Ethical Dilemmas: Aquinas and Augustine on Workplace Morality
This paper examines two everyday ethical dilemmas through the lenses of Thomas Aquinas and Augustine of Hippo. The first scenario involves an office worker whose chronic absenteeism harms his colleagues despite his technical entitlement to the time off; the second involves a woman who suppresses her moral instincts and participates in workplace gossip. Drawing on Aquinas's Summa Theologica and Augustine's City of God and Confessions, the paper categorizes each behavior as either a sin of omission or commission, and considers how both theologians would assess the moral failure involved. Together, the cases illustrate how classical Christian ethical frameworks apply to ordinary, modern workplace situations.
- Introduction to the Ethical Dilemmas: Overview of two workplace moral scenarios
- The Absentee Worker: Entitlement Versus Obligation: Aquinas and Augustine on chronic absenteeism
- Gossip and the Betrayal of Moral Instinct: Free will, gossip, and sins of commission
- Conclusion: Classical Ethics in Everyday Life: Classical ethics applied to modern workplace choices
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It applies classical theological frameworks — Aquinas's distinction between sins of omission and commission, and Augustine's concept of the will turning away from good — to relatable, contemporary workplace situations, making abstract moral philosophy concrete and accessible.
- The paper carefully distinguishes between technical entitlement and moral obligation, showing that legality and ethics are not the same, which is a nuanced analytical move.
- Direct quotation from primary sources (Summa Theologica, City of God, Confessions) is used precisely and purposefully, with each citation tied directly to the scenario being analyzed.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative application of multiple theoretical frameworks to the same type of problem. Rather than simply summarizing what Aquinas or Augustine believed, it shows how each thinker would assess the same moral situation differently, highlighting their distinct emphases — Aquinas on moral precept and duty, Augustine on the corrupting role of the will and deprivation of good. This comparative method is a hallmark of rigorous philosophy and ethics writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized as a group response to two distinct scenario prompts. Each scenario receives its own paragraph of analysis that introduces the moral tension, applies Aquinas's framework, then applies Augustine's framework, and synthesizes both. The conclusion of each section broadens outward to a general moral observation, grounding the specific case in universal ethical principles. Citations are minimal but correctly formatted and traceable to primary texts.
Introduction to the Ethical Dilemmas
The following scenarios present two common workplace ethical dilemmas, each analyzed through the moral frameworks of Thomas Aquinas and Augustine of Hippo. Both cases involve individuals who must choose between personal convenience and their moral obligations to others.
References
Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologica, I-II q. 72.
Augustine. City of God, XII, Chapter 6.
Augustine. Confessions, VII: [XII] 18.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.