Panic Attack Differential Diagnosis: Clinical Case Study
This paper presents a clinical case study of a 19-year-old female college student who arrives at a university health center complaining of chest pain and difficulty breathing during a period of acute academic stress. The paper systematically explores a broad range of differential diagnoses — including myocardial infarction, atrial fibrillation, pulmonary embolism, hyperthyroidism, and several psychiatric disorders — evaluating pertinent positives and negatives for each. After a comprehensive review of systems, patient history, and diagnostic considerations, the paper concludes that the patient's presentation is most consistent with a panic attack. It also addresses the pathophysiology of panic disorder and outlines recommendations for patient education, breathing techniques, and psychiatric referral.
- Differential Diagnoses Overview: Eleven possible diagnoses with exam and testing criteria
- History of Present Illness: Patient's acute presentation and symptom timeline
- Past Medical History and Social History: Medical background, medications, family and lifestyle history
- Review of Systems and Diagnostic Rationale: Organ-system review with clinical reasoning for each
- Differential Diagnosis Summary Table: Pertinent positives and negatives for each diagnosis
- Final Diagnosis, Pathophysiology, and Management: Panic attack confirmed with pathophysiology and referral plan
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper demonstrates disciplined clinical reasoning by systematically listing and eliminating differential diagnoses using pertinent positives and negatives, rather than jumping directly to a conclusion.
- The structured format — from chief complaint through history, review of systems, and diagnostic testing rationale — mirrors real-world clinical documentation, lending the paper authenticity and practical value.
- The final diagnosis is appropriately hedged: the paper correctly notes that the patient does not yet meet full diagnostic criteria for panic disorder, showing nuanced understanding of DSM-based distinctions.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies the pertinent positive/negative method of clinical reasoning. Each differential diagnosis is assessed not only for supporting symptoms but also for the absence of expected findings — for example, noting that the patient's symptoms resolve with controlled breathing and are situationally specific, systematically weakening cardiac and pulmonary alternatives. This technique is a cornerstone of evidence-based clinical decision-making.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with patient demographics and a chief complaint, then surveys eleven differential diagnoses with history, physical exam findings, and diagnostic tests for each. It transitions to a detailed History of Present Illness, Past Medical and Social History, and a full Review of Systems with organ-system rationale. A summary table weighs pertinent positives and negatives for each differential before the paper closes with a final diagnosis, a discussion of panic disorder pathophysiology, and management recommendations.
Differential Diagnoses Overview
Chief Complaint: "I am scared. I feel like I can't catch my breath and my chest hurts."
There are a number of differential diagnoses for these presenting symptoms. The major ones are explored below.
Myocardial Infarction (MI), Angina, and Acute Coronary Syndrome
History: Prodromal symptoms include fatigue, chest discomfort, or malaise in the days before the MI. A typical STEMI may occur without warning. Onset is not directly associated with severe exertion but may be concomitant with exertion. Other symptoms include anxiety, light-headedness with or without syncope, nausea or indigestion, cough, diaphoresis, and/or wheezing.
Physical Exam: Physical symptoms can be variable. The typical chest pain of an acute myocardial infarction is intense and continuous for 30–60 minutes, retrosternal, and may radiate to the neck, shoulder, and jaw and down to the ulnar aspect of the left arm. It may be described as burning, squeezing, aching, or sharp. Sometimes the main symptom is epigastric with indigestion. Hypertension or hypotension may be present depending on the focus of the MI. Acute valvular dysfunction may be present. Other symptoms such as confusion, anxiety, a sense of impending doom, profound restlessness, diaphoresis, weakness, presyncope, hiccupping (which reflects irritation of the diaphragm or phrenic nerve), vomiting, and palpitations may also be present. Atypical presentations may include abdominal discomfort, jaw pain, altered mental status (more common in elderly patients), or atypical chest pain. Nearly half of MIs are clinically silent, as they are not associated with the symptoms described above and may go unrecognized.
Diagnostic Testing: Blood pressure monitoring, ECG/EKG, cardiac imaging, cardiac catheterization, coronary artery calcium scoring, cardiac biomarkers/enzymes, troponin levels, creatine kinase levels, myoglobin levels, kidney function and electrolyte levels, and medication review.
Atrial Fibrillation (AF)
History: Clinical presentation can be variable, ranging from asymptomatic atrial fibrillation with rapid ventricular response to cardiogenic shock or cerebrovascular accident (CVA). The majority of AF episodes are asymptomatic. Three patterns of AF are recognized: paroxysmal AF, which terminates spontaneously within seven days (with most episodes lasting less than 24 hours); persistent AF, which lasts more than seven days and often requires pharmacologic or electrical intervention; and permanent AF, which has persisted for greater than one year.
