Honor and Respect in Homer's Iliad and Aristophanes' Lysistrata
This paper examines how Homer's Iliad and Aristophanes' Lysistrata — two war-themed works separated by genre, tone, and centuries — share a common thematic resolution centered on honor and respect for the enemy. Through close reading of each work's ending, the paper argues that the Iliad's tragic conclusion (Priam's supplication before Achilles and Hector's honorable burial) and Lysistrata's comic finale (Athenians and Spartans celebrating together in song and dance) both redirect attention toward the "enemy" as a means of cultivating mutual respect. The paper further connects these ancient themes to contemporary questions about the moral costs of modern warfare.
- Introduction: War, Endings, and a Common Bond: Both works end by honoring the enemy
- Honor as the Overarching Theme of the Iliad: Honor drives the Iliad from start to finish
- Nobility and Comedy in Lysistrata: Lysistrata pursues noble peace through comedy
- Catharsis, Empathy, and the Price of Respect: Priam and Achilles share grief and mutual respect
- Joy, Humanity, and Peace in Lysistrata's Resolution: Sexual strike ends war with song and celebration
- Ancient Lessons for Modern Warfare: Ancient honor contrasted with modern warfare's moral failure
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The thesis is clearly stated early and consistently supported: both works are read as "artistic attempts to understand the enemy through identification and honor," giving the comparative analysis a unified direction.
- The paper uses direct quotation from primary sources effectively, letting Homer's and Aristophanes' own language carry the argument about tone and theme rather than relying solely on paraphrase.
- The contrast between tragic catharsis (the Iliad) and comedic humanity (Lysistrata) is handled with nuance — the paper acknowledges genuine differences in method while arguing for a shared moral destination.
Key academic technique demonstrated
Comparative literary analysis across genre: the paper sets Homer's epic tragedy alongside Aristophanes' comedy and uses close reading of each work's ending to argue for a shared thematic concern. By anchoring the comparison in specific textual moments — Priam's supplication, the Spartan victory song — the argument remains grounded in evidence rather than abstraction.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a joint introduction establishing the thesis, then devotes separate sections to the Iliad and Lysistrata before bringing the two works together in a comparative synthesis. It closes by applying the ancient thematic lesson to a contemporary argument about modern warfare and moral loss, giving the essay both scholarly and reflective registers.
Introduction: War, Endings, and a Common Bond
It should not be possible to speak of the ends of things without speaking of their beginnings. Homer's Iliad and Aristophanes' Lysistrata are two war-themed works whose tones are dissimilar but whose endings are revealing of a common bond — despite the centuries and structures that separate them. The ending of Homer's Iliad depicts the death of Hector, the abuse of his corpse by Achilles, the begging of mercy by Priam, and the burial of Hector's bones following the cremation of his body on the funeral pyre. The ending of Lysistrata is a jubilant celebration of peace in song as Athenians and Spartans end their war thanks in large part to the influence of their women.
The common bond is this: both works end with attention focused not on those who begin the work — Lysistrata of Athens, or Achilles of the Argives — but rather on the enemy: the Spartans in song, and Hector of the Trojans. The sense is that both works are neither pro-war nor anti-war in the extreme, but may be read rather as artistic attempts to understand the enemy through identification and honor. They are, in other words, works of respect. This paper will show how the ends of both The Iliad and Lysistrata reflect a kind of respect that any honorable man — or woman — of ancient Greece might have done well to cultivate for the enemy, and which we today may likewise do well to cultivate as our nations embark on a foreign policy of total war.
Honor as the Overarching Theme of the Iliad
"Anger be now your song" is Robert Fitzgerald's opening translation of Homer's epic — and it refers to Achilles' anger at Agamemnon, the leader of the Greeks, who has insulted Achilles by stealing his woman and spoil of war. Although Achilles' anger is not the primary focus of the narrative, it introduces from the very beginning the theme of honor — the same theme that will close out the narrative, though a transition will be made from Grecian honor to Trojan honor.
The whole of the narrative may be summed up tersely: Achilles is offended by Agamemnon and refuses to fight the Trojans any longer, whereupon the Trojans — realizing that their greatest foe is no longer a threat — attack the Greek camp and cause massive destruction. Achilles' friend then steps out disguised as Achilles, causing the Trojans to flee in panic; but Hector realizes the ruse and slays the friend of Achilles, whose anger is then turned from Agamemnon to the Trojans. Achilles does battle with Hector, slays him, and drags his corpse from the back of his chariot, insulting the Trojans as he does so. Thereupon the father of Hector, King Priam, humbles himself before Achilles and begs the body back so that it may receive an honorable burial.
Honor is the overarching theme — and the sense, here, is that honor is a noble idea, one that, if held by men at all times, would surely go a long way toward eliminating the destruction that war brings. The Iliad begins with the dishonor of Achilles and ends with the honor of his equal Hector, following, of course, Hector's dishonor at the hand of Achilles.
Works Cited
Aristophanes. Lysistrata / The Acharnians / The Clouds. Trans. Alan Sommerstein. New York: Penguin Classics, 1973. Print.
Browning, Robert. "Andrea del Sarto." Web. 12 Nov. 2011.
Homer. The Iliad. Trans. Robert Fitzgerald. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.