Death of a Salesman as Tragedy: Aristotle's Framework
This paper analyzes Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman as a modern tragedy, examining whether the play fulfills Aristotle's classical definition of tragic drama. The paper provides an overview of the play's plot, characters, and central obstacles before applying Aristotle's criteria — including the fall of a flawed but essentially good man, the arousal of pity and fear, and catharsis — to Willy Loman and his family. It also surveys critical debate over the play's tragic status, considers Harold Bloom's influential readings, and concludes that the Loman family's collective inability to adapt, grow, or escape failure makes the play a tragedy of enduring relevance.
- Overview of the Play and Miller's Legacy: Production history, awards, and Miller's own ambivalence
- The Loman Family: Characters and Their Failings: Willy, Linda, Biff, and Hap as tragic figures
- Obstacles and Foreshadowing of Doom: Characters' obstacles and death's foreshadowing in the title
- Aristotle's Definition and the Case for Tragedy: Play measured against Aristotle's definition of tragedy
- Critical Debate: Arguments For and Against: Critics dispute whether Loman qualifies as tragic hero
- Harold Bloom and the Question of Epiphany: Bloom on Loman's near-epiphany and unresolved questions
- Conclusion: A Tragedy of Wasted Lives: Loman died in vain, burdening family with his failure
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds literary analysis in a clear theoretical framework — Aristotle's definition of tragedy — and consistently returns to it when evaluating characters and plot events.
- It presents multiple critical perspectives, including dissenting voices who dispute the play's tragic status, which gives the argument balance and intellectual honesty.
- Direct quotations from the play itself, alongside scholarly commentary from critics such as Harold Bloom and Terry Otten, are integrated smoothly to support each analytical point.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates definition-driven literary analysis: it establishes a formal criterion (Aristotle's definition), then systematically tests each element of that criterion against evidence from the text. This technique — state the standard, apply it, evaluate the fit — is a reliable model for any comparative or evaluative literary essay.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief thesis, then provides context about the play's production history and Miller's biography. It introduces the major characters and the obstacles they face before turning to Aristotle's definition and the pro/con critical debate. It then engages Harold Bloom's nuanced reading of Loman's near-epiphany and closes with a restatement of the thesis supported by a final critical quotation. The structure moves logically from context, through analysis, to evaluative conclusion.
Overview of the Play and Miller's Legacy
Death of a Salesman is a tragedy of epic proportions. The drama is tragic not only because of Willy Loman's suicide, but because he has left his family with nothing, and his sons with no hopes or abilities of their own.
Arthur Miller wrote Death of a Salesman in 1948, and it premiered on Broadway in February of 1949. Critics Susan C.W. Abbotson and Brenda Murphy note that the play was an immediate dramatic success. They write, "Salesman ran for an extraordinary 742 performances on Broadway, winning the Pulitzer Prize, the Donaldson Award, and the New York Drama Critics Circle Award for best play of the season" (Murphy and Abbotson xiii). The play has continued its popularity to the present day and is often studied in classrooms and reading groups. Many people believe it is the quintessential story of the quest for the American Dream and all that represents in modern society, but it is also a modern-day tragedy, rooted in a long tradition of tragic drama that began with the Greek playwrights and the writings of Aristotle. Death of a Salesman is not Miller's only work — he had many other successes — but it is one of his finest and endures even after the author's death.
Miller is widely regarded as one of America's premier playwrights. He was often hesitant to categorize the play as a pure tragedy. Late in his life he described it succinctly, saying, "Well, it's about a salesman and he dies. What can I tell you?" (Otten 281). However, Miller's play is much more than that. It is the story of a family falling apart and a father who is unable to grow and change with the times — the story of three weak men, with only one showing any promise for the future. Loman has passed on a legacy of failure to his sons, and it seems they will not be able to accomplish much more than their father has managed with his own life. It is a sad and haunting story, and the family is tragic in its own right, but that is not the only element that creates tragedy here. The real tragedy is that the Lomans are hemmed in by modern life, just as their growing Brooklyn neighborhood has physically hemmed them in. All of them are unable to adapt to changing times and changing needs, and the entire family is tragic because it is trapped in something of a time-warp. They are passé and no longer necessary, and Loman cannot deal with being past his prime and unable to provide for his family.
The Loman Family: Characters and Their Failings
The main characters in the play are the Loman family: Willy, the father and the salesman; Linda, his wife; and Biff and Hap, his two sons. There are other characters as well, including Willy's boss, some more successful friends, and even a vague "Woman" — the mistress Willy kept as he traveled during his more prosperous years. Most of the minor characters are more successful than Willy, and they serve as a contrast to his gradual decline. They are prosperous because they are adaptable, and they make Willy look all the more sad and pathetic by comparison. Willy cannot face reality or improve himself through an honest reckoning with his shortcomings, and that is another aspect of the play that is tragic.
Willy does not have to die at the end, but because he cannot adapt, he sees death as his only hope and his only choice. Sadly, suicide leaves behind the pieces — Linda and the boys — unable to make their own decisions and left adrift by their dependence on Willy. The story is sad, but it is also tragic because Willy continually makes the wrong choices and cannot admit that, even to himself.
References
Adamczewski, Zygmunt. The Tragic Protest. The Hague: M. Nijhoff, 1963.
Amsden, Robert. "Aristotle's Definition of Tragedy." Ripon College. 2002.
Bloom, Harold. Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea House, 1988.
Miller, Arthur. "Death of a Salesman." Masters of Modern Drama. Ed. Haskell M. Block and Robert G. Shedd. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1962. 1020–1054.
Murphy, Brenda, and Susan C.W. Abbotson. Understanding Death of a Salesman: A Student Casebook to Issues, Sources, and Historical Documents. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1999.
Otten, Terry. "Death of a Salesman at Fifty — Still 'Coming Home to Roost.'" Texas Studies in Literature and Language 41.3 (1999): 280–310.
Phelps, H.C. "Miller's Death of a Salesman." Explicator 53.4 (1995): 239–240.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.