Physical Exam: An AF diagnosis is based on the physical finding of an irregular heart rhythm.
Diagnostic Testing: A 12-lead ECG is appropriate.
Atrial Flutter
History: Palpitations, a "fluttering" sensation in the chest, shortness of breath, anxiety, and general weakness.
Physical Exam: Typically a macro-reentrant arrhythmia with atrial rates between 240 and 400 beats per minute.
Diagnostic Testing: ECG.
Mitral Valve Prolapse (MVP)
History: Symptomatic MVP is divided into three categories: symptoms related to autonomic dysfunction; symptoms related to the progression of mitral regurgitation; and symptoms that occur as a consequence of another complication such as CVA. Symptoms related to autonomic dysfunction (usually congenital) include anxiety, panic attacks, fatigue, arrhythmia, atypical chest pain, orthostasis, syncope, and/or neuropsychiatric symptoms.
Physical Exam: The classic auscultatory finding in MVP is a mid-to-late systolic click and/or murmur.
Diagnostic Testing: Physical examination and echocardiography.
Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS)
History: Characterized by the development of acute hypoxemia and dyspnea, typically 12–48 hours following a precipitating event (though it may occur even later). Triggering events include trauma, sepsis, drug overdose, massive transfusion, acute pancreatitis, or aspiration. The event may be obvious or difficult to identify depending on the case.
Physical Exam: Often presents with nonspecific symptoms such as tachypnea, tachycardia, and the need for a high fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2) to maintain oxygen saturation. The patient may be febrile or hypothermic. Examination of the lungs may reveal bilateral rales. If ARDS occurs as a result of sepsis, there may be hypotension and peripheral vasoconstriction with cold extremities and possible cyanosis of the lips and nail beds. If sepsis is not readily apparent, attention should be paid to signs of lung consolidation or findings consistent with an acute abdomen. Any recent wounds, drain sites, and decubitus ulcers should be examined for infection. Subcutaneous air, a manifestation of infection or barotrauma, should also be noted.
Diagnostic Testing: ARDS is a clinical diagnosis; an acute onset of symptoms is noted along with chest radiograph, hemodynamic monitoring, and/or bronchoscopy.
Pulmonary Embolism (PE)
History: The classic presentation is sudden onset of pleuritic chest pain, shortness of breath, and hypoxia. However, many patients do not display these symptoms; people who have died from pulmonary embolism have often complained of nagging symptoms for weeks before death.
Physical Exam: Nonspecific clinical signs and symptoms. Sometimes dyspnea, tachypnea, or chest pain are present.
Diagnostic Testing: Can be extensive. Pulse oximetry with mild exertion (such as walking) will typically identify suspect cases.
Hyperthyroidism
History: Anxiety, increased perspiration, heat intolerance, hyperactivity, tremor, palpitations, unexplained weight loss, and oligomenorrhea.
Physical Exam: Hyperactivity; atrial arrhythmia or tachycardia; systolic hypertension; warm, moist, smooth skin; lid lag; tremor; and sometimes muscle weakness.
Diagnostic Testing: TSH and thyroid hormone levels; scintigraphy if needed.
Diabetes
History: Polydipsia, polyuria, and polyphagia, along with lassitude, nausea, and blurred vision.
Physical Exam: Polyuria and associated complaints of nocturnal enuresis, thirst, weakness or fatigue, muscle cramps, and blurred vision.
Diagnostic Testing: Plasma glucose levels, hemoglobin A1c, fructosamine levels, and WBC.
Seizure Disorder (Epilepsy)
History: Recurrent blackouts, staring episodes, frequent lapses of concentration, and missed periods of time.
Physical Exam: Information gathered from the patient concerning auras, preservation of consciousness, and postictal states.
Diagnostic Testing: Two imaging studies are required: a neuroimaging evaluation (MRI or CT) and an EEG.
Drug or Alcohol Intoxication or Withdrawal; Caffeine Intoxication; Medication Side Effects
History: Repeated or intermittent use of drugs or alcohol to cope with or escape from stress.
Physical Exam: Slurring of words, balance difficulties, hyper- or hypoactivity, over- or underarousal, drowsiness, autonomic signs, and nausea.
Diagnostic Testing: Urinalysis and chemistry panel analysis. Cardiac markers, measurement of prothrombin time, or toxicology screening may be indicated.
Psychiatric Disorders
History: The history will depend on the specific disorder in question. Panic attacks are associated with a number of psychiatric disorders, including panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder, phobic disorders, and somatization disorder.
Physical Exam: Interview with the patient. Look for signs of psychosis (loose associations, delusions, or hallucinations), mania (pressured speech, hyperactivity), and depression (decreased affect, amotivation, slowed responses).
Diagnostic Testing: Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders (SCID-I).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.