Ethical and Legal Aspects of Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Mudra did not act according to this principle when he ignored the warning signs of Daniel's condition.

The best course of action would therefore have been a focus on beneficence/non-maleficence rather than upon respect for autonomy. Daniel's age is also an important factor. Concomitantly with his condition, Daniel's immaturity and a desire to "prove" his independence to his parents, could have contributed to his death. When treating such young persons, it is perhaps advisable to place emphasis upon non-maleficence rather than respect for autonomy. In terms of these two principles, it would be acceptable for the parents to complain.

In terms of scope, the final principle, justice, is not as applicable to Daniel's case itself as it is to his parents. The parents feel aggrieved by the practitioner's lack of in-depth knowledge and action regarding Daniel's condition. They are seeking justice for themselves, but it is too late for such justice to extend to their son. While Daniel was alive, there was little dispute regarding this principle, as all involved were in consent to respect Daniel's autonomy. This principle is therefore not as applicable as the others where Daniel himself is concerned.

The utilitarianism framework requires the most happiness for the most amount of people involved. Although Daniel's parents did not approve of his treatment later during the six-month cycle at the end of his life, they allowed him to continue as he insisted that doing so made him happy. Clearly this was not the case, and the outcome is that all remaining parties are unhappy.

The utilitarian approach would have required that changes be made from the fifth month of Daniel's treatment. Although Daniel would not have been happy about terminating his treatment, his relative misery is outweighed by the ultimate joy of everyone to know that he was still alive.

The deontological framework requires an almost slavish obedience to a set of rules. In this case, the Ethical Code of the Institute of Medical Herbalists were followed. The medical practitioner upheld the respect for autonomy, and remained silent about any warning signs that might have appeared. The respect for autonomy and the view of Daniel as a grownup were maintained. This was done despite the fact that, in many ways, Daniel was not able to make his own decisions. The result was disaster. Deontology therefore had disastrous consequences for Daniel, but could be beneficial for the parents. In the NIMH ethical codes, specific rules are prescribed for cases against personnel. The parents can used either this or formal legal services to determine if this was indeed a case of wrongful and preventable death. While utilitarianism is no longer possible, as Daniel's death has already impacted his family, deontology can at least be used to create some form of satisfaction.

In terms of the legal framework, there are several services that can be used to enforce a relatively satisfactory outcome for Daniel's parents. On the other hand, the existing laws relating to complementary medicine and healing are inadequate to handle the many difficult ethical issues people face today. Complementary Medicine and the Law by Julie Stone and Joan Matthews for example calls for greater regulation where complementary medicine is concerned. The herbalist's charter for example dates back as far as 1542. Surely times have changed since then, as women who practice medicine are no longer burned as witches.

From a legal and ethical viewpoint, Mr. Mudra should have terminated treatment as soon as he realized that it was no longer effective for Daniel's condition. He should also have recognized his specific lack of expertise and the potential harm it could cause, even inadvertently. Concomitantly, Daniel's parents should also take some of the responsibility for their son. Nobody knew him as well as they did. It appeared that they had a good working relationship with the herbalist. They should therefore have discussed the matter with him as soon as they realized their could be a problem. Both herbalist and parents are therefore at fault for the death of Daniel. It should however also be realized that Daniel may well have committed suicide regardless of any interventions and indeed perhaps even because of them. Being unpredictable, Daniel's reaction to a change in a therapy that he preferred may have similarly led to a violent reaction. Nonetheless, this should have been closely observed by a professional in the field. The parents need to understand that it was also their shared responsibility to ensure the health of their son. On the other hand, the therapist was working with Daniel on a daily basis, and should have realized when there was a turn in events.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, no ethical issue or legal act is every universally applicable to all cases, even if they are of the same kind. Individual factors determine the best actions to take. In Daniel's case, a number of issues can be highlighted. In terms of the four principles, beneficence and maleficence take precedence of respect for autonomy for two main reasons: the first relates to Daniel's age. Although he is legally able to make autonomous decisions, he is still very young and such decisions should receive appropriate guidance, especially in life and death situations. The second reason relates to Daniel's condition, which is mental. A mental condition typically impairs judgment. Daniel, his parents, and this therapist should all have been aware of this before changing his therapy in the first place. Deontology has been followed here, but a utilitarian approach would have been better suited. Although miserable at first, Daniel would at least have lived if he had not been allowed to continue with the herbal therapy.

