Soviet Jewish Immigration and Acculturation in Germany After 1990

Introduction

Since April 1990, over a hundred thousand Soviet Jews and those with origins in Soviet successor states have immigrated to Germany, drastically changing the culture, size, and shape of Germany's Jewish population. This immigration was unforeseen, unplanned, and unwelcome to both the Israeli and German governments as well as the majority of established German Jews (Ostow, 110). It occurred in the aftermath of the Soviet Union's dissolution and the collapse of the German Democratic Republic; once it commenced, there was no stopping it. Throughout the Cold War era, German Jews were portrayed by the print media as an anomaly or endangered species.

In February 1990, following reports of anti-Jewish uprisings within Soviet territory, a small East Berlin-based Jewish group closely linked to the Socialist Unity Party entreated the then-existing government of East Germany to grant permission for Soviet Jews to seek refuge there (Ostow, 110). This paper examines the reception and acculturation of Soviet Jews in Germany following the Soviet Union's collapse, tracing the immigration process, the policy environment, the resettlement experience, and the lasting impact on German Jewish life.

The Jewish Community in Germany Before Soviet Emigration

Ambiguity surrounds the precise demographics of Germany's Jewish population, particularly in the post-Holocaust era. Somewhat informed estimates indicate that, as of 1945, roughly 3,000 Jews may have survived across all four Allied Zones combined. This very small figure grew swiftly on account of extensive post-1945 migration from East to West: approximately 500,000 to 600,000 had fled the lethal anti-Semitism of the post-Holocaust era in Poland and other Eastern European nations (Wolffsohn, 19). Following the creation of the State of Israel, the number of these displaced persons decreased. A rather small number — around 30,000 — continued to reside in Germany, perceiving future dealings with the nation's non-Jewish population as a profound challenge.

From 1946 to 1949, around 1,000 long-time intellectual Communists returned to what they believed to be a "better Germany." By 1953, however, most Jews residing in East Germany had left the country. The state of this "better Germany" deteriorated, and, along with the remaining Soviet-governed nations, it persecuted the Jewish community from late 1948 until Stalin's death in March 1953 (Wolffsohn, 21). By the time the Berlin Wall fell, a mere 400 Jews still resided in Germany, with about three-quarters of them living in East Berlin. Jewish communities outside East Berlin comprised only a few dozen individuals, several of whom were elderly. The Jewish influx from Russia in the early 1990s helped avert a structural collapse of German Jewry altogether.

Before the Berlin Wall's fall in 1989 — the point at which this essay's central narrative begins — Jews had started to lead somewhat better lives in Germany, though the situation remained difficult. Between 20,000 and 30,000 Jews resided in West Germany (the Federal Republic), 6,000 in Berlin, roughly 500 in East Germany (the German Democratic Republic), and 200 in East Berlin (Peck, 40–41). The majority were elderly and dwindling in number. Soon, however, borders opened, the Soviet Union collapsed, and in the wake of these decisive events of 1989–90, Jewish migrants flooded the nation. Few observers understood how dramatically this population shift would save German Jewry from near-extinction, transforming it into Europe's third-largest Jewish community and the world's fastest-growing.

Roughly 220,000 Jews of Soviet origin migrated to unified Germany from 1991 to 2013. Of these, only 50 percent joined Jewish communities, congregations, or other formal Jewish institutions. These statistics reflect the profound numeric transformation stemming from Germany's reunification and the emergence of a novel, second, and now dominant German Jewish stratum. From the near-ashes of German Jewry — essentially destroyed by 1945 through flight and death — and the narrow stratum of post-Holocaust Jewish immigration from Poland into West Berlin and West Germany, there arose a second and dominant stratum composed of migrants who had grown up in the atheist Soviet environment and were largely unfamiliar with their religious traditions (Wolffsohn, 20). These so-called "New-New" Jews in Germany were Halachically Jewish in many instances, yet were spiritually and culturally distant from virtually all expressions of Jewish religious practice.

Soviet Jewish Immigration to Germany in the 1990s

In February 1990, following reports of anti-Jewish uprisings within Soviet territory, a small East Berlin-based Jewish group closely linked to the Socialist Unity Party entreated the East German government to permit Soviet Jews to seek refuge there (Ostow, 110). Since April 1990, over a hundred thousand Soviet Jews and nationals of Soviet successor states have immigrated to Germany, fundamentally altering the culture, size, and character of the German Jewish population. This immigration was unforeseen, unplanned, and opposed by both the Israeli and German governments and the majority of established German Jews. It unfolded in the aftermath of the Soviet Union's dissolution and that of the German Democratic Republic; once it began, it proved unstoppable.

The mass migration of Russian Jews in 1990 was directed primarily toward Israel and the United States. However, several thousand also made Germany their home. Some chose Germany over America or Israel because the country represented one of Eastern Europe's key economic powerhouses, offering substantial economic opportunity. Others were drawn by Germany's proximity to Russia and its familiar European cultural environment. Still others favored Germany because it appeared more secure than the State of Israel; harrowing accounts of Jews being murdered in Israeli cafes and buses dissuaded many from emigrating there, while Germany offered the financial and personal security they had found lacking in Russia (Peck, 42).

