Classical vs. Positivist Approaches in Criminology
This paper compares two foundational schools of criminological thought: the classical approach and the positivist approach. It begins by defining criminology as the study of criminal behavior and its personal and social dimensions. The classical school, rooted in Enlightenment thinking, holds that individuals exercise free will and commit crimes out of rational self-interest, suggesting that proportional punishment deters future offenses. The positivist school, by contrast, draws on scientific and biological reasoning to argue that criminal behavior is shaped by factors beyond individual choice. The paper examines key thinkers from both traditions — including Cesare Beccaria and Cesare Lombroso — and closes by identifying the common ground shared by both perspectives.
- What Is Criminology?: Defines criminology and previews both schools
- The Classical Approach: Free will, rational choice, and deterrence theory
- Cesare Beccaria and Proportional Punishment: Beccaria's reforms and hierarchical punishment structure
- Motivation, Free Will, and Individual Accountability: Accountability, hedonism, and criminal motivation
- The Positivist Approach: Biological determinism, Lombroso, and scientific crime theory
- Common Ground Between the Two Schools: Shared foundations despite contrasting frameworks
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly frames two competing theoretical traditions and maintains that contrast throughout, making the comparison easy to follow.
- It anchors abstract ideas to named theorists — Beccaria, Lombroso, McLaughlin, and Muncie — giving the argument historical and scholarly grounding.
- The concluding section honestly acknowledges the limited overlap between the schools rather than overstating agreement, which demonstrates analytical balance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative theoretical analysis: it introduces each school on its own terms before drawing direct contrasts. Concepts such as free will, psychological hedonism, and atavism are defined and then evaluated against each other, showing how competing frameworks explain the same phenomenon — criminal behavior — from fundamentally different premises.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a definitional section that situates criminology as a discipline and previews the two schools. Two substantial body sections then develop the classical and positivist positions in sequence, each covering key assumptions, representative theorists, and policy implications. A shorter closing section identifies shared foundations, functioning as a synthesizing conclusion rather than a simple summary.
What Is Criminology?
Criminology is a term used to describe the entire study of criminal behavior, under which narrower aspects — including factors, causes, and consequences — are also examined. The subject deals with the personal and social factors associated with criminal behavior. It also sheds light on the impact that criminal behavior has on family life, on the victim, and on those around the victim. There are mainly two broad classifications within criminology that highlight the disciplines involved in the social sciences. The first is the classical approach and the second is the positivist approach.
Positivist criminologists argue that the criminal loses conscious control and fails to interpret his or her own behavior, which causes the criminal act to occur (Jeffery, p. 24). The person essentially has no control over his or her thinking and therefore does not realize the nature of the behavior he or she is engaging in. This approach places blame on internal and external factors that affect the person and consequently disturb the mental state of the individual's mind. The classical approach, by contrast, argues that every person has full capacity to make decisions and is aware of what he or she is doing. According to classicists, no one loses the ability to think rationally, and every criminal act is committed on the basis of a wrong decision — such as when a person is overtaken by extreme rage or a desire for revenge (Samenow, pp. 20–22).
In the modern world, criminology attracts the attention of many scholars and sociologists who seek to understand the factors that contribute to criminal behavior. Criminology has developed into a separate field of study in which researchers aim to understand the root of the problem and examine the mentality and cognitive processes of those who commit crimes. Various interpretations of criminal behavior exist, and each sociologist and criminologist brings a different perspective, advancing their research and experiments to understand the complete phenomenon of criminal activity. Criminology has also become a recognized career path alongside fields such as law, journalism, and policing (Schmallager, 2006, p. 120). The perspective from which a criminal act is analyzed depends on the act itself and the circumstances in which it occurred. The two broad perspectives — classical and positivist — are examined below, with particular attention to where they differ.
References
Coleman, C. & Norris, C. (2000). Introducing Criminology. Cullompton: Willan Publishing, p. 91.
Downes, D. & Rock, P. (2007). Understanding Deviance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jeffery, C. R. (1971). Prevention Through Environmental Design. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, p. 24.
McLaughlin, E. et al. (2007). Criminological Perspectives, 2nd ed. Sage, p. 77.
McLaughlin, E. & Muncie, J. (2006). Sage Dictionary of Criminology, 2nd ed. Sage, p. 54.
Morrison, W. (1997). Theoretical Criminology. London: Butterworths, p. 72.
Samenow, E. S. (1984). Inside the Criminal Mind. New York: Crown Business, pp. 20–22.
Schmallager, F. (2006). Criminology Today: An Integrative Introduction, 4th ed., p. 120.
Tierney, J. (2009). Key Perspectives in Criminology. Oxford: McGraw Hill/Oxford University Press, pp. 231–236.
White, R. & Haines, F. (2008). Crime & Criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, p. 135.
Young, J. (2003). "Thinking Seriously About Crime: Some Models of Criminology," pp. 35–39.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.