Proletarianization and Teacher Professionalization in Alberta
This paper analyzes the politics of educational reform in Alberta during the 1990s under Premier Ralph Klein's Progressive Conservative government. Drawing on neo-liberal and neo-conservative ideologies, the Klein Administration pursued cost-cutting measures, increased managerial control, and expanded teacher workload through a series of top-down policy reforms. The paper argues that these reforms are best understood through the concept of proletarianization — the process by which workers lose control over core aspects of their work. In response, the Alberta Teachers' Association (ATA) mobilized teachers and advocated for professional autonomy, a stance explained by the concept of professionalization. Analysis of the ATA's 1993 report, "Trying to Teach," illustrates how specific reform proposals intensified teacher labor while eroding professional decision-making authority.
- Introduction: Neo-Liberal Reform and Alberta Education: Context of neo-liberal ideology driving Alberta reforms
- Proletarianization and the Klein Reforms: Defining proletarianization and its application to teachers
- Teacher Resistance and Professionalization: ATA's professionalization response to government restructuring
- The ATA Report: Integration and Results-Based Curriculum: Teacher testimony on integration and curriculum proposals
- Individual Plans, External Testing, and Workload Intensification: Reforms intensifying workload and eroding teacher autonomy
- Conclusion: Education as Business vs. Noble Endeavor: Synthesis of proletarianization versus professionalization conflict
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear theoretical framework early — proletarianization versus professionalization — and applies it consistently throughout the analysis.
- Primary source evidence from the ATA's 1993 "Trying to Teach" report is used extensively, with direct teacher quotations that ground abstract sociological concepts in lived experience.
- The paper contextualizes Alberta-specific reform within broader Canadian and international neo-liberal trends, giving local events wider analytical significance.
- The conclusion neatly crystallizes the paper's central tension: government viewing education as a business project versus teachers viewing it as a professional vocation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates concept-driven analysis: it introduces two sociological concepts (proletarianization and professionalization) with formal definitions drawn from academic sources, then uses those concepts as interpretive lenses applied to specific policy proposals. This technique shows how abstract theory can illuminate concrete historical and political events.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with ideological context (neo-liberalism and neo-conservatism), then defines proletarianization and professionalization as competing forces. The body systematically examines individual reform proposals — integration, results-based curriculum, program continuity, individual educational plans, and external testing — through teacher testimony from the ATA report. The conclusion synthesizes the argument, reinforcing the central opposition between government and teacher visions of education.
Introduction: Neo-Liberal Reform and Alberta Education
In the 1990s, the Canadian educational system underwent a series of significant reforms. The province of Alberta, under the leadership of Premier Ralph Klein and the Progressive Conservatives, took a lead role in implementing these changes. The reforms were rooted in neo-liberal and neo-conservative ideologies and aimed at reducing costs for public education, maximizing economic returns, adopting the managerial structures of corporations for educational institutions, and increasing workload for teachers. These reforms were introduced mostly as top-down policy with little, if any, consultation with teachers and teacher associations. Alberta's teacher associations — the Alberta Teachers' Association (ATA) in particular — took a persistent stance, mobilizing teachers and struggling against the new educational reforms. This paper argues that the Alberta government's attempts to restructure the educational system may be explained by the concept of proletarianization, while the ATA and teachers' resistance to the reforms may be explained by the concept of professionalization.
Neo-liberalism and neo-conservatism are ideologies that share much in common. They have become a guiding principle for the governments of the United States, the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and Canada over the last three decades. For both ideologies, the market economy is a gospel to be defended at all costs. Both advocate corporate tax cuts and oppose large governments as well as welfare states. Neo-liberals and neo-conservatives advocate the pursuit of rigid free-market policies at home and abroad, though these policies are riddled with internal contradictions. For example, advocates of these two ideologies have often contradicted the principles they claim to adhere to by pressuring the governments of the U.S., the U.K., and Canada to interfere in the internal affairs of many developing countries in order to introduce market economies — policies that mostly benefited foreign investors (Harvey, 2005).
The reforms that began in Alberta under the government of Ralph Klein should be understood within the context of the political environment in Canada at the time. Neo-liberal and neo-conservative thinkers in Canada saw a crisis in the country's educational system and decided that the root cause of the problem was public education and the welfare state. Klein and other politicians argued that the cost of education in Canada was too high while Canadian students' performance was poor. In order to improve Canada's global competitiveness, Klein and his political allies argued, Canadian and Albertan educational systems should adopt the business principle of "doing more with less." The educational restructuring in Alberta, as Harrison and Kachur (1999) point out, was "ideologically driven," allowing the government to centralize authority and decrease "equality of student opportunity while opening market niches for private entrepreneurs" (p. xiv). Educational restructuring included, for example, adopting managerial practices of multinational corporations, greater fiscal austerity, and increased monitoring of school performance (Harrison & Kachur, 1999; Flower & Booi, 1999; Peters, 1999; Pocklington, 1999; Taylor, 2001). It should be noted that the Klein government's attack on public education was also an attack on the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which upholds that children of Canadian citizens, including those of minority groups, have the right to receive education "provided out of public funds" (Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms).
Proletarianization and the Klein Reforms
The educational reforms adopted by the Alberta government, among other things, significantly increased teacher workload and decreased teachers' autonomy by introducing various control systems and fixed regulations. Such a policy directed against teachers may be described as proletarianization, which is defined as "a process in which workers lose control over core aspects of their work, or one in which self-sufficient workers are replaced by employees in subordinate positions" (Wotherspoon, 2004, p. 155). Proletarianization occurs when workers are pressured by external forces to intensify their work while being subjected to increased monitoring and control by supervisors and administrators. Proletarianization tries to codify the technical functions of teachers, "such as designing lesson plans, grading students, keeping records of student attendance and progress, and following rules and procedures regarding student discipline" (Wotherspoon, 2004, p. 148).
References
ATA (1993). Trying to Teach. Retrieved March 4, 2011, from http://www.teachers.ab.ca/Publications/Other%20Publications/Pages/TryingtoTeach.aspx
Bascia, N. (2001). Learning Through Struggle: How the Alberta Teachers' Association Maintains an Even Keel. NALL Working Paper #44. Retrieved March 2, 2011, from
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Department of Justice Canada. Retrieved March 3, 2011, from
Flower, D. J., & Booi, H. L. (1999). Challenging restructuring: The Alberta Teachers' Association. In T. W. Harrison & J. L. Kachur (Eds.), Contested Classrooms: Education, Globalization, and Democracy in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta: The University of Alberta Press and Parkland Institute.
Harrison, T. W., & Kachur, J. L. (1999). Contested Classrooms: Education, Globalization, and Democracy in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta: The University of Alberta Press and Parkland Institute.
Harvey, D. (2005). A Brief History of Neoliberalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Peters, F. (1999). Deep and brutal: Funding cuts to education in Alberta. In T. W. Harrison & J. L. Kachur (Eds.), Contested Classrooms: Education, Globalization, and Democracy in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta: The University of Alberta Press and Parkland Institute.
Pocklington, T. (1999). Marketing of the university. In T. W. Harrison & J. L. Kachur (Eds.), Contested Classrooms: Education, Globalization, and Democracy in Alberta. Edmonton, Alberta: The University of Alberta Press and Parkland Institute.
Taylor, A. (2001). The Politics of Educational Reform in Alberta. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Wotherspoon, T. (2004). The Sociology of Education in Canada: Critical Perspectives. Ontario: Oxford University Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.