Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Indeed, Russell does not say there is no God, he merely says he is not convinced the Christian God is the correct version of an absolute beginning and end. As a philosopher, Russell finds much to be convinced about the moral validity of Christ. but, if in Christ we have the epitome of morality and goodness, then are there not universals of quality that are imbedded in other great people: Buddha, Lao-Tse, etc. If Christ is the Church, why are Christ's principles not universally practiced?
For Copleston, though, the world cannot exist without a first cause, and although that first cause is unpredictable, only the existence of God makes sense of human's moral and religious experiences and drive for understanding. The idea of God is based not just on empirical proof -- but on results. Thus, one must have faith in order to believe; faith is individual and is not proven true or false in all situations.
Russell notes that the Christian idea is that if humans can conceive...
This is reminiscent of a famous quote by the German philosopher Nietzsche, "If horses had gods, gods would be horses." Of course, humans perceive God in a certain way because humans think in a certain way. How would we conceive of something in a non-human way? For Copleston, however, God's existence is not a logical argument, but a metaphysical argument and one based on the results of creation.
As in the debate, neither side clearly "won." Humans will likely continue to ask "why are we here," and "how did we get here," because we have the capacity to ask such things. It seems we are psychologically wired to need a belief system that allows us to understand where we have been and where we are going. Thus, the debate about God will likely continue to be contentious and unsolved.
Source:
The Existence of God Debate. (1948). British Broadcasting Company. Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXPdpEJk78E
As in the debate, neither side clearly "won." Humans will likely continue to ask "why are we here," and "how did we get here," because we have the capacity to ask such things. It seems we are psychologically wired to need a belief system that allows us to understand where we have been and where we are going. Thus, the debate about God will likely continue to be contentious and unsolved.
Source:
The Existence of God Debate. (1948). British Broadcasting Company. Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXPdpEJk78E
God Exist? The Case for God's Existence Anselm Thomas Aquinas Other Arguments The Case Against the Existence of God My Assessment Many people go to churches, mosques, and synagogs each week to worship God and to pray. But does God hear those prayers? Does he exist? The debate over God's existence has gone on for centuries and is alive and well in our time. Philosophers, theologians, scientists, and ordinary people have weighed in on the argument.
Existence of God The philosophical questions I will try to answer and why they are of particular interest to me. Opinions that ordinary people tend to have on the issue The great monotheistic religions of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam profoundly influenced Western philosophy. In all of these religions, the existence of God is a central claim. For nearly a millennium from 500 S.D to about 1500 A.D., Western philosophy was the handmaiden
God and Creation Has the concept of God well and truly woven itself into the very psyche of the average American citizen? What exactly does the average American think about God? As a matter of fact, each and every American must take some time to sit back and think deeply about these issues, and also pay close attention to the power and influence of God in the history of America. Perhaps
God Given Rights: Understanding America's Equality and Freedom The poem "On Being Brought to America" by Phillis Wheatley and The Declaration of Independence written by Thomas Jefferson share similarities on the ideals that America possesses. Each of these writings argues for their God given rights, claiming every person is equal. Each must start new: One as a Christian, the others as a government. It is the bravery and the challenge in these
The Cosmological Argument: This argument begins with the tenet that for the Universe to exist something outside the universe must have created it. Also refereed to as the First Cause or the Uncaused Cause theory, here God exists as the prime mover that brought the universe into existence. The universe is a series of events, which began with God who must exist apart from the universe, outside of time and
If it cannot be effectively proven that God does not exist, then God apparently does exist. In fact, the lack of proof for atheism can be used as direct proof in the existence of God. "It is much easier to be persuaded that ontological arguments are no good than it is to say exactly what is wrong with them," (Oppy). The apparent manifest multiplicity of the universe is further proof