Reclaiming The Social Body Through Self-Directed Violence Reaction Paper

Linos, Natalia. (2010). Reclaiming the social body through self-Directed violence: Seeking anthropological understanding of suicide attacks. Anthropology Today, 26 (5).

According to Natalia Linos' 2010 article "Reclaiming the social body through self-directed violence: Seeking anthropological understanding of suicide attacks" from Anthropology Today, it is necessary to use a more rational, cooler academic lens to bring light as well as heat to the debate over the phenomenon of terrorist suicide attacks. While the emotionalism surrounding the issue is understandable, for Linos it often obscures the meaning and reasoning behind these suicidal gestures, and ultimately emotionalism impedes rather than enhances our ability to understand suicide bombing. Linos applies a Foucaultian analysis to the use of suicide bombing in the specific context of the Arab-Israeli conflict.

The body has traditionally been a vehicle of articulation for the powerless....

...

In Israel 'biopower,' or power over the physical bodies of the Palestinians, is manifested through the greater physical might of the Israeli army, checkpoints, and the presence of the military in the territories. For some radical groups, the use of their own biopower in the form of suicide bombers is the only way to strike back at the Israeli show of force. It becomes a paradoxical form of reclaiming one's own body through self-induced violence (Linos 2010:2). Linos suggests that self-directed violence becomes a source of positive self-definition within the symbolic vocabulary of the oppressed, as it has for women in other cultural contexts.
Violence against the self becomes regenerative in the community context of the Palestinians, even if it is personally destructive to the self. Linos also draws upon Durkheim's analysis of indigenous societies: on a communitarian level self-directed violent acts are rational, even if on an individualistic level they…

Sources Used in Documents:

Violence against the self becomes regenerative in the community context of the Palestinians, even if it is personally destructive to the self. Linos also draws upon Durkheim's analysis of indigenous societies: on a communitarian level self-directed violent acts are rational, even if on an individualistic level they are not (Linos 2010:3). An individual suicide is not the same thing as a suicide undertaken for political reasons, and a suicidal bomber cannot be reduced to an individual's 'madness' any more than a hunger strike for a political reason can be reduced to an individual person refusing food (Linos 2010: 3). This inability to honor the collective dimension of individual experience is one reason why Westerners are particularly horrified by suicide bombing, more so than by other attacks (Linos 2010:4).

However, Linos admits that even in Islam there are prohibitions against suicide, as it is seen as a way of taking away the power of God to give and take away life. The notion that Westerners are uniquely disgusted by suicide bombing is also belied by the fact that it has existed within a Western context, such as in the 'Troubles' of Northern Ireland. There is also, she concedes, an element of pollution and co-mingling of the aggressor and the victim on the final death that creates revulsion innately, perhaps cross-culturally (Linos 2010:5).

Fundamentally, Linos believes that the types of political violence, both self-directed and otherwise, against oppressive regimes are often highly contextual in nature. Just because the mode of expression selected by the Palestinians is foreign to our own does not mean that it is senseless and purposeless. Linos' analysis will seem chillingly bloodless to some, in the wake of the real, physical destruction caused by self-induced violence, and the argument that self-directed violence begets more violence on the part of the Israelis is difficult to ignore. However, her article does make a good point that suicidal terrorism should not be reduced to 'acts of madmen,' as they occasionally are in the Western, popular press.


Cite this Document:

"Reclaiming The Social Body Through Self-Directed Violence" (2012, April 28) Retrieved April 29, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reclaiming-the-social-body-through-self-directed-112250

"Reclaiming The Social Body Through Self-Directed Violence" 28 April 2012. Web.29 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reclaiming-the-social-body-through-self-directed-112250>

"Reclaiming The Social Body Through Self-Directed Violence", 28 April 2012, Accessed.29 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reclaiming-the-social-body-through-self-directed-112250

Related Documents

CONTROLLING OUR EMOTIONS? EMOTIONAL LITERACY: MECHANISM FOR SOCIAL CONTROL? At the core of becoming an activist educator Is identifying the regimes of truth that govern us the ideas that govern how we think, act and feel as educators because it is within regimes of truth that inequity is produced and reproduced. (MacNaughton 2005, 20) Disorder, addictions, vulnerability and dysfunction...." Disorder, addictions, vulnerability and dysfunction...." These terns, according to Nolan (1998; Furedi 2003; cited by Ecclestone

psychological research there a thousands of pressing questions, yet among all those questions one rises to the top of the list. In the area of family psychology and family therapy the question of the psychological affects of domestic violence on children has been hotly debated and eternally researched, yet many questions remain unanswered. These questions are pressing as the institution of family in our culture evolves and emerges as

CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE ON WOMEN INVOLVED IN PROSTITUTION Conceptual Paper Millions of children around the globe are sexually abused or exploited. This paper includes several descriptions of studies that relate sexual abuse during childhood to delinquency later in life. There are several difficulties with methodology and definitions that are inherent in the mentioned studies. These challenges make it somewhat difficult to compare and interpret the findings of the study. A framework

They predict age and gender variations relate to bullying concerns. Of the 25 cartoons implemented in the study, two depict characters with different shades of skin color where skin color appeared to be an issue. One cartoon relating to sexual orientation was not used in several countries. Smith et al. report Olweus to assert bullying to be characterized by the following three criteria: 1. It is aggressive behavior or intentional

Pedagogic Model for Teaching of Technology to Special Education Students Almost thirty years ago, the American federal government passed an act mandating the availability of a free and appropriate public education for all handicapped children. In 1990, this act was updated and reformed as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which itself was reformed in 1997. At each step, the goal was to make education more equitable and more accessible to

During her reorganization phase, her personality and the emotional support from other social units played a vital role. As a person, she was a survivor. She appeared to posses a character which made her endure the pain yet live through the moment. It was her resilience that made her go to public authorities even after she lost her case the first time. Alice always wanted to be somebody whose