Counseling Theories & 8230;THERE Is No Thesis

Length: 8 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Psychology Type: Thesis Paper: #41114157 Related Topics: Personal Counseling Theory, Psychoanalytic Theory, Object Relations Theory, Hiroshima
Excerpt from Thesis :

& #8230; in its heyday there was elitism and arrogance among psychoanalysts, a sense of having superior knowledge that set us up for a fall" (Altman, ¶ 3). In a field that claims to possess knowledge of the unconscious, Altman asserts, this constitutes an occupational hazard. To counter the temptation to feel more knowledgeable than others, whether patients or the public in general, therapists who practice psychoanalytic therapy, need to remember that the depths of their own unconscious realms are as unfathomable as those they treat.

Psychoanalysis, nevertheless, possesses particularly valuable offerings, despite numerous attacks on meaning. Due to the fact that people currently, continuing to move faster and faster as they pursue success and security. Consequently, "thoughtfulness and self-reflection get crowded out. People are instrumentalized, working around the clock, on their cell phones and e-mail and Blackberries, allowing themselves to be exploited in the service of the corporate bottom line" (Altman, 2007, ¶ 4). A recent study related in the New York Times and Newsweek, regarding the treatment of depression, found antidepressant medication alone proved superior to psychotherapy alone. The addition of psychotherapy, nevertheless, complemented the efficacy of the medication. One individual who conducted the study contends that as people currently do not have time for psychotherapy; in turn, medication proves to be effective.

In the journal publication, "Whatever happened to symptom substitution?" Warren W. Tryon (2008), Fordham University, Department of Psychology, Bronx, New York, Tryon (2008) examines the empirical evidence for symptom substitution. Tryon contends that without psychoanalytic intervention, a person's ongoing unconscious conflict, will not resolve itself. Tryon explains: "A neurotic symptom is held to be a compromise formed in response to an unresolved conflict between a forbidden unconscious impulse and the ego's defense against it (Tryon, 2008, p. 964)." According to this perception, the symptom is held to be persistent at any time by a coexisting symptom.

Hence, Tryon (2008) argues, if the individual's repressed unconscious wish is not psychoanalytically lifted, the person's underlying neurosis will continue, even if/when his/her therapy smothers the particular symptom the neurosis evidences at the time. While the neurotic conflict persists, the patient's psyche will recall the defensive service the banished symptom.that was previously rendered. Consequently, particularly in severe cases, "the unresolved conflict ought to engender a new symptom" (Tryon, 2008, p. 964). Fifty or so years ago, symptom substitution constituted a significant scientific and clinical question. Concerns regarding this issue, however, were abandoned rather than answered as some contended that it did not seem to occur. In addition, a number of perceived methodological problems hampered empirical research.

Tryon (2008) initially concludes that the reviewed empirical evidence supports the immense exaggeration of clinical concerns regarding the perils of symptom substitution and argues that his study did not reveal clear evidence of symptom substitution. Nevertheless, although the scientific method cannot confirm that symptom substitution is nonexistent, "the lack of credible evidence for it over more than half a century combined with the motivation by psychoanalytic proponents to find and report such evidence strongly suggests that supportive evidence is unlikely to be forthcoming" (Tryon, 2008, p. 967). In regard to symptom substitution, Tryon purports:

The contemporary relevance of the symptom substitution question is that the psychodynamic perspective continues to be widely taught in both Psy.D. And Ph.D. programs. Freud introduced his psychodynamic model of psychopathology, symptom formation, and psychotherapy to America in 1909 during his invited Clark University lectures. This was the only psychological model of


This view compels the corollary conviction that effective psychotherapies must address underlying psychological issues in order to produce lasting results. (Tryyon, 2008, p. 964)

In 1948, 39 years after Freud introduced his psychodynamic model of psychopathology, the American Psychological Association began to accredit clinical training programs. These programs "had to demonstrate that their students were receiving training in psychopathology which meant that their training was based on the psychodynamic model of psychopathology and symptom formation" (Tryyon, 2008, p. 965). In time, even though numerous models in/for training have been introduced, nevertheless, numerous contemporary clinical psychology training programs continue to confirm and communicate the psychodynamic perspective; some to a greater than others.

In psychoanalytic therapy, Tryon (2008) asserts symptoms can clearly be alienated from hypothesized underlying psychodynamic conflicts. The "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders & #8230; [DSM-IV] contains and codifies many psychological symptoms" (Tryyon, p. 965). Perhaps, Tryon, concludes, questioning DSM-IV diagnostic criteria relating to symptom substitution, these criteria do not compose bona fide psychoanalytic symptoms, but depict mere behaviors. If patients receiving psychoanalytic therapy do improve and symptom substitution occurs in patients who receive symptom oriented therapy, the hypothesized symptom may be considered a bone fide psychoanalytic symptom Although current literature does not demonstrate the presence of bona fide psychoanalytic symptoms, if/when psychoanalytic therapy helps these patients improve, additional ethically responsible evidence would prove supportive.

