Personality And Leadership Research Paper

Length: 5 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Leadership Type: Research Paper Paper: #86327576 Related Topics: Personality Traits, Personality Tests, Personality Test, Nature Vs Nurture
Excerpt from Research Paper :

Personality and Leadership

Personality most certainly has an impact on a person's leadership style, effectiveness, and overall competence. And clearly the personality traits shown by leaders impact underlings and employees in numerous ways. In this paper personality -- as linked to leadership skills and styles -- will be viewed through scholarly references and research. Also, the issue of nature vs. nurture will be reviewed and critiqued as well.

What is Personality?

The New York Times-owned explains that personality has certain "fundamental characteristics," including: a) consistency (there is a sense of regularity and order to human behaviors; people tend to act the same way or in "similar ways in a variety of situations"); b) psychological and physiological (personality is psychologically constructed but research reveals that it is "also influenced by biological processes and needs"); c) personality has a profound impact on a person's actions and behaviors (our personalities cause us to act in certain ways, hence, personality isn't just influential, it is a driver of our behaviors); and d) multiple expressions (many behaviors are displayed in response to how our personalities function and how we interact with others and express our thoughts) (Cherry, 2012).

Delving deeper into the idea of personality, the work of Sigmund Freud is still considered the most fundamentally thorough -- albeit in some circles controversial -- description of personality. When thinking about what makes a leader tick, following Freud's descriptions can be helpful and enlightening. Freud posited that humans have an "Id" (the innate biological instincts and urges, a "self-serving, irrational and impulsive" part of the personality that is known as the "pleasure principle" (Coon, et al., 2008, p. 398).

Freud's "Ego" is a system of thinking and planning, of problem solving, and basically it directs energy that has been provided by the Id. It's been called the "executive" part of the personality because it makes decisions. Unlike the popular usage of "ego" Freud's Ego has conscious control of the personality and can postpone action until an appropriate time (Coon, 399). Hence, a strong ego in the Freudian sense is imperative for a leader. The "Superego" is the part of the personality, according to Freud, that acts as the conscience, or the censor. When a leader makes a decision impetuously, and the decision goes is against that leader's normal better judgment, the superego will let him know and perhaps even "punish" the leader with strong feelings of guilt (Coon, 399).

Nature vs. Nurture -- Is Personality Learned?

Kevin Davies' "Nature vs. Nurture Revisited" production on NOVA (2001) -- part of Public Broadcasting Service programming -- opens up with the assertion that the "seesaw struggle between our genes (nature) and the environment (nurture) had swung sharply in favor of nurture" Davies, 2001, p. 1). Davies makes that point after thoroughly reviewing the data from the Human Genome Project. In that august research, which posited that humans have about 30,000 genes, the evidence is definitely slanted towards nurture and not nature.

While some scientists and others would like to believe that people who suffer from colon cancer, for example, are born with a defective "colon cancer" gene, research published in the highly respected New England Journal of Medicine points to the fact that cancer is "largely caused by environmental rather than inherited factors (Davies, 1).

What about personality and genes? Davies writes that notwithstanding the "media hype" to the contrary, genes apparently don't control "addiction, shyness, thrill seeking, and most controversially, sexual orientation" (2). Genes offer "tantalizing clues" to the above-mentioned traits, but as of the publishing of this production, there is no training before the age of six" (Davies, 3). Hence, there may be certain genes in a person that can aid in becoming a worthy leader, but without training, experience, a strong superego and the environment to allow leadership to flourish, those genes cannot be assumed to be responsible.

Ethical Leadership and Leaders' Personalities

A scholarly article in the peer-reviewed journal Social Behavior and Personality examines the relationship between ethical leadership and the dimensions of leaders' personalities. The authors explain that there have been "hundreds of studies" devoted to looking into the relationships between the "Big Five personality dimensions and leadership," but there has been very little research "carried out to investigate the relationship between ethical leadership" and the Big Five personality dimensions (Xu, et al., 2011, p. 362). So Xu and colleagues acquired data from 59 community healthcare centers in northern China, using questionnaires and interviews to tap into the views of employees regarding their supervisory leaders.

The Big Five personality dimensions include: "emotional stability (also referred to in this article as neuroticism), agreeableness, openness to experience, extraversion and conscientiousness" (Xu, 362). One research group, Brown and Trevino (2006), studied neuroticism and determined it was related to ethical leadership in a negative way, while Walumbwa and Schaubroeck (2009) found in their research into neuroticism that it was simply not linked to ethical leadership at all. Hence, the authors believed it was important to research the link between the Big Five and ethical leadership.

In their research, the authors used the 10-item Ethical Leadership Scale that was developed by Brown (et al.) and tested by Walumbwa and Schaubroeck; this scale measures the perceptions that employees have of the ethical leadership embraced by their supervisors. In order to assess employees' he authors also used the 12-item subscale from Costa and McCrae's NEO-Five-Factor Inventory. Xu and colleagues hypothesized that extraversion, agreeableness and conscientiousness would be positively linked to ethical leadership -- which seems logical at the outset.

