This paper examines evidence-based strategies and classroom activities designed to support adolescent students who struggle with reading comprehension. Drawing on research by Nation (2019), Parrish (2020), and Ellemen and Oslund (2019), the paper outlines five instructional approaches: focusing on oral language comprehension, providing vocabulary instruction, teaching critical thinking strategies, encouraging reciprocal teaching, and delivering explicit comprehension skills instruction. It also proposes appropriate texts and classroom activities for a small group of eighth-grade students and provides a rationale explaining how these strategies address language development deficits, emphasizing the need for long-term, evidence-based instructional practices across all grade levels.
The primary objective of reading is to comprehend and reconstruct the writer's mental world. Skilled readers experience a sense of ease and natural flow in their comprehension, although this masks the underlying complexity of reading, even when the text is straightforward. Numerous cognitive and linguistic processes come into play, ranging from word identification to inferences about situations not fully described in the text. Consequently, finding a straightforward answer to questions such as "How does reading comprehension develop?" and "Why does it sometimes fail?" becomes exceedingly challenging (Nation, 2019).
Focus on overall language comprehension: Recent studies indicate that difficulties in reading comprehension may originate from an underlying weakness in oral language that persists from early childhood, even before formal reading instruction begins. Students who struggle with reading comprehension also tend to understand fewer spoken words, have a limited grasp of auditory input, and exhibit weaker spoken grammar (Nation, 2019; Parrish, 2020; Ellemen & Oslund, 2019).
Provide vocabulary instruction: Since students with poor comprehension often lack adequate vocabulary skills and struggle to understand spoken language, it is beneficial to teach the meanings of new words using multisensory techniques such as graphic organizers, pictures, and mnemonics. Enhancing overall language proficiency increases students' ability to understand words they encounter in written text (Nation, 2019; Parrish, 2020; Ellemen & Oslund, 2019).
Teach critical thinking strategies: Once students acquire the necessary vocabulary to navigate a text, they often face challenges related to complex thinking and sustained attention — both of which are required to comprehend important details and infer information that is not explicitly stated. Teachers can address this by explicitly instructing students on cognitive strategies (Nation, 2019; Parrish, 2020; Ellemen & Oslund, 2019).
Encourage reciprocal teaching: Following direct instruction, students can consistently practice and implement cognitive strategies through reciprocal teaching, which empowers them to take a leadership role in their own learning and encourages metacognition while listening or reading (Nation, 2019; Parrish, 2020; Ellemen & Oslund, 2019).
Directly instruct comprehension skills: Students should receive explicit instruction in comprehension skills such as sequencing, story structure using the plot mountain, making inferences and drawing conclusions, and recognizing various forms of figurative language. They should have opportunities to practice these skills initially with texts read aloud by the teacher and later with independent reading materials suited to their reading levels (Nation, 2019; Parrish, 2020; Ellemen & Oslund, 2019).
The following texts are appropriate for use with a small group of eighth-grade students who would benefit from additional instruction in reading comprehension skills:
All of the texts listed above offer opportunities to implement the following activities and validate the strategies described in Part 1.
Recommended activities to reinforce reading comprehension and summarizing skills include:
"How strategies address adolescent reading comprehension deficits"
"Cited academic and professional sources"
You’re 41% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.