work journal that informs "clinical decisions, legal actions and public policy" (Springer Publishing, 2011). It is a peer-reviewed journal that includes subject matter on "theory, research, policy, and clinical practice in the area of interpersonal violence and victimization" across a myriad of professional disciplines to the likes of medicine, law, sociology, psychology and social work

Violence Against Children
Words: 3060 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 49177108

Violence Against Children The structure of violence as related to children directly correlates to their perceived socio-demographic risk. Several factors directly relate to the likelihood that a child will be subjected to violence at some point during their lives. Social, economic, demographic and physical factors all have a dramatic impact a child's development, either positive or negative and these factors also influence whether or not a child is more or less