Superintendent and New School Board Member Relationship
This paper examines the strategies a district superintendent should employ when building a productive working relationship with a newly elected or appointed school board member. Drawing on perspectives from experienced educators and academic literature, the paper highlights the importance of hiring the right personality from the outset, initiating early informal contact, practicing active listening, establishing honest communication norms, and maintaining a structured communication plan. The paper argues that a superintendent who proactively invests in this relationship—through transparency, respect for divergent views, and consistent follow-through—creates the conditions for effective shared governance and stronger school district leadership.
- Introduction: The Foundation of a Working Relationship: Framing mutual respect and hiring as starting points
- Early Outreach and Informal Connection: Casual early meetings to build personal rapport
- Listening, Communication, and Honesty: Why sincere listening is essential for the superintendent
- Managing Conflict and Differences of Opinion: Strategies for handling disagreements openly and quickly
- Sustaining the Relationship Through Structure and Consistency: Structured communication plans and consistent follow-through
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its practical recommendations in a real-world example — Linda Murray's eight-year experience as superintendent of the San Jose Unified School District — lending credibility to its claims.
- It moves logically from initial hiring considerations through informal rapport-building and then into ongoing communication strategies, creating a coherent arc of advice.
- The tone is appropriately direct and applied, making abstract leadership principles concrete through specific suggestions such as scheduling a casual coffee meeting or sharing upcoming proposals well in advance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the use of practitioner-sourced quotations alongside academic references to support applied recommendations. Rather than relying solely on theory, it blends an expert quotation with citations from peer-reviewed journals and a professional handbook, showing how scholarly and practitioner knowledge can reinforce one another in an education leadership argument.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by framing the general conditions for good relationships before narrowing to the superintendent–board member context. It then moves through a sequence of practical strategies: early informal outreach, active listening, honest conflict management, transparency about proposals, and a sustained communication plan. A bibliography of journal articles and a practitioner handbook provides sourcing. The conclusion ties structure to outcome — consistent communication yields both personal rapport and effective leadership.
Introduction: The Foundation of a Working Relationship
People develop good relationships through mutual respect, genuine connection, and shared interests. When a working relationship must also be established, courtesy, diplomacy, and acceptance become equally important. So it is with a district superintendent attempting to build a solid relationship with a new school board member.
The process of making this new relationship work should ideally begin when the board hires the superintendent in the first place. Selecting the right personality from the outset is crucial. As school superintendents are expected to lead collaboratively, their interpersonal skills matter as much as their administrative competence.
Linda Murray, an eight-year superintendent of the San Jose Unified School District in California, argues that respect and attentive listening are the keys: "I think a great deal of it, of any relationship, is the relationship itself — being a good listener, being able to appreciate and respect the divergent views of the board members and trying to build a consensus through a lot of discussion and dialogue" (Pascopella, 2001).
References
Eadie, D. (2007). A precious but fragile bond. American School Board Journal, 194(3), 50–51.
Eadie, D. (2008). An indispensable partnership. American School Board Journal, 195(10), 52–53.
Pascopella, A. (2001, June). Working together. Curriculum Administrator, 37(6), 40–42.
Townsend, R. S., Johnston, G. L., Gross, G. E., Lynch, P., Garcy, L. M., Roberts, B. B., et al. (2006). Effective superintendent–school board practices: Strategies for developing and maintaining good relationships with your board. Corwin Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.