Verified Document

Summary The Role Of Customer Gratitude In Relationship Marketing Essay

Related Topics:

Palmatier, R.W., Jarvis, C.B., Bechkoff, J.R. & Kardes, F.R. (2009). The Role of Customer Gratitude in Relationship Marketing. Journal of Marketing, 73(5), 1-18.

Abstract: Although most relationship marketing theories have in the past emphasized the relevance of commitment and trust in seeking to influence performance outcomes, gratitude has been identified as yet another critical mediating mechanism on this front. By utilizing data from two studies, the authors in this case demonstrate that gratitude also mediates the influence of a sellers relationship marketing investments on performance outcomes.

Introduction: According to the authors, most marketing experts are in agreement that in marketing, the relevance of sustaining good relations with customers cannot be overstated. It is however important to note that as Palmatier (as cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009) points out, on the basis of a meta-analysis founded on thousands of relationships, RM investments have a direct effect on seller objective performance outcomes that is actually greater than the effect mediated by trust and commitment. For this reason, a need exists to evaluate and study the rest of the mediating mechanisms which according to Palmatier, Dant, and Grewal (as cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009) could include, but they are not limited to gratitude, exchange effectiveness, and reciprocity. As it has also been pointed out by Emmons and McCullough; and Morales (as cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009), the authors of this particular study propose that gratitude, the emotional appreciation for benefits received, accompanied by a desire to reciprocate is an important construct for understanding RM effectiveness.

Conceptual Background of Gratitude: The authors note, from the onset, that reciprocal behaviors are largely founded on the emotional aspect of one of the most prominent human interactions social components, i.e. gratitude. It is also this social component that, as Gouldner (as cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009) points out, motivates human beings to honor reciprocal obligations. Gratitude has two key components, i.e. the behavioral component and the affective component with the former having to do with the creation of a long-term reciprocity cycle as a consequence of feelings of gratitude; and the latter being a rather short-term occurrence whereby persons are under some sort of pressure to give back. The authors point out that both components ought to be understood in an attempt to grasp the role gratitude plays in RM. It is important to note that very few studies have been conducted in an attempt to highlight the role gratitude plays in informing the behavior of consumers. Even fewer studies take into consideration the resident emotional process. It is for this reason that the authors propose that viewing feelings of gratitude as reciprocitys emotional core (Emmons 2004, p. 12) offers a theoretical richness that could otherwise be missed if the behavioral outcomes of customers are assessed without consideration of the psychological process involved.

Table 1: In a tabular format, the authors condense their review of literature on the subject matter to derive meaningful theoretical positioning of constructs. They find out that in addition to the number of studies connecting the reciprocal motives of customers with gratitude feelings being very few, the task or reciprocity or gratitude has not been tested empirically, or even subjected to the relevant measurements and assessments. From the tabular review, it is therefore clear that as the authors note, gratitude may provide an explanation of the direct effect of relationship investments on seller performance in the extant commitmenttrust RM model.

Hypotheses: The authors, in essence, hypothesize and test the role of gratitude (both affective and behavioral aspects) as a missing mediator for the effects of RM on performance outcomes, parallel to trust and commitment. According to the authors, once the RM undertakings of the seller are recognized by the buyer, the emotional systems of the customer are engaged. This effectively triggers the customers gratitude feelings and enhances the said customers intentions to give back or what the authors in this case refer to as intentions to repay the seller. As Dahl, Honea, and Manchanda; and Morales (as cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009) point out, customers could act out the said intentions by adapting their purchase habits. Customers could engage...

…RM investments on customer trust. The authors also find out that the gratitude of customers is further enhanced by both their enhanced needs and the perceived benevolent acts of the seller.

Study 2

Procedure of study 2: The second study, a dyadic longitudinal field survey, involved rep firms offering for sale various products and services (industrial) and their customers in North America. Customer surveys conducted in this case were matched with each rep firms sales data.

Measurement in study 2: In this particular study, the authors conducted a CFA so as to conduct an evaluation of the constructs psychometric properties.

Results of study 2: The field study results match the experimental study results. Essentially, H1b is supported in that reciprocal behaviors that are based on gratitude and relationship management investment exhibit positive relations. H3a and H3b are also supported in that sales growth, sales revenue, as well as wallet share are positively influenced by the reciprocal behaviors of customers that are based on gratitude. H4b is supported on the basis of customer trust being positively impacted upon by gratitude-based conduct of customers.

Discussion of study 2: In basic terms, the laboratory findings external validity is confirmed by Study 2 field survey. For this reason, as the authors point out, the findings of Study 1 are echoed by Study 2 results. In their own words, the authors observe that the field study shows that gratitude-based reciprocal behaviors drive company performance outcomes, specifically, sales revenue, share of wallet, and sales growth.