Using simple linear regression analysis the authors determined that while neuroticism (a trait that has the individual fluctuating in moods and sometimes anxious) was indeed seen as a negative aspect of ethical leadership, agreeableness, conscientiousness and extraversion were seen as positive attributes vis-a-vis ethical leadership (Xu, 366-67).

Meanwhile in an article published by the Journal of Business Ethics (Kalshoven, et al., 2010) the authors -- as authors generally do in peer-reviewed pieces -- suggest that there are certain aspects of a problem or issue that haven't yet been carefully scrutinized. To wit, Kalshoven and colleges suggest that many studies have covered and verified the fact that "commitment, satisfaction with the leader, trust, perceived leader effectiveness, and organizational citizenship behavior" are linked in a positive way to ethical leadership. "Far less," Kalshoven writes, is known about "the antecedents of ethical leadership" (349).

And since leaders in the new millennium are expected to not just meet financial goals, but to meet environmental and societal responsibilities as well, the role of a leader in terms of creating an "ethical climate at work" has taken on enormous importance (Kalshoven, 349). The antecedents used in this research paper -- fairness, role clarification and power sharing -- were studied in the context of -- and juxtaposed with -- the Big Five traits, and the result showed that: a) as expected and as hypothesized, conscientiousness and agreeableness were "most relevant for ethical leadership"; b) conscientiousness was deemed most critical for "role clarification"; c) agreeableness appeared "most important for fairness and power sharing"; and d) emotional stability was clearly most relevant for "ethical leadership and role clarification" (Kalshoven, 360).

The conclusion that Kalshoven and colleagues offer is simply that because the selection and development of leaders that are "likely to behave somewhat more fairly, share power and clarify roles" is vitally important to an organization in terms of fostering ethical leadership, executives should…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Cherry, Kendra. (2012). What Is Personality? / Psychology. Retrieved April 24,

2012, from

Coon, Dennis, and Mitterner, John O. (2008). Introduction to Psychology: Gateways to Mind

and Behavior. Independence, KY: Cengage Learning.

Cite this Document:

"Personality And Leadership" (2012, April 26) Retrieved July 30, 2021, from

"Personality And Leadership" 26 April 2012. Web.30 July. 2021. <>

"Personality And Leadership", 26 April 2012, Accessed.30 July. 2021,

Related Documents
Leadership Played a Substantial Role in the
Words: 923 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 27961663

Leadership played a substantial role in the recent economic troubles. The banking industry suffered from leadership that was incentivized to pursue high-risk short-term policies that resulted in high levels of return but subjected the entire economy to substantial risk. In the automobile industry, leaders failed because they did not adequately anticipate industry trends and did not adjust the corporate culture soon enough to respond to changes in the external environment

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal and How Teachers...
Words: 14019 Length: 50 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 37659084

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal It is the intention of this research to study the leadership and cognitive styles of teachers and instructors of both genders within the educational system and their preference for types of leadership in a principal of that institution. The research will include teachers and educators from all levels of the educational system from grade school to high school. The study will also include teachers and

Leadership Models Theories. Include: Describe Similarities Differences...
Words: 1809 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 86040619

leadership models theories. Include: Describe similarities differences models. Discuss model address contemporary leadership issues challenges. It is amazing how volumes of literature exist on the several aspects of leadership theories and models. In any case, it appears that leadership has for a long time been an interesting subject in entirely all sectors of humanity. Indeed, leadership defines a great proportion of the human race and it therefore warrants the much

Leadership Style in Community-Based Healthcare
Words: 3060 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 37443093

They will need others to contemplate on some issues as well as complete the required tasks. Therefore, an ENTJ leader will need to accompany a team as expected. That is to say, that a team player should remain incorporated in the leadership processes, if this is a necessary component that will enable completion of the set task. Here, one will establish that the leadership associations remain a two-way corporation/correspondence

Personality and Leadership: A Qualitative and Quantitative
Words: 1865 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 79274723

Personality and Leadership: A Qualitative and Quantitative Review," Judge, Bono, Ilies & Gerhardt (2002) focus on the trait theory of leadership. In "Applying a Psychobiological Model of Personality to the Study of Leadership," O'Connor & Jackson (2010) study the relationship between personality and emergent leadership. In "When the Romance is Over: Follower Perspectives of Aversive Leadership," Bligh, et al. (2007) explore what the researchers call the "dark side" of

Leadership in International Schools
Words: 29649 Length: 108 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 20990082

Leadership Skills Impact International Education CHALLENGES OF INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION Practical Circumstances of International schools THE IMPORTANCE OF LEADERSHIP IN EDUCATION What is Effective Leadership for Today's Schools? Challenges of Intercultural Communication Challenges of Differing Cultural Values Importance of the Team Leadership Style LEADERSHIP THEORIES Current Leadership Research Transformational Leadership Skills-Authority Contingency Theories APPLYING LEADERSHIP IN AN INTERNATIONAL SETTING Wagner's "Buy-in" vs. Ownership Understanding the Urgent Need for Change Research confirms what teachers, students, parents and superintendents have long known: the individual school is the key unit