The application of psychoanalytic techniques would be appropriate and warranted, Tryon (2008) contends, only if / when the therapist empirically verifies psychoanalytic symptoms. As Freud argued for the need for psychoanalytic therapy, yet advised: "A man should not strive to eliminate his complexes but to get into accord with them, for they are legitimately what directs his conduct in the world" (Sigmund Freud Quotes, 2009). He also noted: "Being entirely honest with oneself is a good exercise" (Ibid.). Whether getting into accord with one's complexities requires psychoanalytic therapy or another type of another narrative, the researcher contends, understanding one's self seems to signify a positive starting point for both the one utilizing the therapy, as well as the one the treatment intends to help.


Altman. N. (2007). Renewing psychoanalysis for the 21st century. Psychoanalysis & Psychotherapy. Heldref Publications. Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam


Bacal, H.A. (2007). Discussion of Judy Pickles's case presentation from the perspective of psychoanalytic specificity theory. Psychoanalytic Inquiry. The Analytic Press, Inc.

Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam Research:

Bertram, K.P. (2005). Recurrent psychotic depression is treatable by psychoanalytic therapy without medication. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry. Springer Publishing

Company. Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam Research:

Gay, Peter. (2009). Sigmund Freud. Time Inc. Retrieved October 01, 2009

Hiroshima, N. (2007). Cognitive therapy and psychoanalytic psychotherapy. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynecology. Taylor & Francis Ltd. Retrieved October 01,

2009 from HighBeam Research:

Levitt, C. (2008). Comment on Waska's Is it psychoanalytic?. Canadian Journal of Psychoanalysis. Canadian Psychoanalytic Society. Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam Research:

Sigmund Freud Quotes and Quotations. (2009). Retrieved October 01, 2009

Tryon, W.W. (2008). Whatever happened to symptom substitution? Clinical Psychology Review.

Volume 28, pp. 963 -- 968. Retrieved October 1, 2009 from

Westenberger-Breuer, H. (2007). The goals of psychoanalytic treatment: Conceptual

considerations and follow-up interview evaluation with a former analysand1.

International Journal of Psychoanalysis. International Journal of Psychoanalysis.

Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam Research:

Wolitzky, D.L. (2007). The role of clinical inference in psychoanalytic case formulation.…

Sources Used in Documents:


Altman. N. (2007). Renewing psychoanalysis for the 21st century. Psychoanalysis & Psychotherapy. Heldref Publications. Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam


Bacal, H.A. (2007). Discussion of Judy Pickles's case presentation from the perspective of psychoanalytic specificity theory. Psychoanalytic Inquiry. The Analytic Press, Inc.

Retrieved October 01, 2009 from HighBeam Research:

Cite this Document:

"Counseling Theories & 8230 THERE Is No" (2009, October 02) Retrieved October 25, 2021, from

"Counseling Theories & 8230 THERE Is No" 02 October 2009. Web.25 October. 2021. <>

"Counseling Theories & 8230 THERE Is No", 02 October 2009, Accessed.25 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Counseling Theories
Words: 2191 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 31525156

Counseling Theory Existential therapy, person-centered therapy, and gestalt therapy all fall under the rubric of humanistic psychology. They share a considerable amount of theory, philosophy, and practice. Yet each of these practices is stemmed in its own theoretical framework; therefore, existential, person-centered, and gestalt therapies differ in key ways. Recent scholarship on existential, person-centered, and gestalt therapies builds on the rich canon of literature in these three core humanistic traditions, but

Counseling Theory: The Bondage Breaker in the
Words: 975 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 73884594

Counseling Theory: The Bondage Breaker In The Bondage Breaker, Neil T. Anderson presents a very religious and somewhat controversial approach to therapy; he believes that some problems may be the result of demonic possession and his therapeutic approach incorporates traditional Christian methods for dealing with demonic possession. It is important to realize that Anderson does not believe all psychological problems are the result of demonic possession or even that they

Counseling Theory: Boundaries and Marriage in Boundaries
Words: 966 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 34489926

Counseling Theory: Boundaries and Marriage In Boundaries and Marriage, Henry Cloud and John Townsend introduce the concept of boundaries as it relates to marriage. In order to understand their theory of boundaries, it is important to realize that this book is one in a series of books that the authors have written about boundaries, and includes an exploration of how boundaries impact interpersonal relationships. Their theory is that relationship problems

Counseling Theory and the Christian Worldview
Words: 2711 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 32282354

New Counseling Paradigm Focusing on Scripture and Family New Directions for Christian Counseling: A Focus on Scripture and Family This paper will focus on presenting a new counseling paradigm which synthesizes the power of the Bible by combining a variety of elements from assorted counseling theories with the inherent goal of maximizing client outcomes. This framework is useful as it mixes the intrinsic nature and needs of man along with the defining psychological

Understanding Different Counseling Theories
Words: 484 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Counseling Paper #: 71997990

graduate students in counseling programs to learn theories? Graduate students in counseling programs are required to learn counseling theories because of their significance in the profession. It's important for graduate students in such programs to learn counseling theories for a variety of reasons. First, theory is the essential framework and building block for counselors in training (Lofrisco, 2013). Without having a solid foundation and understanding of theory, students in

Substance Abuse Counseling Theories Substance
Words: 3044 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Sports - Drugs Paper #: 13009622

It has been argued that despite this fact, because substance abuse treatment has been developed by men, for men, it emerged "as a single-focused intervention based on the needs of addicted men." (Covington 2008). Without empowering substance abusers whose lives have become severely impaired in terms of basic life functioning, treating the abuse or disability as a purely biological function will have little effect, and only address the physical