This paper examines gender roles and the division of labor within two households through interviews with a stay-at-home mother and a working mother. Both women manage comparable domestic responsibilities while raising young children, yet their experiences of autonomy, financial control, and decision-making power differ significantly. The stay-at-home mother, though conforming more closely to traditional gender role expectations, exercises greater control over household finances and major family decisions. The working mother, despite a seemingly more equitable division of labor, reports less financial autonomy and more shared — sometimes compromised — decision-making. The paper concludes that the relationship between gender role conformity and domestic power is more nuanced than stereotypes suggest.
To help understand the role that women play in the family unit, two women were interviewed. The first, a stay-at-home mother, has two young children. The second, a mother who works outside the home as a teacher, also raises two small children. Both women have considerable household obligations, but the division of labor in their households differs substantially.
During the interviews, the aim was to determine the source of that difference and what the varying gender roles in those families reveal about gender roles in society at large. It must first be noted that both women were responsible for all the chores one normally associates with running a household. Both did the grocery shopping, major housekeeping, gift purchasing, laundry, clothes shopping, and food preparation. All of the children were involved in activities requiring scheduling and carpooling, and both mothers were fully responsible for ensuring the children arrived on time with all necessary equipment. In both households, therefore, the women were fully in charge of what is normally considered the domestic sphere.
The similarities between the two households were, however, mainly superficial. In the stay-at-home mother's household, she was responsible not only for the domestic sphere but for everything else related to the home as well. Home repairs, yard work, all errands, automobile maintenance, and paying the bills all fell within the scope of her duties. Her husband works as an attorney and they both want him to eventually make partner; she therefore supports his efforts to work approximately 80 hours each week. She also recognizes that his work provides the family with a degree of financial freedom — she can hire people to maintain the yard, arrange routine home repairs, and schedule automobile maintenance without concern for cost.
Her stated goal is to ensure that her husband's time at home is peaceful and free of chores, so that he can spend as much quality time with the family as possible. However, the 80-hour workweek means she is working at least that many hours herself and is practically a single parent during the week. To sustain her own wellbeing, she hires a babysitter every other Wednesday to attend either a book club meeting or a girls' night out. Because her neighborhood has few other stay-at-home mothers, she has also joined an organization called the MOMS Club, which provides support and companionship for at-home parents.
Conscious that being a stay-at-home mother places her in a financially dependent position, she has ensured that she controls all of the family's finances and maintains a substantial separate savings account. Her husband's inability to participate in daily household life means that she effectively makes all major decisions: she selected their home without his input, researched and purchased both of their automobiles, and plans all of their family vacations and holidays.
"Working mother's labor division and financial compromises"
"Counterintuitive link between gender conformity and household power"
You’re 57% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.