History of Quarantine in the United States: Origins to Modern Day
This paper traces the history of quarantine in the United States from its biblical and medieval origins through the colonial era, the establishment of federal quarantine law, and into the twentieth century. It examines landmark events including the founding of quarantine stations in New York and Philadelphia, the case of Typhoid Mary, the 1918 venereal disease quarantines, and the transfer of quarantine authority to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The paper also addresses the shortcomings of quarantine as a public health tool, including civil liberties concerns, limited effectiveness, and documented abuses, concluding with a survey of the modern federal quarantine framework managed by the CDC's Division of Global Migration and Quarantine.
- Introduction: The Apollo Quarantine and the Meaning of Isolation: Apollo astronaut quarantine introduces the concept
- Definition and Origins of Quarantine: Etymology, biblical roots, and medieval ship quarantine
- History of Quarantine in the United States: Colonial laws through nineteenth-century epidemic responses
- The Rise of Federal Quarantine Authority: National quarantine acts and bacteriology era
- Typhoid Mary and Civil Liberties Controversies: Typhoid Mary case and polio and venereal disease quarantines
- The Modern Quarantine Framework: CDC authority, SARS response, and current structure
- Shortcomings of Quarantine: Civil liberties, effectiveness limits, and documented abuses
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Chronological organization gives the reader a clear narrative arc from ancient practice through modern federal policy, making complex legal and epidemiological history accessible.
- The paper balances descriptive history with critical analysis, dedicating a full section to the civil liberties and effectiveness shortcomings of quarantine rather than treating the practice as purely beneficial.
- Concrete case studies — the Apollo 11 astronaut quarantine, the Philadelphia Lazaretto, Typhoid Mary, and the SARS response — ground abstract policy history in vivid, specific events.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of historical case analysis to build a policy argument. By presenting individual quarantine episodes in chronological sequence and then evaluating them critically in the "Shortcomings" section, the author shows how empirical history can support a nuanced normative conclusion — that quarantine is necessary but prone to abuse and limited in effectiveness.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with the unusual Apollo astronaut quarantine to engage the reader, then provides a formal definition and etymology of quarantine before moving into a chronological US history. It transitions from colonial law through nineteenth-century epidemics, federal legislation, and landmark cases, before closing with an evaluative section on quarantine's disadvantages and a brief conclusion affirming its continued necessity.
Introduction: The Apollo Quarantine and the Meaning of Isolation
In 1966, during the summer, the U.S. Congress closed debate and passed approval for the construction of a laboratory that would be used to confine the astronauts and the materials they brought back from the moon. Congress approved NASA's budget for the project in 1966, and the laboratory was completed in September 1967. This was a major step forward in the history of the American quarantine system. The center was named the Lunar Receiving Laboratory (LRL), located at the Lyndon B. Johnson Space Center. The project arose from fear of back-contamination from the astronauts and the material they carried from the moon.
The process was straightforward. After the crews of Apollo 11, 12, and 13 were recovered from the sea upon landing, they were taken directly from the helicopter to a waiting isolation vehicle on the aircraft carrier deck and flown to the LRL for isolation.
This isolation of the astronauts was viewed as a preventive measure against any potential danger or incidental contamination. It was not carried out upon confirmation of any assured back-contamination from the moon. In fact, in all three Apollo quarantine cases, no serious threats were detected, and the astronauts were released to continue with their daily lives. The principle behind the quarantine was, and remains, more important than the findings that followed.
Definition and Origins of Quarantine
Quarantine is a voluntary or compelled isolation, ordinarily used to control the spread of an infection or disease deemed lethal to a population. The disease may be considered sufficiently contagious to warrant isolation. Isolation periods range from very short — as in cases of anthrax exposure, where a victim can leave as soon as contaminated clothing is removed and a decontamination shower taken — to considerably longer periods while laboratory results are awaited. Quarantine has undergone massive advancements and today encompasses quarantine ambulances, mobile dispensaries, hospitals, and full lockdowns.
The word quarantine originates from the Italian quarantena, quaranta dei, or quaranta giorni, all of which literally mean a forty-day period. This forty-day period was historically observed when ships arrived at the dock of another country and there was suspicion that they came from an area with active plague. These days were considered sufficient for the authorities to confirm that none of those aboard was infected. Though this method was not watertight — since fleas, rats, and cockroaches could still carry plague into the new country — the practice of quarantine continued. The mass holding of people offshore for forty days continued for quite a long time, until the mid-twentieth century, when antibiotics were discovered and vaccinations were offered to visitors in place of wholesale detention.
Quarantine has been practiced since biblical times. In the Old Testament, there is clear evidence of lepers being isolated from the rest of society. The laws governing the "unclean" were designed to protect others from contagion. Lepers were placed outside the camp, and their remaining clothing was torn and burned (Leviticus 13:45–46). This was one of the harshest early forms of quarantine, as lepers were considered cursed and unclean. The practice continued into the New Testament period and beyond.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.