Mortgage Fraud and Predatory Lending: Causes and Regulation
This paper offers a comprehensive examination of mortgage fraud and predatory lending in the United States. Beginning with the historical roots of the mortgage as a "death pledge" and tracing its evolution through New Deal–era reforms, the paper explains how each stage of the modern loan-approval process creates openings for deception. It analyzes a spectrum of fraudulent conduct — from individual applicants embellishing income details to organized property-flipping rings and identity theft — and then turns to the exploitative tactics predatory lenders use against vulnerable, often minority borrowers. The final section evaluates the effectiveness of federal agencies (FHA, FBI, IRS), state statutes, local ordinances, and non-governmental organizations in combating both types of fraud, concluding that systemic reform remains elusive.
- Introduction: The Scale and Nature of Mortgage Fraud: Scope and dual nature of mortgage fraud
- The Dead Pledge Heritage: Historical Roots of Mortgage Exploitation: Historical links between mortgages and exploitation
- The New Deal and the Modern Mortgage: FHA reforms and rise of modern home lending
- How the Loan-Approval Process Creates Opportunities for Fraud: Vulnerabilities at each loan-approval stage
- How Fraud and Predatory Lending Operate in Practice: Fraud types from white lies to organized schemes
- Regulations: Attempts, Concerns, and Failures: Federal, state, and local anti-fraud efforts
- Conclusion: Systemic causes and pessimistic outlook for reform
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper sustains a clear analytical thread across a very broad topic, moving from history to mechanics to fraud typology to regulation without losing coherence.
- It draws on a genuinely diverse source base — industry journals, activist reports (ACORN, NTIC), government newsroom releases, and a first-hand insider interview — giving the argument both breadth and on-the-ground texture.
- The use of concrete illustrative dialogues and dollar figures (e.g., the $80,000 vs. $100,000 "amount financed" example) makes abstract financial deception tangible for general readers.
- The paper is consistently self-aware about moral complexity, resisting the urge to assign simple hero/villain roles to any party.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies contextual framing: rather than cataloguing fraud types in isolation, it embeds each in its historical, economic, and regulatory context. The opening etymology of "mortgage" as a "death pledge" is not mere decoration — it anchors the entire subsequent argument that exploitative lending has structural, not merely individual, causes. This technique shows readers why fraud persists rather than simply what it looks like.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a funnel-then-broaden structure: a vivid rhetorical opening establishes stakes; two historical sections provide context; a mechanics section explains vulnerability; a long central section catalogs fraud types from least to most organized; a regulatory section tests proposed solutions; and a conclusion synthesizes the moral ambiguity. Footnote-style commentary woven into the source text enriches the main argument without interrupting its flow, functioning as a running critical commentary alongside the primary analysis.
Introduction: The Scale and Nature of Mortgage Fraud
If a rash of armed bank robberies swept across America and criminals absconded with $30 billion, one may be certain that public panic would ensue and the banking system would likely be changed forever. If thousands of armed thugs went rampaging across the nation forcing people out of their homes and then destroying the properties — leaving the occupants homeless — fear would force society to adapt its policies to fight that threat. Yet in many ways this is precisely the situation occurring with the recent rise in mortgage fraud and abuse. Certainly the criminals are armed with paperwork instead of shotguns, but the impact they are having is no less real. Authorities have stated that fraud is involved in $60 billion in loans annually, resulting in $30 billion in losses.
Mortgage fraud is quickly leading to houses being repeatedly "flipped" between conspiring buyers to reach artificially high prices and then fraudulently sold to innocent purchasers for far more than they are worth — leading both to repossessions and to artificially created comparable sales that may skew future appraisals. Such flipping serves to defraud both banks and individual buyers.
However, not only is the mortgage industry being defrauded from outside; elements within the mortgage industry are also — often illegally — defrauding thousands of disadvantaged borrowers out of millions of dollars combined and destroying thousands of lives in the process. The effects of these frauds are particularly felt in inner cities, where predatory lending practices are shattering many communities, leading to homes being repossessed from long-term owners and either left vacant or sold to slumlords. Many independent studies have shown that the majority of consumers targeted by predatory lenders are minorities or lower-income individuals — fraud seems to target those who can least afford to survive it. A startling number of loans made to lower-income or credit-disadvantaged borrowers (the subprime market) are not only unfair in terms of higher interest rates, but are actively deceptive and intended to leach away as much income and equity as possible. The mortgage industry is not only subject to fraud perpetrated upon it — it is also itself riddled with abusive and fraudulent practices.
It is perhaps because fraud is so pervasive in the industry today that less is being done to combat it than one might expect. Mortgage companies frequently fail to report fraud, and when they do, reports are often put on hold by law enforcement. Individual consumers may not realize they have legal protection, or may feel there is no point in fighting the system and risking losing even more. Abuse committed by mortgage companies is even harder to prosecute than fraud committed against them, as the former often walks the thin line between legal — if unethical — and illegal practice. Many grassroots groups are trying to combat lending abuse, while many corporate organizations work to develop ways for mortgage companies to better protect themselves against fraudulent applications. In addition to these non-governmental solutions, federal, state, and local governments have all tried passing regulations to prevent mortgage fraud and abuse. Despite these efforts — and in some cases ironically because of them — fraud and abuse continues to grow year by year, daily reaching new extremes, developing new tactics, and becoming increasingly destructive in the economic and social realms.
