This paper compares two landmark episodes of popular revolt in French history: the 1789 storming of the Bastille that ignited the French Revolution, and the 1871 Paris Commune. The paper examines who participated in each uprising, the demands the insurgents made, and how the existing governments responded. In both cases, Parisian workers and segments of the military united against entrenched authority, yet both movements ultimately ended in violent suppression. The paper concludes by drawing broader lessons about how revolutionary idealism can give rise to new systems of control, and reflects on parallels to contemporary political challenges.
Two of the most significant episodes of popular revolt in French history — the 1789 storming of the Bastille and the 1871 Paris Commune — share striking similarities in their participants, motivations, and ultimate fates. Comparing these events reveals enduring patterns in the relationship between popular idealism and political power.
On March 26, 1871, a combination of French workers and military members, opposed to a German occupation following France's defeat in the Franco-Prussian War, revolted and were elected to form a municipal council known as the Paris Commune. The Commune acted as the city's government for approximately two months.
At the end of May, a powerful French military force swept into Paris and ended the Commune by slaughtering approximately 30,000 unarmed workers and exiling 7,000 more. What had begun as a bold experiment in self-governance concluded in one of the bloodiest episodes of repression in French history.
On July 14, 1789, the common population of Paris overwhelmed and captured the Bastille — a well-known and deeply hated prison that stood as a symbol of royal authority and oppression. The assault marked the beginning of the French Revolution. The vast crowd of revolutionaries included several thousand women, reflecting broad popular participation across social lines.
In the end, however, the revolution consumed itself. During the Reign of Terror, the new revolutionary government guillotined tens of thousands of people who disagreed with its direction, demonstrating how swiftly liberating movements can turn authoritarian.
In both the Paris Commune and the French Revolution, it was the commoners of Paris — the workers — who revolted. In both cases, segments of the military also joined the people's cause.
During the Commune, soldiers and workers together formed the municipal council that governed the city. During the storming of the Bastille, the French Guards joined with the people to capture Paris after the fortress fell.
In both instances, the opposing force was the existing government or monarchy. During the Paris Commune, the French Government of National Defense — still reeling from the Franco-Prussian War — opposed the workers of Paris. During the French Revolution, it was King Louis XVI and his government that stood against the commoners, until the king was executed in January 1793.
"Self-governance, rights, and democratic reform"
"Idealism, new control systems, and modern parallels"
You’re 54% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.