Competitive Strategy Analysis: The Real Chocolate Company
This case study examines the competitive strategy of the Real Chocolate Company, a gourmet chocolate franchise established in 1981 with over 320 stores across North America. The paper conducts a PESTEL analysis of the external environment, evaluates internal strengths and weaknesses, and diagnoses the company's core strategic challenge: sustaining revenue growth in a competitive, fragmented market. Using the Ansoff Matrix and Porter's Generic Strategies as analytical frameworks, the paper generates and evaluates seven strategic options. A weighted scoring approach identifies product differentiation as the most suitable strategy, and the paper concludes with a concrete action plan for implementation, including forming an R&D team and executing a structured new-product launch process.
- Introduction and Company Overview: Background on Real Chocolate Company's history and competitive position
- Analysis of the External Environment: PESTEL analysis of macro opportunities and threats
- Analysis of the Microenvironment: Internal strengths and weaknesses of the company
- Current Problem Diagnosis: Core strategic challenge of sustaining revenue growth
- Generation and Evaluation of Strategic Options: Seven options scored using Ansoff and Porter frameworks
- The Selected Strategy: Product Differentiation: Rationale for choosing differentiation as optimal strategy
- Action Plan and Conclusions: Implementation steps and summary of findings
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Applies multiple well-known strategic frameworks—PESTEL, Ansoff Matrix, and Porter's Generic Strategies—in a coordinated, sequential manner, building logically from environmental scan to strategy selection.
- Uses a scored comparison table to evaluate seven strategic options objectively, giving the reader a transparent rationale for the final recommendation rather than an unsupported assertion.
- Connects the selected strategy back to the company's specific internal capabilities and gaps, grounding the recommendation in evidence from the case rather than generic theory.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates framework triangulation: rather than relying on a single analytical model, it applies two complementary tools (Ansoff Matrix and Porter's Generic Strategies) and shows how their outputs converge on the same recommendation. This approach strengthens the conclusion by demonstrating consistency across different theoretical lenses.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a classic business case report structure: company background → external environment (macro then micro) → problem statement → option generation → option evaluation → strategy selection → implementation plan → conclusion. Each section builds on the previous, making the logic easy to follow. The numbered section headings aid navigation, and the evaluation table serves as a visual anchor for the central analytical move.
Introduction and Company Overview
The chocolate industry generates billions of dollars annually, with demand for premium products continuing to rise. The aim of this paper is to examine a leading player in the American gourmet chocolate industry and assess its internal and external characteristics, the problems it faces, and the strategic options available. To accomplish this, it is first necessary to briefly introduce the company under analysis.
The Real Chocolate Company was established in 1981 in Kingston, Colorado as a small family business, which soon expanded to operate more than 320 stores across the United States and Canada. All but five of the stores are run through franchises, and the total number of organizational employees is 235. The company has built a favorable reputation through its commitment to quality, the ambiance of its stores, the wide variety of products offered, and the expertise of its team — all of which form components of its competitive advantage.
As the case study notes: "The philosophy at Real Chocolate Company is to use the finest, highest quality ingredients and no artificial preservatives. […] The Real Chocolate Company brand is well-known in the U.S.A., and company managers believe this, alongside with its reputation for quality, variety and taste of products, special ambiance of the stores, store site selection criteria, expertise in the manufacture and merchandising of chocolate candy products, and good customer service, provide the company with a competitive advantage."
Analysis of the External Environment
Opportunities: A primary opportunity presented by the external environment is the increasing demand for gourmet chocolates. Given this trend, the industry is capable of registering sustainable growth. For Real Chocolate, this translates into the ability to expand operations and further consolidate revenues. The drivers behind this growth include the widely publicized health benefits of chocolate and the successful marketing strategies — particularly branding and positioning — used to promote premium products.
Threats: The company faces several significant threats: intensifying competition; the possibility of new legislation bringing additional financial costs; a generally unstable economy that could reduce consumer spending on gourmet products; rising commodity prices; demand tied strictly to consumer tastes and preferences; and the economies of scale already achieved by large players in the market (Hoovers, 2009).
PESTEL Analysis
Political: Political stability is generally maintained within the United States, though new legislation introduced by incoming administrations could affect business operations and costs.
Economic: Rising commodity prices have necessitated increases in retail prices (Kowalski, 2007), while broader economic instability poses the risk of reduced consumer demand for premium goods.
Socio-cultural: The contemporary population faces growing concerns around weight management, which may reduce consumption of confectionery products. At the same time, a clear trend toward dark and premium chocolate — which is considered healthier and is often consumed in smaller portions — presents a countervailing opportunity (Rupani, 2007).
Technological: In an era of rapid technological development, chocolate producers have gained access to equipment and processes that improve operational efficiency while simultaneously enhancing product quality.
Environmental: The gourmet chocolate industry has responded to growing environmental awareness by incorporating organic ingredients into product lines (Rupani, 2007).
Legal: As with the political environment, the legal landscape is largely stable, though changes introduced by new administrations remain a possibility that companies must monitor.
Analysis of the Microenvironment
Internal Strengths: The Real Chocolate Company offers its customers an exceptionally wide product selection: at any given time, the company provides at least 100 chocolate varieties, 15 types of fudge, and more than 30 varieties of caramel-covered apples, with additional specialty items introduced for occasions such as Christmas and Valentine's Day. This breadth of selection ensures that nearly every customer can find something to their taste, effectively broadening the company's revenue base.
Additional organizational strengths include a commitment to quality, the use of premium ingredients and proprietary recipes, a strong and reputable brand, and a loyal and growing customer base. The company's financial performance also stands as a strength: revenues increased by 12.5% in 2007 relative to 2006, reflecting a consistently upward trend (case study).
Internal Weaknesses: The Real Chocolate Company has chosen high-traffic, high-visibility locations for its stores — such as shopping malls and airports — which, while strategically sound, carry higher operating costs. The ongoing transition from manual to automated production processes introduces the risk that product quality could suffer and that employees may experience dissatisfaction during the changeover. Additionally, the company's Materials Requirements Planning (MRP) system, while valuable, has not yet been fully implemented across all store locations.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.