General discussion and implications: It is important to note that although quite a number of marketing studies have indicated that the reciprocation principle or process is of great relevance in relationship management, very few studies have attempted to integrate reciprocity into models of relationship management. The present study, as the authors note, empirically demonstrates that both the affective and behavioral aspects of gratitude are important mechanisms for understanding how and why RM influences seller performance.

Understanding the role of gratitude in RM: A review of literature in this case clearly demonstrates that relationships are influenced by gratitude to a great extent whereby as some authors including Bartlett…

Sources used in this document:

cited in Palmatier, Jarvis, Bechkoff, and Kardes, 2009) point out, gratitude is representative of reciprocity’s emotional foundation. This study lends both empirical as well as conceptual support to the relevance of gratitude as far as the effectiveness of relationship management is concerned. With this in mind, managers ought to be aware of an opportunity to tap on gratitude feelings after an investment in relationship management. Towards this end, the authors point out that “in addition to the obvious advantage of gaining incremental sales during this period, giving customers the opportunity to reciprocate will generate a cycle of reciprocation and strengthen the overall relationship.”

Increasing RM's effectiveness by leveraging gratitude: According to the authors, it is possible to increase gratitude via the further enhancement of the perceptions of the customer regarding the benevolent intentions of the seller. This could also be achieved by ensuring that the needs of the customers are matched with the investment in relationship management.

Limitations: The authors note that one key limitation of the mixed research approach used in the study remains “the lack of longitudinal and causal linkages between the feeling and resultant behavior of gratitude and trust.” For this reason, they call for the utilization of the longitudinal approach in future studies to evaluate the long-term comportment or bearing of gratitude feelings. The authors also point out that there is need for future studies to take into consideration other gratitude-leveraging constructs. These include, but they are not limited to, the competence of the seller. The authors also call for future research to adopt context-based or a narrower view of gratitude measurement so as to have better grasp of the issue.

Appendix A: In appendix A, the authors offer the eight scenario descriptions about the shopping experience, as assigned to participants in the first study. These include high-free-will scenario, low-free-will scenario, high-motive scenario, low-motive scenario, high-risk scenario, low-risk scenario, high-need scenario, and low-need scenario.

Appendix B: Appendix B highlights the various constructs measured, loadings, as well as scale sources. The constructs included are eight in total. It is important to note that the factor loadings happen to be p < .01 at all instances, and hence could be regarded significant.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Trust Explain How You Develop and Maintain
Words: 689 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Trust Explain how you develop and maintain trust at work and why confidentiality is so important in building and maintaining trust at work. Trust is critical to the functioning of any team or organization. Individual employees need to be able to trust their role in the organization so that ideas, concerns, and opinions are shared freely. Likewise, supervisors need to trust their employees will share their opinions that pertain to increasing productivity.

Trust in Government Trust in
Words: 872 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Periods of trust in the government are not, perhaps, as easily identified, but they are just as numerous. Following the onset of the Depression and the election of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a period of restored faith and hope in the government began and continued throughout World War II and after. Prior to that, there was a great deal of trust placed in the federal government throughout much of the first

Trust Race the Power of
Words: 1121 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

(2009), yet faculty trust was included as an identified feature of academic optimism and thus the relationship of these two studies is made clear and the reliability of Smith and Hoy's (2007) study greatly increased. This study also did not take race into account, making it again less comprehensive and slightly less meaningful than Goddard et al. (2009). Comparisons of race and of racial attitudes to academic achievement abound in

Trust & Distrust Five Causes
Words: 617 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

He notes there has been an overall decline in government trust since the mid-1960s. Only once since 1975 has government trust broke 50%. That occurred in the months following 9/11. After the tumultuous assassinations of the 1960s, the Vietnam War, the resignation of President Nixon, and the stagflation of the late 1970s, public trust fell from 80% in 1966 to about 25% in 1981. The Watergate scandal, the regularity

Trusted Friends Fast Food Nation: Chapter 2
Words: 866 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Trusted Friends Fast Food Nation: Chapter 2 review "Your trusted friends" (31-59) One of the most striking aspects of McDonald's is the way in which it markets itself as a 'friendly' organization committed to family values, even while it sells food that is blatantly unhealthy and damaging to consumers' health. The Happy Meals it promotes to children have an innocent quality, even while the food is carefully engineered so that it

Trust Is a Valuable Tool
Words: 2962 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

The principal is the property that is contained in the trust that produces income like dividends, rents, and interest. Payments for bills to the trust may be paid out of either income or principal but payments to beneficiaries may be made out from income only. Where such payments will be made lies within the discretion of the trustee. Determining the proper distribution of income and principal is one of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now