Expansion in the Age of Discovery vs. Age of Reason
This essay examines the literary output of two major historical epochs — the Age of Discovery and the Age of Reason — identifying expansion as their shared thematic focus. While explorers such as Christopher Columbus and Fray Marcos de Niza produced travelogues documenting physical conquest and colonization, thinkers of the Age of Reason, including Hobbes, Locke, and Thomas Paine, advanced intellectual expansion through philosophy, science, and politics. The paper argues that despite their common emphasis on human progress, the two eras differ fundamentally in their orientation: one outward toward new lands, the other inward toward human reason and achievement.
- Introduction: A Common Theme of Expansion: Both eras share a focus on human expansion
- Physical Expansion in the Age of Discovery: Explorers' travelogues document colonization and conquest
- Intellectual Expansion in the Age of Reason: Hobbes, Locke, and Paine champion human reason
- Science, Politics, and Industry in Enlightenment Writing: Enlightenment writing advances science and politics
- Conclusion: Two Faces of Human Progress: Physical and intellectual expansion compared and contrasted
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear central argument in the opening paragraph — that both eras share a focus on expansion but differ in whether that expansion is physical or intellectual — and sustains it throughout.
- Specific textual examples (Columbus, Fray Marcos de Niza, Hobbes's Leviathan, Locke's Two Treatises, Paine's Age of Reason) ground the comparative argument in concrete evidence.
- The contrast structure (one era per body paragraph) keeps the comparison organized and easy to follow.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a point-by-point thematic comparison across two historical periods, anchoring abstract claims about intellectual or physical progress to named authors and texts. This technique — identifying a shared motif and then distinguishing how each era expresses it — is a strong model for comparative literary and historical essays at the introductory undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis establishing the shared theme of expansion and the key distinction between the two eras. Two body paragraphs then develop each side of the contrast: the Age of Discovery (physical expansion via exploration and travelogue) and the Age of Reason (intellectual expansion via philosophy, science, and political theory). A shorter paragraph elaborates on the Enlightenment's focus on industry and non-conquest advancement before a brief conclusion restates the central comparison.
Introduction: A Common Theme of Expansion
There are a number of poignant similarities and inherent differences between the Age of Discovery and the Age of Reason. Moreover, these dissimilarities and parallels are reflected in the literature that typified each of these historical epochs. A close examination of the writings endemic to these time periods reveals a definite focus on expansion. Mankind was attempting to progress, propelling civilization forward in the process. The key distinction between the writings of these ages is that in the Age of Discovery that progress was based on physical expansion, whereas in the Age of Reason that progress was based on intellectual expansion.
Physical Expansion in the Age of Discovery
Numerous works from the Age of Discovery attest to the fact that the common motif of this era was physical expansion. Indeed, the most noted works of this time period were those of explorers attempting to traverse the globe in search of new lands, cultures, and territories to claim for their European patrons. In this respect, many of these writings effectively served as travelogues documenting these adventures. Christopher Columbus, for example, wrote several works detailing his voyages to the so-called New World. Fray Marcos de Niza composed similar writings in his quest for a city of gold on behalf of Spain.
Therefore, the vast majority of works during this period concerned physical manifestations — new lands, new peoples, and new countries. The explorers were seeking to make new discoveries in the physical world, and their writing reflected this ambition. The literature of the Age of Discovery was not theoretical; rather, it documented European attempts to colonize the globe.
Intellectual Expansion in the Age of Reason
In contrast, the more noteworthy writings of the Age of Reason were concerned with intellectual expansion. These works were not typically focused on travel, foreign cultures, or distant lands. Instead, they focused on humanity's intellectual prowess and achievement. An important undercurrent in the writings of this era is that they emphasized human achievement as contrasted with the authority of God. In most eras prior to the Age of Reason, mankind made deliberate attempts to remain subservient to God. During the Age of Reason, belief systems such as Deism counteracted that notion, contending that mankind was ultimately the master of its own fate.
Hobbes's Leviathan typified this intellectual expansion. Although a political treatise, it incorporated elements of philosophy, science, and religion to stress human achievement. Locke's Two Treatises of Government followed in this vein, though it was published toward the end of the era. Thomas Paine's Age of Reason likewise captured the sentiment of the day, contrasting divine authority with humanity's newfound capacity to excel through reason.
Conclusion: Two Faces of Human Progress
The primary similarity between the writings of the Age of Reason and those of the Age of Discovery is that both were focused on humanity's forward expansion. The latter treated that subject literally, in terms of physical territory and geographical conquest. The former dealt with it intellectually, advancing ideas that ultimately challenged organized religion and redefined humanity's relationship to political power. Together, these two bodies of literature map the dual trajectory of early modern progress: outward into the world and inward into the mind.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.