Some migrants arrived in Germany almost accidentally, owing to the peculiarities and complications of the immigration process and entry procedures through Rome or Vienna. Another factor was Germany's liberal policy of accepting former Soviet Jews and the appeal of residing in a European Union member state with a robust democratic system. Eventually, Germany also encouraged Soviet Jews to reckon with their responsibility toward the memory of the Holocaust. Following the Soviet collapse of 1991, Germany formulated a more formal and liberal Jewish immigration policy (Peck, 43).

In early June 1990, the German Democratic Republic's Council of Ministers agreed that previously persecuted individuals and their descendants were entitled to return to Germany (Ostow, 110). This concession to an almost-marginalized elite population gained political significance in the GDR's final months. The government of Lothar de Maizière, desperately seeking legitimacy in its waning days, drew on the rhetoric of the Republic's anti-Fascist tradition to reaffirm the state's role as a refuge for those victimized by and resistant to Hitler. During the spring and summer of 1990, roughly forty Soviet Jews were arriving in East Berlin each week and being cared for by several local East Berlin organizations.

By autumn, West Berlin's Jewish community had assumed organizational oversight. By mid-September, with German reunification approaching, West Germany's Soviet consulates were ordered to cease processing Jewish migrant applications; East Germany was advised to do likewise. On October 2 of that year, West Germany's borders were formally closed to Jews of Soviet origin. Nevertheless, until year's end, Soviet Jews continued to enter illegally or semi-legally — for instance, by being invited to visit relatives already in the country (Ostow, 111).

At the end of 1990, the president of Berlin's Jewish community and of Germany's Central Jewish Council assembled a staff of social workers and administrators to serve Soviet migrant Jews, publicly insisting that they be allowed to enter Germany outside normal quota restrictions and be permitted to reside in the country. This position was maintained despite pressure from both the Israeli and German governments and from a significant segment of established Jewish community members.

Conclusion

Roughly 220,000 Jews of Soviet origin migrated to unified Germany from 1991 to 2013. Several opted for Germany over America or Israel owing to the country's economic opportunities, its proximity to Russia, or the perception that it was safer than the State of Israel. The immigration of Soviet Jews to Germany was unforeseen, unplanned, and unwelcome to both the Israeli and German governments as well as the majority of established German Jews. Of those who arrived, only 50 percent joined Jewish communities, congregations, or other formal Jewish institutions. The influx generated financial, psychological, and emotional tensions, prompting the German government to introduce requirements that constrained the previously unrestricted flow of immigrants.

For Soviet Jews, Germany ultimately offered an opportunity and the conditions necessary for reconnecting with their Jewish heritage — even, in some cases, for the children of mixed-heritage families and those living with non-Jewish spouses. For many, culture replaced the religious engagement they had rejected or been excluded from. Compared with the overall German population, Jews remain a small minority in Germany today, though they are now acknowledged and heard by at least some Germans. The legacy of this migration wave is thus deeply ambivalent: it saved German Jewry from near-extinction and produced one of Europe's largest Jewish communities, yet it also created lasting tensions around identity, authenticity, and the meaning of Jewish belonging in post-Holocaust Germany.

Becker, Franziska. "Migration and Recognition: Russian Jews in Germany." East European Jewish Affairs 33.2 (2003): 20–34.

Ben-Rafael, Eliezer. "10. Russian-Speaking Jews in Germany." The New Jewish Diaspora. Rutgers University Press, 2016. 173–185.

---. "Germany's Russian-Speaking Jews." Being Jewish in 21st-Century Germany 16 (2015): 63.

Kotowski, Elke-Vera. "Moving from the Present via the Past to Look toward the Future." Being Jewish in 21st-Century Germany 16 (2015): 103.

Ostow, Robin. "From Victims of Antisemitism to Post-Modern Hybrids: Representations of (Post) Soviet Jews in Germany." European Judaism 36.2 (2003): 110–117.

Peck, Jeffrey M. "3. Russian Immigration and the Revitalization of German Jewry." Being Jewish in the New Germany. Rutgers University Press, 2005. 40–59.

Roberman, Sveta. "Impostors of Themselves: Performing Jewishness and Revitalizing Jewish Life among Russian-Jewish Immigrants in Contemporary Germany." Social Identities 20.2–3 (2014): 199–213.

Shneer, David. "The Third Way: German–Russian–European Jewish Identity in a Global Jewish World." European Review of History 18.01 (2011): 111–121.

Weiss, Yfaat, and Lena Gorelik. "The Russian-Jewish Immigration." A History of Jews in Germany Since 1945: 379–416.

Wolffsohn, Michael. "Jews in Divided Germany (1945–1990) and Beyond." Being Jewish in 21st-Century Germany 16 (2015): 13.