Finally, any ethical issues within human society tend to be complicated. Mistakes will occur and medical professionals run a continuous risk of losing their reputation or earnings via law suits. In a case such as Daniel's it is therefore difficult to say whether it is truly ethical for the parents to sue when they played a significant part in the outcome of their son's treatment. Professionals should however understand their duties to their patients and act accordingly.

Bibliography

Stone, J. (2002) an ethical framework for complementary and alternative therapists.

Routledge.

Applebe, G. & Wingfield, J. (1997) Applebe's Pharmacy law and ethics. The Pharmaceutical Press

Gillon, R. & Lloyd, a. (eds.) (1993). Principles of health care ethics. Wiley.

Gillon R. (1994, 16 July). Four principles of medical ethics and attention to scope. BMJ. Vol. 209, Iss. 184. http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/309/6948/184

Kennedy, I. And Grubb, a. (1994) Medical law: Text with material. London: Butterworths.

Mason, K. And McCall Smith, a. (2002) Law and medical ethics. Sixth edition. London:

Butterworths.

National Institute of Medical Herbalists (1991) Code of ethics: Code of practice: Disciplinary procedure. Exeter: NIMH.

Stone, J. And Matthews, J. (1996) Complementary medicine and the law.…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Ethical And Legal Aspects Of" (2009, February 20) Retrieved December 9, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethical-and-legal-aspects-of-74038

"Ethical And Legal Aspects Of" 20 February 2009. Web.9 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethical-and-legal-aspects-of-74038>

"Ethical And Legal Aspects Of", 20 February 2009, Accessed.9 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/ethical-and-legal-aspects-of-74038

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Clinical Ethical and Legal Aspects of Biomedical

    clinical, ethical and legal aspects of biomedical decision-making ( with an example of case related to healthcare clinical, ethical and legal issue involved and as an admistrator what is my standpoint? Biomedicine involves various facets. To be a successful practitioner in this filed one needs to know not only the distinctions between each but also possess a basic knowledge of the principles of each. The three categories of biomedical decision

  • Ethical and Legal Perspectives in

    Bans save cash. It is costly to encourage smoking in prisons. Smoke-harmed detainees and staff require costly medical care, for different tobacco impacts. Citizens pay, both by expanded duties, and by expanded insurance rates. The prison authorities must raise the issue with government officials and ask them how much smoking costs citizens. When inmates smoke in jail, more bills, hospital expenses, come to citizens: for the smokers' conditions, and

  • Legal Aspects of Medical Errors Various Factors

    Legal Aspects of Medical Errors Various factors in the health care system are reported to be contributors to medication errors. This work reviews a case study discussed in 'Hospital Pharmacy' (Smetzer and Cohen, 1998) which provides a clear example of the complex nature of the health care system and the process of medication use and how this interrelates to medication safety and quality. The nurse made the decision to administer the

  • Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology

    Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology All psychologists are required to follow the ethical guidelines found in the 2002 Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct of the American Psychological Association (APA), commonly known as the Ethics Code. Other important ethical guidelines are found in the 2007 Competing Development Achievement Levels (DALs) of the National Council of Schools and Programs in Professional Psychology (NCSPP) and the Assessment of Competing Benchmarks Work

  • Ethical and Legal Perspectives in

    It might also involve taking a simple approach to save cash rather than initiating appropriate strategies to increase profits, this is unjust. Increasing premiums despite increasing profit margins at the expense of more uninsured people, as they cannot afford the rise is unjust. Injured patients who are loaded with the expenses of avoidable damage or compelled to sue indeed, when there is no carelessness is unjustifiable to both physicians

  • Ethical and Legal Perspectives in

    In any case, patients can set out defined clause in the Power of Attorney telling operators how they might like them to act with respect to deathbed issues (Edge & Krieger, 2008). Response 2 Living wills and other development directives depict a patient's inclination with respect to medicine if the patient is confronted with a genuine mishap or disease. These authoritative reports represent the patient when he/she is not ready to

  • Legal Aspects and Considerations

    Legal Aspects and Considerations "Coaches should pursue opportunities for professional development to keep abreast of best practices, safety, and legal issues within their chosen sport(s)" (Schaefer, 2008, Risk Management Tips Section, ¶ 5). Challenges for Coaches During 2006, Bill Baker, a Sahuarita High School football coach in Chandler, Arizona resigned from his coaching position following a 2005 post-game incident which involved him and a player the previous fall. In the newspaper account, "Coach


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved