Decentralization, Labeling Theory, and Order-Maintenance Policing
This paper examines two interconnected topics in criminal justice policy. The first section defines decentralization — the dispersal of power from central to local authorities — and traces its connection to labeling theory, arguing that social domestic ills prompted government redistribution of resources to local agencies capable of diverting labeled youth from prisons and reformatories. The paper identifies improved decision-making quality as the most important outcome of decentralization and addresses the tension between the "less not more" ideal and Blomberg and Lucken's finding of "more not less." The second section analyzes order-maintenance policing (OMP) and its contested relationship with violent crime rates, drawing on Rosenfeld, Fornango, and Rengifo's study of New York City homicide and robbery data, and argues that OMP does meaningfully reduce crime when underreported offenses, ordinance violations, citizen disorder complaints, and police staffing levels are all properly considered.
- Introduction to Decentralization and Labeling Theory: Defines decentralization and its link to labeling theory
- The Most Important Practice from Decentralization: Improved decision-making as decentralization's key outcome
- Less Not More vs. More Not Less: Contrasting the ideal and actual results of decentralization
- Order-Maintenance Policing and Crime: Competing views on OMP and violent crime rates
- Limitations of Prior OMP Research: Methodological gaps in OMP studies and ordinance omissions
- Police Staffing, Ordinance Enforcement, and OMP Effectiveness: How staffing levels and indirect variables shape OMP impact
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly connects an abstract theoretical concept (labeling theory) to a practical policy movement (decentralization), grounding each in the same source framework.
- The OMP analysis engages directly with competing scholarly positions — Kelling and Sousa versus Harcourt and Ludwig — before synthesizing a nuanced argument about methodological limitations.
- The paper consistently returns to specific evidence (underreported rape cases, ordinance violations, citizen disorder complaints, police staffing) rather than relying solely on general claims.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective critical evaluation of conflicting studies. Rather than simply accepting one side of the OMP debate, the author identifies specific methodological gaps — such as the reliance on violent crime index as the sole outcome measure and the omission of indirect variables — and uses those gaps to build a more complete argument. This move from "both sides are partially wrong" to a synthesized conclusion is a valuable academic technique for undergraduate-level criminology writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized in two distinct question-and-answer blocks. The first block (three paragraphs) covers decentralization, its link to labeling theory, the most important practice it generated, and the "less not more" paradox. The second block (four paragraphs) addresses OMP and crime, progressively stacking evidence — underreporting, ordinance omissions, citizen complaints, and staffing — to argue that OMP does reduce violent crime when properly measured. A single reference list closes the paper.
Introduction to Decentralization and Labeling Theory
Decentralization refers to the dispersion of power from a central authority to existing local and regional authorities. The central authority delegates its functions and powers to these subordinate bodies. Labeling theory helps explain why people may engage in deviant behaviors. For instance, an individual who associates with thieves might receive the label of being a thief, and may then begin incorporating that behavior into his daily activities.
Blomberg and Lucken assert that labeling theory helps justify decentralization in its core concepts. The social domestic ills that the government could not accommodate prompted the redistribution of national resources to local authorities (Blomberg & Lucken, 2010). In this context, the distribution of resources represents one meaning of decentralization, while the domestic ills are understood through the lens of labeling theory. This implies that the contexts of labeling theory — which help illustrate the meaning of crime in society — triggered governments to adopt decentralization. Blomberg asserts that the government became entrenched in a "war of mentality" against domestic social ills, and that the only remedy was the massive mobilization of national resources to local authorities.
Local authorities are better positioned to deal with labeled youth because there is a recognized need to divert them from the formal system. The federal government cannot engage directly with offenders at the local level; it can only commit them to prisons and reformatories. Local authorities, by contrast, work to keep offenders out of those institutions (Blomberg & Lucken, 2010).
References
Blomberg, T. G., & Lucken, K. (2010). American penology: A history of control. AldineTransaction.
Rosenfeld, R., Fornango, R., & Rengifo, A. (2007). The impact of order-maintenance policing on New York City homicide and robbery rates: 1988–2001. Criminology, 45(2).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.