Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Murdick's text was purely instructional, and could effectively be boiled down to a list of do's and don'ts -- examples were provided for clarity's sake, but true experiential learning is conspicuously lacking from his approach. The Longman text, on the other hand, not only provides an abundance of long-form examples form published literary works to supplement the instructional passages in the text, but these passages are themselves written in a more literary and formal style that at times directly and purposefully emulates the compositional lessons being discussed. This approach is both more inclusive and more demanding of the reader, and explicitly tries to make the reading experience mirror that of writing inasmuch as possible.
Both texts adequately cover the pure knowledge and skills that are...
Both the examples and the tone of the text's writing reinforce the instruction, rather than simply repeating it, as Murdick often does. The brief "...in College Writing" sections that accompanied each major subheading of compositional styles (Description..., Narrative..., etc.) in the Longman text were unnecessary, but this is a minor quibble. All in all, the book was highly effective and far more engaging than the Murdick text.
References
Murdick, William. A Student's Guide to College Composition. New York: Jain Publishing, 2003.
Dawe, Charles and Edward Dornan, eds. The Longwood reader, 4th Edition. New York: Longman, 1999.
Comparative Critique of Seven ArticlesIntroduction (Purpose of Articles)Public relations (PR) is a significant element in public education. The purpose of the article by Norton (2009) is to lay emphasis on the fundamental significance of the human resources function within the school system, especially in the execution of an efficacious school public relations program and in the leadership quality rendered by the administrators and the qualified and off the record staffs.
Works Cited: Murray, G. (2008, January). The Case for Corporate Aviation. Risk Management, 55(1), p. 42. Sheehan, J. (2003). Business and Corporate Aviation Management: On Demand Air Transportation. New York: McGraw Hill. Suzuki, Y. (2000). The effect of airline positioning on profit. Transportation Journal, 39(3), 44-54. Toomey, J. (2010, March). Building Parner Aviation Capacity Through Training. DISAM Journal of International Security Assistance Management, 31(4), pp. 118-25. Transportation Security Administration. (2011, March). Air Cargo Security Programs. Retrieved
Bible Counseling Goal of Christian Counseling Dr. Larry Crabb sees human problems through two lenses: the first category involves problems that result from "…natural or physical causes" (things the individual has little or no control over). Examples of those kinds of problems include learning disabilities, a chemical imbalance within the person, and other issues that result from "perceptual dysfunctions." Crabb's goal is to fill the basic needs of a person, and under
Critique of Article: Health and Safety in the Engineering Classroom 1 The type of research is descriptive, to elicit statistics on how prevalent safety and health instruction is in the normal college engineering curriculum. 2. Yes, the problem is clearly stated. "The Professional Engineer's Code of Ethics includes the responsibility 'to hold paramount the public safety, health and welfare,' and yet several recent reports suggest that few undergraduate engineering programs include
Running Head: COMPARATIVE CRITIQUE COMPARATIVE CRITIQUE 8Comparative Critique of Seven ArticlesAbstractThere is a need for a new crop of leadership and leadership educators with demographic shift internationally. The globalization of the economy and the technological demands of the information age are converging to create unique and unprecedented challenges and opportunities for school systems. The challenges in marginal areas include �increased local student transiency, homelessness, and the influx of newcomers; including
For instance, according to Slaatte (1968), the "paradox of the paradox per se refers to two opposite properties of the paradox itself: its sheer impertinence to reason, on the one hand, and its profounder pertinence to reason, on the other" (p. 6). From Slaatte's perspective, "Truth is seen in vital relation to the self in his existence-as-he-experiences-it; it is not related as though one object is thrust upon another. If