Egoism and Utilitarianism in Workplace Ethics: A Case Study
This paper applies two foundational ethical theories — egoism and utilitarianism — to a series of workplace moral dilemmas. Using Shaw and Barry's framework from Moral Issues in Business, the paper evaluates whether a CEO acts ethically by allowing employees to choose whether to work overtime in dangerous areas, and whether employees should be permitted to forgo protective equipment. The analysis considers both the advantages and disadvantages of each theory before extending the discussion to whether the conclusions change when the worker in question is pregnant or of child-bearing age. The paper concludes that individual autonomy is best preserved in the overtime decision, while collective safety concerns make the protective equipment decision an ethical obligation rather than a personal choice.
- Introduction: The CEO's Moral Framework: CEO grants workers moral autonomy over risk decisions
- Overtime in Dangerous Areas: An Egoism Analysis: Egoism supports individual choice on dangerous overtime
- Protective Equipment: A Utilitarianism Analysis: Utilitarianism argues mandatory protective equipment serves collective good
- Impact of Pregnancy on Ethical Positions: Pregnancy does not alter the core ethical conclusions
- Impact of Child-Bearing Age on Ethical Positions: Child-bearing age similarly leaves ethical positions unchanged
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Each scenario is answered with a clearly stated position, followed by a specific ethical theory applied to justify that position — making the argument easy to follow and evaluate.
- The paper consistently pairs each theory with both an advantage and a disadvantage, demonstrating awareness of theoretical limitations rather than one-sided advocacy.
- The extension to gender-related scenarios (pregnancy and child-bearing age) shows the student can apply the same analytical framework across variations of a problem without abandoning consistency.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied ethical reasoning — the ability to select an appropriate normative theory (egoism or utilitarianism) and map its logic onto a concrete workplace scenario. Rather than defining theories in the abstract, the student uses them as analytical tools, showing how each theory produces a specific verdict in a specific context.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized as a numbered case study with four discrete questions. The first two sections address distinct ethical dilemmas using different theories. The final two sections revisit those positions under modified conditions (pregnancy and child-bearing age), testing the robustness of the earlier conclusions. Each section follows a consistent pattern: position statement, theory application, advantages and disadvantages, and final verdict.
Introduction: The CEO's Moral Framework
This case study examines a series of workplace ethical dilemmas in which a CEO, acting on moral grounds, grants employees varying degrees of autonomy over decisions involving personal risk. Two ethical theories — egoism and utilitarianism — are applied to evaluate whether the CEO's positions are ethically sound. The analysis also considers whether those conclusions shift when the worker in question is pregnant or of child-bearing age.
References
Shaw, W. H., & Barry, V. (2007). Moral issues in business (10th ed.). Thomson Wadsworth.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.