Washington vs. Jefferson: Federal Power and Internal Improvements
This paper examines the contrasting political philosophies of George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, focusing on the concept of "internal improvements" — public works programs designed to promote security, prosperity, and civic development in the early republic. Despite sharing similar backgrounds as Virginia gentleman-farmers of the "monied gentry," the two founders diverged sharply on the proper role of the federal government. Washington, shaped by his Revolutionary War experience and extensive travel, believed human nature was fundamentally self-interested and that strong federal intervention was necessary. Jefferson, by contrast, trusted in the innate capacity of citizens to govern themselves when freed from oppressive authority. The paper traces how these philosophical differences played out in debates over roads, canals, the National Bank, and the Louisiana Purchase.
- Introduction: Two Founders, Two Visions: Thesis contrasting Washington and Jefferson on federal power
- Development of Beliefs Among the Monied Gentry: Shared aristocratic background of the founding elite
- Washington's View of Human Nature and Internal Improvements: Washington's skepticism of citizens and federal solutions
- Jefferson's Philosophy and Opposition to Federal Power: Jefferson's trust in citizens and limits on government
- Internal Improvement Projects and the Constitutional Debate: Policy clashes over roads, banks, and public works
- Conclusion: The Legacy of Federalism: Federalism as temporary necessity now worth reconsidering
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The thesis is clearly stated and directly contrasts the two founders' beliefs about human nature as the root cause of their political disagreements — giving the paper a specific, arguable central claim.
- The paper grounds abstract philosophical differences in concrete historical examples, such as the Potomac River Canal, the National Bank, and the Louisiana Purchase, connecting ideas to real policy outcomes.
- The shared background of the two figures (Virginia, gentleman-farmer class) is established first, making their divergence more analytically meaningful and historically credible.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective comparative analysis by establishing a common baseline (shared class, background, and republican values) before isolating the specific variable — views on human nature — that explains their divergent positions. This technique prevents oversimplification and shows how subtle philosophical differences can produce dramatically different political outcomes.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical context and a stated thesis, then provides shared biographical background before splitting into separate treatments of Washington's and Jefferson's beliefs. It connects each founder's philosophy to specific internal improvement debates before closing with a brief reflection on the long-term relevance of Federalist institutions. The structure is largely chronological and thematic, moving from belief formation to policy application.
Introduction: Two Founders, Two Visions
George Washington and Thomas Jefferson are perhaps the most revered of the Founding Fathers. Even during their own time, they were regarded as the leaders of the fledgling republic before they became the heads of their respective political parties. Their beliefs and actions established a political struggle that has persisted to this day, with debates as lively as those that took place during the framing of the Constitution.
Washington and Jefferson's respective beliefs took on special significance in the area of "internal improvements." As historian John Larson uses the term, "internal improvement" refers to all kinds of public works programs designed to encourage security, prosperity, and enlightenment among the people — a concept central to early American political life. Internal improvements implicated both leaders because of the heavy involvement they required of the federal government.
The central argument of this paper is that Washington and Jefferson adopted opposing positions on the role of the federal government because they held fundamentally different views about human nature. Washington believed the average person was selfish and would not do the right thing independently, and therefore that the federal government had to act in the public interest when individuals would not. Jefferson believed that the average person was capable of becoming a good citizen if given the space and abundance necessary to cultivate himself — a condition he viewed as impossible under an overly powerful federal government.
Development of Beliefs Among the Monied Gentry
Thomas Jefferson and George Washington had much in common. They were both from Virginia, owned large farms, and practiced the doctrine of self-sufficiency. Throughout their lives, both men were curiously reluctant to accumulate personal power. In a sense, they were true aristocrats, embodying the ideal of the gentleman-farmer.
Washington referred to men like Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and himself as part of a distinct social class — the "monied gentry." According to Larson, this class "assumed a right to lead based on superior knowledge, patriotic feeling, and what they called their 'wisdom.'" Indeed, many men of this class were genuinely brilliant. They were not only intellectual elites relative to their American countrymen but also the equals of the great statesmen and philosophers of their day in Europe — figures comparable to Locke, Hobbes, and de Tocqueville.
In addition to their intellectual gifts, the monied gentry were uniquely industrious, paternalistic, and patriotic. The Republican experiment was, in a sense, their great project — a creation in need of nurturing and guidance that only they believed they could provide. They truly cared for the welfare of the American people, though they likely cared even more deeply about the success of the Republican experiment itself.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.