Equity, Diversity, and Accountability in American Education
This paper reviews Bensimon, Polkinghorne, and Bauman's article "The Accountability Side of Diversity," which examines how accountability systems can promote equitable education for diverse student populations. The review focuses on the Diversity Scorecard, a project piloted at several Los Angeles-area colleges that sought not merely to measure diversity but to ensure equal access to educational options and outcomes for students of varied racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic backgrounds. The paper evaluates the article's argument that American universities have not sufficiently adapted their curricula to serve diverse student bodies, and assesses the broader significance of linking institutional accountability to diversity outcomes.
- Introduction: The Problem of Educational Equity: Overview of equity challenges in American public education
- The Diversity Scorecard: An Accountability Framework: Description of the LA-area Diversity Scorecard project
- Critiquing the Curriculum Gap: Evaluation of universities' failure to adapt curricula
- Significance and Broader Implications: Article's contribution to accountability and diversity research
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly identifies the central argument of the article under review and situates it within the broader context of American educational policy.
- It maintains a consistent evaluative stance, offering measured praise for the article's contribution while grounding that praise in specific claims about the Diversity Scorecard project.
- The review moves logically from description to analysis to broader significance, giving it a coherent argumentative shape despite its brevity.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates concise critical summarization — a skill central to academic writing at all levels. The writer accurately represents the source article's hypothesis, methodology (the Diversity Scorecard), and conclusions, then offers a brief but clear evaluative judgment. This technique requires the writer to distinguish between what an article claims and what it achieves, a distinction that is well handled here.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a statement of the broader educational problem before introducing the specific article and its hypothesis. The second paragraph narrows the focus to the Diversity Scorecard project and its operational logic. The third paragraph broadens again to evaluate the article's significance, concluding that it makes a timely contribution to an underexplored area of accountability research. The structure follows a classic funnel-and-reverse-funnel pattern appropriate for a short critical review.
Introduction: The Problem of Educational Equity
One of the biggest problems facing the American educational system is equity with regard to a diverse student body, and how public schools should be held accountable for providing a quality education to all students. Bensimon, Polkinghorne, and Bauman's article "The Accountability Side of Diversity" examines the relevance and effectiveness of an accountability system designed to measure schools' responses to diversity. The hypothesis is that such an accountability system, while difficult to design and implement, would promote equitable education for American students. This research, and the article based on it, is optimistic, encouraging, and should help American educational institutions pay greater attention to their treatment of minority students.
The Diversity Scorecard: An Accountability Framework
This article largely describes the "Diversity Scorecard," a project of educational accountability piloted at several Los Angeles-area colleges. As the authors state, the Diversity Scorecard was designed not to promote diversity — for these schools' student bodies were already diverse — but to ensure that all students have access to the same educational options and outcomes. The underlying assumption is that American universities, even those that boast student bodies as diverse as those found in urban centers like Los Angeles, may not have altered their curriculum sufficiently to enhance the education of people from various racial and ethnic backgrounds.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.