Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 3,254 words

Oz, Race, and the American Dream in Urban Culture

~17 min read 6 sections Literature · Fairy Tales
Abstract

This paper examines three texts — L. Frank Baum's The Wizard of Oz, Jonathan Lethem's The Fortress of Solitude, and the film Trading Places — as cultural artifacts that help illuminate the American transition from rural to urban life and the complex intersections of race, identity, and the American Dream. The paper argues that Baum's fairy tale prepared Americans for urbanization and the commodification of popular culture, while Lethem's novel explores how race and culture shape destiny in 20th-century Brooklyn. Trading Places is then used to challenge and complicate the notion that race is destiny, drawing parallels to the Harlem Renaissance poet Claude McKay. Together, the texts reveal how magic, transcendence, and upward mobility are negotiated across race, class, and cultural identity.

Key Takeaways
  • The Wizard of Oz and the Rural-to-Urban Transition: Oz as cultural bridge from country to city
  • The American Dream, Power, and Commodification in Oz: Abstract virtues commodified by elites in Baum's world
  • The Fortress of Solitude: Race, Magic, and Urban Identity: Race, culture, and magic in Lethem's Brooklyn novel
  • Dylan, Mingus, and the Divergence of Destiny: How race shapes two friends' diverging life paths
  • Trading Places and the Question of Racial Destiny: Film and McKay challenge racial determinism
  • Conclusion: Race, Culture, and Transcendence Across Three Texts: Destiny shaped by race, magic, and intervention
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper successfully draws unexpected but illuminating connections across three very different cultural texts — a children's fairy tale, a literary novel, and a Hollywood comedy — to build a unified argument about race, identity, and the American Dream.
  • The historical contextualization of Baum's Oz within Gilded Age banking crises, the Federal Reserve Act, and early 20th-century urbanization gives the literary analysis genuine social depth.
  • The treatment of the "fortress of solitude" as a shifting metaphor across the stages of Dylan's life is a strong close-reading technique that anchors the thematic analysis in specific textual detail.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper employs comparative cultural analysis, reading literary and cinematic texts against their historical and sociological contexts. It moves fluidly between close textual reading (e.g., the symbolism of the magic ring or the silver shoes) and broad cultural argument (e.g., the commodification of abstract virtues like "courage" and "heart"), demonstrating how individual works both reflect and shape their historical moments.

Structure breakdown

The paper is organized into three thematic sections corresponding to each primary text, followed by a brief synthesis. The Oz section is the longest and most historically grounded. The Fortress of Solitude section pivots to race and urban identity, and the Trading Places section uses the film and Claude McKay to complicate and partly refute the racial determinism suggested by Lethem's novel. A shared Works Cited list ties the three sections together as a unified essay.

Essay 3,254 words

The Wizard of Oz and the Rural-to-Urban Transition

The Wizard of Oz provides Americans with a text that helps them make the transition from the country to the city and sets the stage for the commodified American popular culture of the 20th century. Thanks to its pristine (Emerald) beauty and adventurous episodes, Oz makes "the city" far more appealing than the muted, old-fashioned landscape of rural America. Yet Dorothy ultimately returns to Kansas — someone has to carry back home the message of how wondrous "the city" truly is.

Baum's Oz shows that every man can become a king if he pursues his own desires. The Scarecrow is awarded leadership over the Emerald City, the Tin Man leadership over Winkie County, and the Cowardly Lion kingship over the forest. Each character rises to meet his own personal challenge — and, nonetheless, these are clear examples of how the American Dream is perfectly attainable if one simply determines to set off in search of it.

With the industrialization of America, this Dream seemed more possible than ever. At the end of the 19th century, America had faced several banking crises; its people were picking up the pieces after the horrors of the previous generation's Civil War; and new foreign wars loomed on the horizon — for example, the Spanish-American War and the advent of American imperialism. America as a nation had changed and was changing still more: it was being urbanized as more individuals moved to the big cities to find work, and monopolists like Rockefeller consolidated power. The big bankers would make their gambit for total control of the nation's money supply — and win — in 1913 with the passing of the Federal Reserve Act. In a sense, these men were like the mighty Wizard of Oz: hucksters posing as men of brilliance. The promise of free and easy credit after World War I, coupled with a scofflaw attitude fueled by Prohibition, made the 1920s a "Roaring" time indeed — a boom that ended in a devastating bust.

In one sense, Baum's Wizard of Oz helped prepare the way for these changes and certainly helped Americans transition from the country to the city. Dorothy, for example, is the farm girl from Kansas who is swept off to Oz, where she makes wonderful friends and has fantastic adventures. Baum's American fairy tale also prepares the way for the commodification of 20th-century popular culture by suggesting that abstract ideas like "courage," "brains," and "heart" can be bought and sold by powerful elites — wizards, bankers, corporations — who "magically" know how to produce them for the average citizen who supposedly lacks them.

Baum's book was published in 1900; in 1902 the Broadway musical adaptation was produced; and in 1939 the film version was released — a forty-year span from the text's introduction to its transformation into one of the most iconic films of all time. That transformation mirrored the transformation the nation itself had undergone, as its "brains," "courage," and "heart" were tested by episodes like the Great Depression and both World Wars. Movements like the Harlem Renaissance also helped to shape how Oz was perceived from one generation to the next, as a more dynamic and exciting version — the film — replaced the old print medium.

5 Sections Hidden · 1,620 words
The American Dream, Power, and Commodification in Oz420 words
If "the City" is so wonderful and magnificent, why does Dorothy still long for home and eventually return to Kansas? The answer has two parts. Just as the artists of the…
The Fortress of Solitude: Race, Magic, and Urban Identity310 words
The Fortress of Solitude by Jonathan Lethem explores the issues of race, popular culture, and magic. The novel highlights, in the style of fantastic realism, the nature…
Dylan, Mingus, and the Divergence of Destiny380 words
Dylan becomes, in this sense, like Ellison's Invisible Man — yet Dylan is not alone. All those who grew up in the neighborhood are invisible to…
Trading Places and the Question of Racial Destiny390 words
Trading Places contradicts the assertion made by The Fortress of Solitude in that it asserts that race is not destiny. The character played by Eddie Murphy shows that being a black…
Conclusion: Race, Culture, and Transcendence Across Three Texts120 words
Ironically, Murphy's character likely would not have risen had it not been for the intervention of the old cronies — but the same may be said of McKay. Upward mobility for Dorothy comes in the form of a twister.…

Works Cited

Baum, F. The Wizard of Oz. Chicago, IL: George M. Hill Company, 1900.

Ellison, Ralph. Invisible Man. New York: Random House, 1952.

Jones, E. Michael. Sexual Liberation and Political Control. South Bend, IN: St. Augustine's Press, 2000.

Landis, John, dir. Trading Places. Los Angeles: Paramount, 1983. Film.

Lethem, Jonathan. The Fortress of Solitude. New York: Doubleday, 2003.

Mailer, Norman. "The White Negro."

Rose, Tricia. "Hip-Hop Nation." In Popular Culture in American History.

Key Concepts in This Paper
American Dream Urbanization Racial Identity Popular Culture Commodification Magic Ring Transcendence Harlem Renaissance Fortress of Solitude Hip-Hop Culture
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Oz, Race, and the American Dream in Urban Culture. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/oz-race-american-dream-urban-culture-2151978

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.