Paris Is Burning and Mass Media: Race, Gender & Identity
This paper offers a critical deconstruction of Jennie Livingston's 1990 documentary Paris Is Burning through the lens of six academic readings on mass media and representation. The film's portrayal of New York's drag ball culture — and the African-American, Latino, transgender, and gay communities that shaped it — is examined alongside scholarly chapters addressing gay visibility, the hot-Latina stereotype, Ellen DeGeneres's media persona, Oprah Winfrey's self-help philosophy, misogynistic stereotypes in hip-hop, and the evolution of children's advertising. Together, these frameworks illuminate how the film's characters navigated race, homophobia, gender conformity, and the pursuit of the American Dream within a deeply stratified society.
- Introduction: Paris Is Burning and Its Cultural Context: Overview of the documentary, its themes and awards
- Gay Visibility and the Limits of Tolerance: Gay representation in media versus drag ball reality
- Latina Stereotypes, Self-Imposition, and the Drag Ball Houses: Hot-Latina stereotype and self-imposed drag ball standards
- Reiteration, Resistance, and the Politics of Conformity: Ellen DeGeneres's media persona and minority conformity
- Dreams, Self-Belief, and the Power of Individual Vision: Oprah, drag queens, and Venus Xtravaganza on dreaming
- Gender, Power, and the Defiance of Stereotype: Venus challenges hip-hop misogyny and male dominance
- Consumerism, Agency, and the Shift in Power: Children's advertising parallels Venus's personal agency
- Conclusion: Film as timeless reflection of universal human aspiration
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper applies multiple distinct theoretical frameworks to a single cultural artifact, demonstrating breadth of media literacy and the ability to sustain a complex comparative argument across many chapters.
- Each textbook chapter is connected to a concrete scene or character from the documentary, grounding abstract theory in specific, observable examples such as Venus Xtravaganza's confrontation scene or the drag queen's makeup monologue.
- The paper moves fluidly between the historical context of 1980s New York and contemporary media patterns, showing that the film's relevance extends well beyond its original moment.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies intertextual comparative analysis: rather than treating each scholarly source in isolation, the writer consistently triangulates between the film's scenes, the chapter's theoretical claim, and broader social patterns. This technique allows a single documentary to serve as the connective tissue for six distinct academic arguments about representation, identity, and power in mass media.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a detailed introduction to the documentary and its reception, then proceeds chapter by chapter through six academic readings. Each section identifies the chapter's central argument, locates a corresponding moment in the film, and draws a comparison. A concluding section synthesizes the threads, arguing that the film transcends its narrow urban setting to reflect universal desires for success, acceptance, and love. The structure is thematic rather than strictly chronological, mirroring the film's own movement between interview subjects.
Introduction: Paris Is Burning and Its Cultural Context
Paris Is Burning is a provocative and controversial documentary film released in 1990. Directed by Jennie Livingston, it focuses on the drag ball culture that existed in New York City during the 1980s. The film centers on three primary topics: race, homosexuality, and prejudice toward social stereotypes. It examines not only white American urban culture but also the lifestyles of African-Americans, Latinos, and gay individuals within their communities, while simultaneously shedding light on the lives of transsexual people and sex workers in the city.
The significance of the film lies not only in the thought-provoking topics it covers but also in its style of filmmaking and in the fact that it perhaps marks the end of the cultural phenomenon that was the New York drag balls. The documentary moves between footage of drag ball events and interviews with prominent personalities from the African-American, Latino, gay, and transsexual communities. The drag ball events and competitions were structured around specific themes, and all contestants were expected to walk across a crowded room as models do on a runway. The key difference was that the judging criterion was not based solely on fashion sense but on the authenticity of the individual and what he was representing as part of himself. Contestants were divided into groups called "houses" based on their fashion sense and styling — for example, the House of Prada. Each house was representative of the family or social circle of the contestant. The most consistent winners would attain the status of legend. Interviewees included celebrated figures such as Pepper LaBeija, Dorian Corey, Anji Xtravaganza, and Willi Ninja. Their commentaries focused on how individuals leading lives outside the mainstream had to tackle intolerance, racism, homophobia — sometimes from their own families — as well as disease and social, medical, and economic hardship.
The drag ball is also represented as a multifaceted presentation of sex, social division, and race — a space where any individual can freely express their lifestyle, identity, orientation, dreams, goals, and opinions without fear of ridicule or judgment. The film brings to light both the African-American and Latino communities, each encompassing a wide array of identities, sexualities, orientations, and social transgressions. The film received considerable recognition for its provocative approach, including the following awards:
- International Documentary Association Award (1990)
- Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award for Best Documentary (1990)
- Audience Award for Best Documentary, San Francisco International Lesbian & Gay Film Festival (1990)
- Grand Jury Prize for Best Documentary, Sundance Film Festival (1991)
- Teddy Award for Best Documentary, Berlin International Film Festival (1991)
- Best Documentary, Boston Society of Film Critics Awards (1991)
- Golden Space Needle Award for Best Documentary, Seattle International Film Festival (1991)
- Outstanding Film or Documentary, GLAAD Media Awards (1992)
- National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Documentary (1992)
References
Clarkson, J. (2008). The limitations of the discourse of norms: Gay visibility and degrees of transgression. Journal of Communication Inquiry, 32(4), 368–382. Sage Publications.
Green, J. (1993). "Paris Has Burned." The New York Times. Retrieved August 9, 2011, from http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9F0CE0DF143DF93BA25757C0A965958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all
Merskin, D. (2007). Three faces of Eva: Perpetuation of the hot-Latina stereotype in Desperate Housewives. Howard Journal of Communications, 18, 133–151. Taylor & Francis.
Moore, C. (2008). Resisting, reiterating and dancing through: The swinging closet doors of Ellen DeGeneres's televised personalities. In R. Beirne (Ed.), Televising queer women: A reader (pp. 17–31). Palgrave Macmillan.
Peck, J. (2008). The anxieties of the enterprising self and the limits of the mind cure in the age of Oprah. In J. Peck, The age of Oprah: Cultural icon for the neoliberal era (pp. 211–239). Paradigm.
Rose, T. (2008). There are bitches and hoes. In The hip-hop wars (pp. 167–185). Perseus.
Schor, J. (2004). From Tony the Tiger to Slime Time Live: The content of commercial messages in children's advertising. Excerpt from Born to buy: The commercialized child and the new consumer culture. Scribner/Simon & Schuster.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.