Customer Service Excellence: TQM and Case Study Analysis

Introduction

This paper examines customer service quality by drawing on scenarios where customer service has been both excellent and severely lacking. It also presents several methodologies that an organization — such as a rehabilitation center — can apply to improve its customer service. Key topics include Total Quality Management (TQM), foundational service principles, and other approaches for building a system that deals with customers effectively and respectfully.

Case Study: Hospital Customer Service

The following is a case study of a scenario involving a hospital and its customer service. The experience described here comes from a hospital that was treating a family member who had suffered a stroke, which provided a close opportunity to observe its customer service practices firsthand.

The complaint monitoring and receiving system was excellent. From the moment the first call was made, its positive impact was immediately felt. There was no annoying answering machine; instead, a staff member with a warm and helpful voice responded with a clear focus on addressing the problem. She guided the caller through the steps and procedures required to properly register at the hospital. Upon arrival, a well-organized intake system was easy to understand and navigate, covering all necessary requirements.

The documentation process was straightforward — it covered the patient's name, the nature of her condition, and which department to visit. A list of available medical professionals was also provided, so that if one was unavailable, another could be contacted with minimal disruption.

After the patient was admitted, the hospital assumed full responsibility for her care. The positive attitude of the doctors and other medical professionals in managing her critical condition was a tremendous source of comfort. From the very beginning, they offered reassurances that everything was under control. The overall working environment was equally impressive — staff members across departments consistently helped one another.

The professionalism displayed by the staff made a deeply stressful situation far more manageable. Their conduct suggested experience with situations even more demanding than this one. The lead physician treating the patient established a warm rapport from the very first meeting, exchanged contact information personally, and offered direct reassurance that the patient would recover.

The medications provided by the hospital were reasonably priced given the financial circumstances involved, and in some cases were offered at no cost. Whether this was a deliberate strategy to build a positive impression or simply an act of generosity, it worked — the experience left such a lasting impression that recommending this hospital to friends, colleagues, and family became a natural response, not only for its medical services but for its outstanding customer care.

Other noteworthy features included the rapid response time of the hospital's ambulances in emergency situations and the use of modern, effective medical equipment. The hospital environment itself felt welcoming and home-like. Visitors had access to a wide range of amenities, including a children's play area, a billiards room, a swimming pool, a library, and an indoor basketball court. The overall experience was genuinely memorable.

Case Study: Rehabilitation Center Customer Service

After consulting with the hospital's doctors, the decision was made to transfer the patient to a rehabilitation center, as her condition was improving and the hospital was becoming stretched for resources due to a high volume of incoming patients.

This is where significant problems began. The first major issue arose when dealing with two separate agencies responsible for the patient's social services. The rehabilitation center's complaint-handling system was frustrating — an automated answering machine that was unable to resolve critical issues forced an in-person visit to the agency for basic consultation.

Upon arrival, it became clear that because the patient's healthcare coverage came from a different agency (Medicare retirement benefits), additional documentation had to be retrieved from that agency before services could be accessed at the rehabilitation center. There was no coordination between the two agencies, despite the fact that they were serving the same purpose. Multiple trips to Medicare were required because the necessary staff members were frequently unavailable.

Even after all required documents were submitted to the rehabilitation center, processing took an unreasonably long time. The level of coordination among different departments within the center was poor — each department appeared to operate in isolation from the others. There was also no formal mechanism for lodging an official complaint about the experience.

The staff attitude was notably lacking. Many employees appeared to be on voluntary placements and may not have been adequately compensated, which seemed to affect their motivation and the quality of assistance they provided. Their behavior stood in sharp contrast to that observed at the hospital. A significant disconnect existed between top-level management and front-line staff — management retained full control over decisions, and employees were neither consulted nor encouraged to contribute their perspectives.

This was the opposite of the employee empowerment model observed at the hospital, where staff at all levels were encouraged to participate in decision-making. At the rehabilitation center, authority was firmly concentrated at the top. Several staff members mentioned that they worked there only because no other employment options were available, and many expressed dissatisfaction with how management operated the facility and its indifference toward service quality.

The medical professionals at the rehabilitation center were also noticeably disengaged compared to those at the hospital. Their level of care toward patients was disappointing and left a poor impression on both patients and visitors alike.

References

Brown, S. A. (1998). Breakthrough Customer Service. Toronto: John Wiley & Sons.

Buttle, F. (2004). Customer Relationship Management. Amsterdam: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.

Els, W. (2003). Winning at Service. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.

Horrell, E. (2006). The Kindness Revolution. New York: AMACOM.

Jill, G. (2002). Customer Loyalty: How to Earn It, How to Keep It. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Joby, J. (2003). Fundamentals of Customer-Focused Management. Westport: Praeger.

Lowenstein, M. (1997). The Customer Loyalty Pyramid. Westport: Quorum Books.

McCarthy, P. (2000). The Nordstrom Way. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Poisant, J. (2002). Creating and Sustaining a Superior Customer Service Organization. Westport: Quorum Books.

Zemke, R., & Woods, J. A. (1998). Best Practices in Customer Service. New York: American Management Association.