Burglary Statute And Case Case Study

PAGES
3
WORDS
860
Cite
Related Topics:

Burglary Case

Facts

Jimmy Stewart, a renowned Hollywood star, purchased a get-away cabin in western Virginia. Jimmy intended to use the cabin, which was located in the deep woods, at least once per month for long weekends. He assigned an interior designer to buy furniture for his ten rooms and equipped most of the rooms including the kitchen and bedroom. The kitchen had a table and chair as well as cooking and eating utensils while he had a mattress and blankets in one of the rooms. However, Jimmy lost his prestigious status in Hollywood, was broke, and ended up moving to Japan for a sit-com role. Following his move to Japan, Jimmys plan to use the cabin each month was never fully realized. After an initial three monthly visits, Jimmy did not use the cabin for two years. Nonetheless, the house still had electricity, water, and some foodstuff in the refrigerator.

Burglars broke into Jimmys cabin and stole everything in the basement storage area. The sheriff of the local county had arrested one of the burglars named Black Jack Smith. He was arrested when he attempted to sell some of the furniture stolen from the house at a local police bazaar. He was charged and convicted of burglary under Code Ann. 18.2-89 (1950). Through his attorney, Swifty Lazaar, Black Jack appealed the courts ruling grounds that Jimmys cabin was not a dwelling house.

Issue

Should Jimmys cabin, at the time of the burglary, be considered a dwelling house pursuant to Code 18.2-89?

Analogous Case

In Giles v. Commonwealth (2009), the court held that a house is regarded as a dwelling house, under Code 18.2-89, when it is used for habitation including periodic habitation. Moreover, the court argues that the burglary...…for a house to be considered a dwelling house. So, it does not matter whether Jimmy used the house daily, weekly, or monthly. Therefore, the frequency of use is not a requirement to determine whether Jimmys cabin was a dwelling house.

Conclusion

Pursuant to Code 18.2-89, Jimmys cabin is considered a dwelling house at the time of the burglary. There is sufficient evidence to prove that Jimmys cabin was a dwelling house at the time of the incident. Therefore, Black Jacks guilty verdict should be upheld by the Court of Appeals.

Based on the burglary statute, a house used for habitation is a dwelling house. Moreover, a house does not lose its dwelling status simply because an individual is absent for either a regular or irregular time period. Periodic habitation of a house does not necessitate that the residence is used at regular periods of time as…

Cite this Document:

"Burglary Statute And Case" (2022, August 07) Retrieved May 18, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/burglary-statute-case-case-study-2179309

"Burglary Statute And Case" 07 August 2022. Web.18 May. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/burglary-statute-case-case-study-2179309>

"Burglary Statute And Case", 07 August 2022, Accessed.18 May. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/burglary-statute-case-case-study-2179309

Related Documents

Burglary -- History, Definition, and Hypothetical Case According to Common Law, burglary was identified as the breaking and entering the premises of another person's inhabitance with the purpose of committing a crime there. It can thus be associated with ideas like the act of entering a person's house without his or her permission and the act of committing a crime at the respective location. Individuals perceived a person's house as the place

Burglary Robbery Homicide
PAGES 6 WORDS 2366

Burglary, Robbery, Homicide Burglary, robbery and homicide are all criminal activities directed against the average man. There is never a specific indication as to the person who is going to fall as the next victim, and thus every individual needs to know what precautions should be taken. Since we are discussing three different types of crimes, the analysis is also spread up in three different sub-sections -- Burglary, Robbery and Homicide. Burglary

Burglary Investigations
PAGES 5 WORDS 1758

Burglary investigations [...] theory of burglary investigations, how "surveillance" is part of the stakeout, how to look for a suspect, how fingerprinting is a part of the investigation, and will distinguish between the different types of burglaries, i.e.: First-degree; Second-degree, etc. based on using a weapon or not. It will also discuss the degrees of penalty, and how burglaries differ between day and night. BURGLARY INVESTIGATIONS Burglary is one of the

crime rate data of burglaries in two U.S. metropolitan localities. The UCR (Uniform Crime Reporting) Program of the Federal Bureau of Investigation describes the act of burglary as illegal entry into a structure for committing theft or a felony. For labeling a crime as burglary, it is not necessary for the element of 'forced entry'. UCR provides three sub-categories of burglary: forced entry; non-forced, illegal entry; and attempted forced entry.

Corporate crime is (is not) like burglary. Corporate crime is like burglary. Both crimes are about the taking of property to satisfy personal greed. Both types of crime involve using stealth to avoid attracting attention during the commission of the crime. Both often involve the use of deception to make the criminal activity appear legitimate to an observer. Both crimes often involve abusing a position of trust, such as accountant, or