Reconciling Shared Values and Diverse Ideas in Healthcare
This paper examines the complementary roles of shared values and diverse ideas within healthcare organisations. It begins by defining shared values as the beliefs and principles that bind organisational members together, fostering integration, commitment, and collaboration. It then considers how diverse ideas drive creativity, innovation, and employee empowerment. The paper acknowledges the potential tension between these two forces — where strong shared values can inadvertently suppress divergent thinking — and argues that effective leadership is the key to reconciling them. Drawing on organisational culture theory and diversity management literature, the paper proposes that healthcare leaders can resolve this tension by modelling shared values, remaining flexible in their approach, and formally embedding diversity as a core organisational value.
- Introduction: Introduces shared values, diversity, and leadership focus
- The Role of Shared Values in Organisations: Defines shared values and their organisational functions
- The Importance of Diverse Ideas: Explains how diversity drives innovation and empowerment
- The Tension Between Shared Values and Diversity: Identifies conflict between shared values and diverse thinking
- Leadership Strategies for Reconciling Values and Diversity: Proposes leader-centred approaches to balancing both forces
- Embedding Diversity as a Core Organisational Value: Argues for diversity as a formal shared organisational value
- Conclusion: Summarises the case for balancing values and diversity
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly defines its two central concepts — shared values and diverse ideas — before examining their interaction, giving readers a solid conceptual foundation.
- It uses a concrete, well-chosen example (a physician with an Asian background serving Asian patients) to illustrate how diversity and shared values can coexist without conflict.
- The argument builds logically from definition, to tension, to resolution, maintaining a consistent focus on the healthcare context throughout.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of theoretical synthesis: it draws on Schein's organisational culture framework alongside diversity management theory (Yang & Konrad; Danowitz et al.) to develop a nuanced argument. Rather than treating these bodies of literature as separate, the author integrates them to show that leadership sits at the intersection of culture and diversity — a hallmark of graduate-level analytical writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a clear problem–solution structure. It opens with a claim about the importance of both shared values and diversity, devotes two sections to defining each concept, then identifies the tension between them. The final argumentative sections propose concrete leadership strategies, culminating in the recommendation that diversity itself be adopted as a shared value — neatly resolving the tension introduced earlier. The conclusion restates the thesis without introducing new material.
Introduction
Shared values and diverse ideas are crucial for organisational success. Shared values connect people within an organisation (Schein, 2010), while diversity serves as a source of strength, motivation, and empowerment for organisational members (Danowitz, Hanappi-Egger & Mensi-Klarbach, 2012). This can have a positive impact on employee productivity and organisational performance as a whole. Nonetheless, this may not be achieved if the potential conflict between shared values and diverse ideas is not effectively reconciled. Within the health care environment, it is particularly crucial to ensure coexistence between shared values and diverse ideas. After highlighting the significance of shared values and diverse ideas to an organisation, this paper discusses how leaders in the health care environment can reconcile shared values and diverse ideas.
The Role of Shared Values in Organisations
Within the context of organisational behaviour, shared values essentially denote the beliefs, principles, and standards that bind or are common to members of a particular organisation. Shared values comprise part of an organisation's culture and define what an organisation believes in (Schein, 2010). For instance, an organisation may believe in teamwork, integrity, customer-centredness, community involvement, and so on. In any organisation, shared values are vital for integration, coordination, and control (Edington & Pitts, 2016). Integration means that members of a given organisation act in unison — they behave in a similar manner. Coordination and control means that shared values serve as a valuable mechanism for organising, directing, and regulating organisational members. On the whole, shared values contribute to the achievement of organisational goals and objectives by positively affecting employee outcomes — they foster organisational commitment, morale, collaboration, and a family-like atmosphere (Edington & Pitts, 2016).
The Importance of Diverse Ideas
Diverse ideas are also vital for organisational success. An organisation that embraces diverse perspectives benefits from a larger pool of ideas (Danowitz, Hanappi-Egger & Mensi-Klarbach, 2012). Individuals bring to the organisation different skills, experiences, and backgrounds. Without room for diversity, ideas that may be useful to the organisation may be blocked. Encouraging diverse ideas means that there is no room for one-man-shows, where all decisions are made by a single individual or a select few. It means giving everyone a chance to participate in decision-making. The different ideas are then evaluated to arrive at the most feasible, suitable, and acceptable option.
In today's increasingly complex work environment, the diversity of ideas encourages creativity and innovation, which can in turn drive organisational performance (Yang & Konrad, 2011; Bell, 2012). Diversity is crucial not only for organisational performance, but also for employee empowerment and motivation. When organisational members are given an opportunity to contribute their ideas, they feel appreciated, acknowledged, and valued (Danowitz, Hanappi-Egger & Mensi-Klarbach, 2012). This can increase employee commitment, loyalty, and satisfaction.
Conclusion
On the whole, while they may appear to be in conflict, both shared values and diverse ideas are essential to any organisation. Shared values promote a climate of oneness within an organisation, while diverse ideas encourage creativity and innovation. Therefore, leaders must emphasise shared values while, at the same time, encouraging diversity of ideas.
References
Bell, M. (2012). Diversity in organisations (2nd ed.). Cengage Learning.
Danowitz, M., Hanappi-Egger, E., & Mensi-Klarbach, H. (2012). Diversity in organisations: Concepts and practices. Palgrave Macmillan.
Edington, D., & Pitts, J. (2016). Shared values-shared results: Positive organisational health as a win-win philosophy. Edington Associates.
Schein, E. (2010). Organizational culture and leadership (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.
Yang, Y., & Konrad, A. (2011). Understanding diversity management practices: Implications of institutional theory and resource-based theory. Group & Organization Management, 36(1), 6–38.
Yoder-Wise, P. (2013). Leading and managing in nursing (5th ed.). Elsevier.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.