Business and Ethical Case Against Outsourcing: Electrocorp Study
This paper examines the ethics and business logic of outsourcing through the hypothetical Electrocorp case study, originally developed by Karen Musalo of the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics. Drawing on free trade theory — including Russell Roberts's comparative advantage argument — the paper evaluates whether Electrocorp should relocate its manufacturing operations to Mexico, the Philippines, or South Africa. Each destination is assessed on wages, government stability, environmental regulations, and worker conditions. The analysis concludes that despite short-term cost savings, outsourcing to any of the three countries imposes unacceptable ethical costs and long-term business risks, making continued domestic operation the more sound strategic and moral choice.
- Introduction: Free Trade and the Case for Outsourcing: Free trade theory, comparative advantage, and outsourcing overview
- Outsourcing to Mexico: Opportunities and Drawbacks: Mexico's wage, government, and environmental tradeoffs
- Outsourcing to the Philippines: Low Wages and High Ethical Costs: Philippines offers lower wages but deeper ethical problems
- Comparing Mexico and the Philippines: Both destinations fail on ethics and long-term business grounds
- Outsourcing to South Africa: A Different but Flawed Case: South Africa's higher wages still yield ethical and business risks
- Conclusion: The Ethical and Business Argument for Staying in the United States: Domestic operation is the ethically and strategically sound choice
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses a concrete hypothetical case study to ground abstract economic and ethical arguments, making the analysis tangible and easy to follow.
- It systematically evaluates each outsourcing destination using consistent criteria — wages, government stability, environmental standards, and worker welfare — giving the argument a disciplined comparative structure.
- The paper balances business logic with ethical reasoning throughout, demonstrating that short-term cost savings do not justify long-term reputational, competitive, or moral harm.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective cost-benefit analysis applied to a business ethics scenario. Rather than dismissing outsourcing outright, the author engages each destination on its own merits before systematically dismantling the case for relocation. The use of secondary sources — an ethics researcher, an outsourcing industry advocate, and a free trade economist — shows how to synthesize competing perspectives into a coherent argument.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a theoretical framing drawn from Russell Roberts's comparative advantage model, then introduces the Electrocorp scenario. The body proceeds country by country — Mexico, the Philippines, South Africa — applying the same evaluative framework to each. A brief comparative synthesis follows before the conclusion recommends domestic operation on both business and ethical grounds. This funnel structure moves from general theory to specific cases to a final judgment.
Introduction: Free Trade and the Case for Outsourcing
In his economic allegory of free trade, The Choice, Russell Roberts argues that free trade is ultimately beneficial to everyone involved: workers, producers, and the general public (2002). According to Roberts, two countries specialize in particular products because one country possesses a comparative advantage over the other. Roberts illustrates this concept using the metaphor of a factory owner and manager who is also an excellent typist but has hired a secretary to handle his typing. When it comes to managing, the executive holds a comparative advantage over his secretary. He is gifted in management while the secretary is not. It is better, therefore, for the manager to specialize in managing while his secretary specializes in typing. This arrangement benefits both parties, as well as everyone who works in the company. For this reason, Roberts argues that free trade is optimal, despite its negative side effects (2002).
Unfortunately, those negative side effects are real, and although they may be overshadowed by the broader benefits of free trade, that does not make them any easier to bear. Outsourcing is one such side effect. Traditionally, many Americans have viewed outsourcing as harmful — displacing hardworking domestic workers in favor of foreign labor. Some also argue that it worsens social conditions abroad, as foreign workers are forced to work for very little pay. Free trade economists, however, counter that outsourcing not only creates more and better jobs for Americans but also improves social conditions in developing countries. Outdated jobs that can be performed in less technologically advanced environments are outsourced, making room for new industries and higher-paying positions in the United States. In the same vein, outsourcing allows residents of developing countries to acquire new skills and become more competitive in the global market. Free trade economists also argue that trade opens borders, allowing developing and politically repressed countries to become more receptive to Western ideals of democracy and freedom. Even so, most agree that a thorough cost-benefit analysis must be performed before any individual company makes the significant decision to outsource its operations.
An excellent illustration of this is the Electrocorp case study, developed by Karen Musalo, director of the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics International Human Rights and Migration Project, who used this hypothetical situation to discuss the ethics and business implications of outsourcing with Stan Raggio, Senior Vice President for Sourcing and Logistics at the Gap. As the CEO of Electrocorp, an electronics company whose operating costs have begun to overshadow profits, a decision must be made about whether to relocate the company to one of three developing countries. By evaluating the business environment in Mexico, the Philippines, South Africa, and the United States, this analysis concludes that while outsourcing may offer short-term financial benefits, the ethical costs are too high a price to pay.
References
Casale, Frank J. (2006). The Outsourcing Institute: Mexico Trends & Opportunities. Retrieved June 1, 2008, from
Esselaar, Jeanne. (2002). The debate over outsourcing in South Africa: Evidence from a case study. Proceedings from Development Policy Research Unit Conference '02. Muldersdrift, Johannesburg.
Roberts, Russell. (2000). The Choice. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Unknown. (n.d.). The future is bright for outsourcing done right. Retrieved June 1, 2008, from http://pioutsource.com
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.