Feminist Themes in "Day Star" and "Paper Matches"
This paper examines the feminist themes present in Rita Dove's "Day Star" and Paulette Jiles's "Paper Matches," arguing that both poems critique the oppression embedded in traditional gender roles and the institution of motherhood. Through close reading of imagery, language, and symbolism, the analysis shows how each poem conveys female entrapment, resentment, and the limited possibilities for liberation. The paper also reflects on the broader value of literary study as a means of understanding historical context, social class, gender dynamics, and the evolution of collective cultural identity across time periods.
- Introduction: Oppression and Identity in 'Day Star': Dove's poem frames motherhood as identity suppression
- Motherhood and Resentment in 'Day Star': Imagery conveys disdain for domestic roles
- Feminist Symbolism in 'Paper Matches': Jiles uses fire symbolism for female entrapment
- Critiquing Social Myths of Motherhood and Marriage: Both poets challenge romantic and maternal ideals
- Institutionalization of Gender Norms: Gender roles portrayed as socially enforced and inescapable
- Literature as a Window into Social Reality: Literary study reveals historical and social truths
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its feminist argument in specific textual evidence, quoting directly from both poems to support each analytical claim rather than relying on vague generalization.
- It draws meaningful comparative connections between two distinct poems, identifying shared themes—entrapment, resentment, and inward rebellion—while acknowledging differences in approach (literal versus symbolic).
- The concluding section broadens the discussion to make an argument about the value of literary study itself, giving the paper a reflective dimension that elevates it beyond pure close reading.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies comparative literary analysis: it places two poems in dialogue with each other, identifying a shared thematic framework (feminist critique of gender roles) and then tracing how each poet achieves similar effects through different stylistic means. This technique requires the writer to move fluidly between texts while maintaining a unified argumentative thread.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a close reading of "Day Star," establishing the central feminist argument. It then introduces "Paper Matches" as a parallel case, before widening the lens to compare both poems' treatment of social myth and institutionalized gender norms. The final section pivots to a broader reflection on why literary study matters for understanding historical and social reality, functioning as a concluding framework rather than a summary.
Introduction: Oppression and Identity in 'Day Star'
Rita Dove's "Day Star" details the oppression of motherhood and the submission of personal identity to the role of housewife. Dove describes a mother whose spirit and creativity are thoroughly thwarted by her domestic circumstances. She wants only "a little room for thinking," yet her constant chores and household obligations barely afford her an hour of time for herself. The protagonist steals moments during her children's nap time, hiding in the garage and looking out at simple things like "the pinched armor of a vanished cricket" or a "floating maple leaf." Sometimes she simply closes her eyes, but when she does, she sees "her own vivid blood." The morbid imagery, coupled with overt language of oppression, promotes the feminist ideals of liberation from traditional gender roles.
Motherhood and Resentment in 'Day Star'
Motherhood is described with an almost shocking derision, which has the feminist effect of liberating the speaker through the frank admission that the role is not all it is made out to be. Diapers "steaming on the line" suggest that motherhood and housewifery can amount to a pile of stinking misery. Even sexuality is described in negative terms, as Thomas "rolled over and lurched into her." She escapes the moment by fantasizing about the brief peace she cultivates during her only time alone each day.
The negative attitude the mother holds toward her role is liberating in itself. Because it is socially unacceptable to reject motherhood, the protagonist's honesty — her willingness to express anger and resentment at a role that many women claim is the highlight of their lives — becomes a quiet act of defiance.
Feminist Symbolism in 'Paper Matches'
In "Paper Matches," Paulette Jiles conveys the same feminist theme as Dove. The anger and resentment that characterize entrapment in traditional gender roles are symbolized by a match: "We come bearing supper, / our heads on fire." Dove's poem is far more literal, but both achieve the same goal of women sharing a common identity within oppression. Neither poet offers any solution beyond the acknowledgment of anger. Hope is absent, as the females in both poems are stuck and imprisoned in their roles, which suggests that the problem is institutionalized.
Women do not have the option to break free from their roles, because their efforts would be met with ridicule. In "Paper Matches," for example, Aunt Hetty states flatly, "That's the way it is." The mother in "Day Star" would not want the ethical burden of abandoning her children, even if she resents being trapped by having to care for them without the help of her husband.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.