The Dead Pledge Heritage: Historical Roots of Mortgage Exploitation
The degree of dishonesty and fraudulence associated with the modern mortgage industry raises an important question: is there some level at which the very nature of the mortgage industry is fraudulent, or at least invites fraud? Looking over the history of mortgages, one can see some indication that there has long been a link between exploitation and the mortgage. This is somewhat indicated in the formation of the word itself. Mort- signifies death, and -gage derives from the same root as "pledge."
Mortgages are, literally, death pledges. This phraseology is descended from the idea that "property rights were said to be 'dead' to the borrower until the due date. Worse yet, if he failed to settle up on the due date, he lost everything — or, as English jurist Sir Edward Coke put it in 1628, if a mortgagor failed to pay, 'then the Land which is put in pledge… is taken from him for ever, and so dead to him.'"
As this brief linguistic lesson suggests, mortgages in the old world were not unrelated to the exploitative systems of feudalism. In fact, many ancient civilizations had agreements akin to mortgages. In ancient Egypt, for example, most private landowners had effectively mortgaged their land to the ruling class, and though they owned it officially, still paid for the right to remain there. This stable Egyptian system gave rise to the longest-lasting civilization known to history and created an enduring and powerful ruling class which, nonetheless, might be considered to have been somewhat exploitative of the peasantry.
The ability to borrow against one's property — to pledge it to death if one failed to pay — was important to the economic development of Egypt, just as it would later be in Europe and America. It was this mortgaging aspect of Egyptian culture against which the Mosaic Laws were reacting when the Jewish scriptures forbade lending money at interest to fellow Jews and ordered that all property be returned to its hereditary owners every seven years. The ancient Hebrew sense that God did not approve of the death pledge of mortgaging carried over to Catholic theory and later Puritan thought as well, both of which considered usury a sin.
Mortgaging of property persisted despite the Christian rejection of usury, and has been credited with helping to fuel the westward expansion of the American frontier, as struggling farmers had one property after another foreclosed on by predatory banks.
Mortgages have historically been linked to the chaining of individuals to the soil, to the transfer of power from peasants to ruling classes, and to other exploitative practices. This history has a certain relevance to today's predatory lending practices and may contain insight on possible solutions to mortgage fraud if fully explored. It may also help explain certain dynamics on the consumer side of mortgage fraud. To fully understand how modern mortgage fraud functions, however, it is necessary to know the history and mechanics of the common modern mortgage.
The New Deal and the Modern Mortgage
It was not until the New Deal fought to pull America out of depression that mortgages as they currently exist — with all their strengths and weaknesses — really came into being. This was when the Federal Housing Administration was established to guarantee 93% of new homeowner mortgages, and when the Federal Savings and Loan Insurance Corporation (FSLIC) and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) were created to insure savings and deposits. With the federal government guaranteeing nearly everything, there was almost no risk for lenders. This created an environment in which, for the first time, loans were both federally regulated and actively encouraged. A predictable surge in homeownership followed.
This government move was at least partly a response to the significant problem of predatory lending that already existed in America. Prior to the founding of the FHA, the American mortgage industry had gotten its start not with banks but with insurance companies — institutions motivated not by fees and interest charges but by the hope of gaining ownership of properties if borrowers failed to make payments. Repayment schedules were spread over three to five years and ended with a balloon payment. It was the FHA that introduced the amortization of loans so that indebtedness could decrease over time. They also instituted lending practices based on ability to repay, assessment of property quality before making a loan, and expanded loan terms — seven, fifteen, and thirty years — so that mortgages could be feasibly repaid. For the first time in modern Christian history, carrying significant mortgage debt was equated not with sin but with the proper way of family living, and homeowners went from being a minority to a majority of households.
Yet despite this overwhelming push to improve the financial situation of borrowers, the end result was not an unmitigated good. In the housing rush, houses had often been bought at inflated prices and at high rates of interest. For many people, homeownership was "cost burdened," with mortgage payments taking more than 40% of some households' income. To this burden were added the additional costs of suburban living — the necessity of owning a car for transportation to remote workplaces and the upkeep of suburban lifestyles. Within a few decades, foreclosures began again, and a younger generation watched their parents' dreams seem increasingly remote. Financing changed once more as Fannie Mae began offering more flexible options such as adjustable-rate mortgages and resurrected the balloon payment. Meanwhile, the weight of mortgages served to settle the older generation into political and economic stagnation, something that many young people in the 1960s and 1970s protested as a hidden cost of suburbia.
One can see, therefore, a certain degree to which mortgages are inherently exploitative. A simple analysis of the amount borrowed compared to the total amount repaid over the life of a loan might point to the same conclusion. Some of the fraud perpetuated within the mortgage industry may have its roots in this fundamental inequality — whether from individuals' sense that a certain amount of dishonesty is justified by the high price they will pay for their mortgage, or from companies being willing to overlook certain fraudulent acts that might in the end increase net profits if they do not result in foreclosure. Nonetheless, there is a significant difference between legitimate — if exploitative — loans undertaken with the full and informed consent of all parties, and loan fraud that occurs when one or more parties is lied to about the essential facts of the situation. Lending may be parasitic in all cases, and predatory in many, but it is particularly predatorial when it is based in fraud and misrepresentation.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.