How TV News Agencies Select Stories and Determine News Value
This paper examines how television news agencies select stories and determine what qualifies as "newsworthy." Drawing on McGregor's (2002) framework, it analyzes four core news values — visualness, emotional draw, conflict, and the celebrification of journalists — and explains how each shapes editorial decisions. The paper argues that news selection is driven not purely by journalistic integrity but by a combination of audience engagement, advertising revenue, and the cultivation of viewer trust and loyalty. It also addresses the tension between journalists' self-perception as neutral reporters and their considerable power to define and frame the news.
- Introduction: What Gets on Television News: Commercial and sensational forces drive story selection
- The Power to Create News: Journalists shape reality by defining newsworthiness
- Visualness as a News Value: Visual appeal determines what airs on television
- Emotional Draw and Viewer Loyalty: Emotional bonds keep audiences returning to outlets
- Conflict and Audience Justification: Conflict attracts viewers seeking belief confirmation
- The Celebrification of Journalists: Celebrity reporters lend credibility to news stories
- Conclusion: The Alchemy of Newsworthiness: Multiple forces combine to shape final news decisions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Applies a clear theoretical framework — McGregor's four news values — and uses it consistently throughout, giving the argument structural coherence.
- Balances abstract claims about media behavior with concrete examples, such as the 9/11 news coverage, to ground abstract arguments in recognizable events.
- Maintains a critical but measured tone, acknowledging journalists' self-defense while pointing out the structural forces that shape their choices.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates analytical synthesis: it takes a theoretical model from one source (McGregor's news values) and uses secondary sources (Milgrom and Schudson) to corroborate and extend the argument. Rather than summarizing each source separately, the writer integrates them to build a layered explanation of how commercial, psychological, and institutional forces converge in news selection decisions.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the commercial logic of television news, then introduces the concept of journalistic power. It proceeds section by section through McGregor's four news values — visualness, emotion, conflict, and celebrification — devoting a paragraph to each before synthesizing them in the conclusion. This scaffolded structure ensures each news value receives focused treatment before the final integrative argument.
Introduction: What Gets on Television News
The selection of news stories in the television media is a relatively straightforward process shaped by both commercial and editorial pressures. Depending on the motivation of the news agency or channel, the media will report different stories in different ways. The stories that make it on television are commonly the most abrasive, controversial, and emotionally engaging ones available. If they were not interesting to the target audience, viewership would suffer and the channel would lose its ability to sell advertising space effectively. The television news channel must function partly as an advertiser: as people tune in to keep tabs on the world around them, they are simultaneously exposed to viewpoints and products promoted during news segments.
Another factor in what makes the news is a story's level of sensationalism. Many people, to one degree or another, live vicariously through others they observe — whether celebrities, sports stars, or other public figures. People feel a need to stay in touch with those they admire. The stories that are most interesting or sensational on a basic human level — those that often involve sex, drugs, scandals, or other innately compelling human experiences — are most frequently the ones conveyed by television news agencies.
The Power to Create News
People are often critical of journalists as a whole, frequently referring to them as sensationalists or exaggerators of the truth. While this characterization may sometimes hold, journalists themselves are generally offended by such accusations. They often argue that although exaggerations and aberrations do occur, a news journalist never fabricates a story outright (Schudson, 1989, 263). This may be true; however, the fabrication of a news story does not carry as much social impact as the creation of a news story does. The power to construct legitimate news from sometimes dubious sources is far greater than the power to invent one outright.
The creation of a news story by the media — and the act of defining what news is — are both enormously powerful tools that television news journalists wield in the modern era. Modern real-time news, covering events as they unfold, has become the norm for most television news channels and programs. Yet the emergence of this type of coverage has had little effect on what is fundamentally considered "newsworthy." For hundreds of years, the same types of news and social dialogue have been widely regarded as newsworthy. The technologies surrounding these events have changed, but the exposure of the basic human condition has remained a central part of news coverage throughout the centuries. There are, however, a few distinct news values that have come to the surface in recent times as news has begun to cover live events. According to author Judy McGregor, these values are visualness, emotion, conflict, and the "celebrification" of the journalist (McGregor, 2002, 3). Together they form the formula within which most major news outlets operate when deciding what is newsworthy.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.