Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,728 words

American National Character in Early American Literature

~9 min read 6 sections Literature · American Literature
Abstract

This essay examines the formation of the American national character as reflected in four key early American literary works: Crèvecoeur's "Letters from an American Farmer," Benjamin Franklin's "Autobiography," Samson Occom's narrative, and Olaudah Equiano's "Narrative." The paper argues that, unlike European societies structured by hereditary class and title, early American identity was shaped by more fluid markers such as labor, wealth, religious conversion, and race. By reading these texts together, the essay reveals the contradictions at the heart of American self-definition—a nation simultaneously promoting individual reinvention and enforcing rigid racial hierarchies that denied freedom and status to enslaved and indigenous people.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: The Uncertain American Identity: America's unclear collective identity in its early years
  • Crèvecoeur and the Plurality of the American Social Fabric: Crèvecoeur's outsider view of American pluralism and character
  • Benjamin Franklin and the Self-Made American: Franklin's autobiography as a template for American identity
  • Samson Occom and the Complexity of Religious Identity: Occom's narrative between Native identity and Christianity
  • Olaudah Equiano and the Limits of American Freedom: Equiano's enslavement and the failure of American promise
  • Race, Status, and the Contradictions of Early America: Race as an immovable barrier in a supposedly fluid society
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper reads four distinct primary sources together, allowing their contrasts and tensions to drive the argument rather than treating each work in isolation.
  • It grounds abstract claims about national identity in specific quoted passages, giving the analysis textual authority.
  • The essay moves logically from the most privileged narrator (Franklin) toward the most dispossessed (Equiano), building an increasingly critical picture of American idealism.

Key academic technique demonstrated

Comparative close reading: the paper places primary texts in direct conversation, using Franklin's confident self-fashioning as a foil against which Occom's marginalization and Equiano's enslavement are measured. This technique shows how a single ideological claim—that America rewards hard work—is validated for some and violently denied to others.

Structure breakdown

The essay opens with a framing question about American uniqueness, introduces Crèvecoeur's outsider perspective on pluralism, moves to Franklin's archetypal self-made narrative, briefly treats Occom as a transitional figure between acceptance and exclusion, then centers Equiano's narrative as a counter-testimony to Franklinian optimism. The conclusion synthesizes the tension between social mobility and racial rigidity.

Essay 1,728 words

Introduction: The Uncertain American Identity

What is so unique about America? During the early years of this country's existence, America was still a colonial nation with an unclear identity as a collective entity. Was it a mass of individualistic states, or was it a unique system of values and rights, as eventually embodied in the American Constitution? It began originally as a conglomerate of individuals seeking religious freedom and, in some cases, criminals seeking to establish a new life. But the nation gradually evolved into a more clearly defined social network, with its own hierarchies of status.

Unlike the hereditary hierarchies of Europe, however, the social networks generated by these individuals—"afflicted by miseries," in Crèvecoeur's phrase—were, by definition of the American character, far more shallowly rooted in emotional and practical ties to hereditary wealth, inherited land, and noble title. Other factors of social significance came to the forefront in determining American identity and social status: hard work, hard-won money, and, equally significantly if not quite as positively, the visible status markers of race and freedom.

5 Sections Hidden · 1,080 words
Crèvecoeur and the Plurality of the American Social Fabric310 words
Letters from an American Farmer is a unique snapshot of the early nation because its author lived and toiled on the land of America, yet had been transplanted from another country. It is unclear whether Crèvecoeur ever became a naturalized citizen; regardless,…
Benjamin Franklin and the Self-Made American320 words
The most famous of these autobiographies is, of course, Benjamin Franklin's Autobiography. Franklin is first and foremost thought of as a founding father…
Samson Occom and the Complexity of Religious Identity120 words
Although Franklin pays lip service to the significance of God and Providence in his success, he ultimately credits his own ingenuity. This may be contrasted with the Native American convert Samson Occom,…
Olaudah Equiano and the Limits of American Freedom200 words
Race, in the absence of class and heredity, was another marker of status—and usually not a positive one. This is particularly evident in the experience of enslaved Black people.…
Race, Status, and the Contradictions of Early America130 words
Status was more fungible and mutable in the new America—it could be changed by gaining money, like Franklin, or land, like the author of the Letters from an American Farmer. Yet certain statuses, such as race, could not be concealed. Christian…

Works Cited

Franklin, Benjamin. The Autobiography. Accessed December 2, 2003. The Early American Website.

Equiano, Olaudah. Narrative and "West Indies Slavery" Essay. Accessed December 2, 2003. http://www.wsu.edu:8000/~dee/Equiano.html.

"Letters from an American Farmer." Letter 3 and Commentary.

Occom, Samson. "Story and Biography." Commentary and Text. Accessed December 2, 2003. The Early American Website.

Key Concepts in This Paper
National Identity Self-Fashioning Racial Hierarchy Social Mobility Autobiography Colonial America Religious Conversion American Pluralism Slavery Hard Work
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). American National Character in Early American Literature. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/american-national-character-early-literature-157959

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.