Ethical Egoism and the Case for Legal Euthanasia
This paper examines the morality of euthanasia through the lens of Ethical Egoism, arguing that individuals have the moral right to make end-of-life decisions for themselves. Beginning with the real-world case of actor Richard Farnsworth, who took his own life rather than endure terminal cancer, the paper explains Ethical Egoism and contrasts it with deontological, utilitarian, and virtue-based frameworks. It then addresses the principal objection to euthanasia—that the Hippocratic Oath forbids physician-assisted death—and rebuts it by characterizing such prohibitions as legal moralism that denies individual autonomy. The paper concludes that laws restricting euthanasia force people into undignified deaths, and that Ethical Egoism provides the most coherent justification for legalizing the practice.
- Introduction: Farnsworth case introduces euthanasia thesis
- What Is Ethical Egoism?: Defines Ethical Egoism against rival frameworks
- Ethical Egoism Applied to Euthanasia: Theory applied to Farnsworth and California law
- Objection: The Hippocratic Oath and Legal Moralism: Rebuttal of oath objection via Animal Farm analogy
- Conclusion: Synthesizes argument, returns to Farnsworth case
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Opens with a compelling, humanizing real-world case (Richard Farnsworth) that anchors the abstract ethical argument in lived experience, immediately engaging the reader.
- Clearly defines Ethical Egoism and situates it against competing frameworks (deontology, utilitarianism, virtue ethics), giving readers enough context to follow the comparative argument.
- Employs a classic objection-rebuttal structure, anticipating the strongest counterargument and directly responding to it, which demonstrates argumentative balance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the use of a sustained applied-ethics framework: rather than surveying multiple theories neutrally, it selects one (Ethical Egoism), defines it rigorously, and applies it consistently to a single real-world policy question. This "framework-first, application-second" approach is a model technique for undergraduate ethics essays, as it forces the writer to remain logically consistent throughout.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a five-part structure: (1) an introduction that presents the thesis and the Farnsworth case; (2) a definition and explanation of Ethical Egoism compared to rival theories; (3) a direct application of the theory to the euthanasia debate, including relevant California legislation; (4) a formal objection-and-rebuttal section addressing the Hippocratic Oath, supported by a literary analogy from Animal Farm; and (5) a conclusion that synthesizes the argument and returns to the Farnsworth example. The symmetrical opening and closing on the same case gives the paper a cohesive, unified feel.
Introduction
In 2000, veteran actor Richard Farnsworth, at the age of 80, took his own life rather than allow cancer to consume his final days and force him to become a burden to his family (AP). The news was shocking to some fans of the beloved series Anne of Green Gables, in which Farnsworth had starred as the surrogate father to the eponymous heroine. But others, like comedian Norm Macdonald, lauded the star, saying it was noble of him to make that decision for himself and for his family, regardless of what critics thought (Smith).
Opponents of euthanasia — which is, in most states, the illegal practice of doctor-assisted suicide — claim that it is immoral and unjustified from an ethical perspective, leading people like Farnsworth to take drastic measures to end their lives. Opponents argue that suicide is never justified, and they draw upon various ethical perspectives — from virtue ethics to deontology to utilitarianism — to support their claims. But from the standpoint of Ethical Egoism, which appeals to many in today's relativistic world, suicide can be seen as a logical act that makes sense for some, such as those in Farnsworth's position.
It is the thesis of this paper that, from the standpoint of Ethical Egoism, euthanasia should be legal and available to those who seek that option for themselves. This paper will support this thesis by explaining Ethical Egoism, considering the most common objection to this ethical theory, and rebutting that objection using a concrete illustration.
Works Cited
AP. "Actor Richard Farnsworth Kills Himself." Los Angeles Times, 2000. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2000-oct-07-mn-32851-story.html
Holmes, A. Ethics: Approaching Moral Decisions. InterVarsity Press, 2007.
Neuman, Scott. "Judge Overturns Assisted Suicide Law in California." NPR, 2018. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/05/16/611527757/judge-overturns-assisted-suicide-law-in-california
Smith, Kyle. "Why Norm Macdonald Didn't Discuss His Terminal Cancer." National Review, 2021. https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/why-norm-macdonald-didnt-discuss-his-terminal-cancer/
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.