Female and Mature Age Workers: Workplace Injury Trends

Introduction: Shifting Demographics in the Workforce

Several implications surround the increasing numbers of female and mature age workers in the workforce throughout the world, not the least of which involve job-related injuries, insurance coverage, and workers' compensation settlements. Several factors have contributed to this occurrence, including an overall improvement in health and living conditions furnished by technological advances, longer life spans, and numerous sociological factors that enable and encourage women to become financially independent and self-supporting. All of these aspects of the contemporary workforce indicate that the trend of women and mature age laborers entering and maintaining positions in diverse industries and occupations is not likely to change or decline in the years to come. As such, it becomes important to examine what effects these particular segments of the labor force will have on the workforce — and to determine what, if any, ramifications their burgeoning presence holds for this resource so vital to global economies. The results of such analysis consistently demonstrate that age and gender are definite contributing factors to the costs, duration, prevalence, and severity of work-related injuries.

Gender Differences in Workplace Injury

Although it is a confirmed fact that women outnumber men — significantly so in certain populations — throughout the world, it is worth noting that even with the increased presence of women in the workforce, men are injured more frequently and incur fatal injuries far more often than their female counterparts. Several reasons account for this, one of the most salient being the types of occupations each gender tends to occupy. Although examples of either sex can be found in most professions, some careers — such as construction — are predominantly occupied by men and carry inherently high injury and mortality rates. Occupations such as mining, construction, and farming have leading mortality rates, and while women may work in these fields, they do so far less frequently than men.

On the whole, women tend to occupy positions that are more nurturing and supportive in nature, while men more commonly hold managerial, technical, or physically demanding roles. Women can more frequently be found in employment roles involving high levels of repetition, little autonomy, and limited decision-making power — all of which shape the types of injuries they are most likely to incur. Even in cases where men and women occupy the same positions, men are typically paid more, advanced further and sooner, and assigned different tasks. These factors, combined with the domestic responsibilities many women carry outside of the workplace, help explain why work-related injuries among women frequently include stress-related illness and musculoskeletal disorders — the latter of which may involve chronic problems with their backs, hands, and knees.

Mature Age Workers and Injury Risk

Just as it may surprise some to learn that women suffer fewer work-related injuries than men despite outnumbering them, it may be equally surprising to learn that younger laborers — particularly those between the ages of 15 and 24 — are far more likely to sustain on-the-job injuries than mature age workers, who are often assumed to be more frail and vulnerable. This tendency becomes even clearer when examining the number of emergency room visits related to workplace injuries among 15- to 24-year-olds compared to those of mature age workers, as research from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention illustrates.

Several characteristics of mature age workers contribute to their decreased likelihood of injury. These include the considerable advantages of professional experience, heightened vigilance and familiarity with safety measures, and the extended time they have had to develop coping mechanisms for the hazards specific to their careers. Additionally, the most physically vulnerable mature age workers are likely to have already retired or withdrawn from the workforce, leaving only the most capable and prudent laborers still active at advanced ages.

The general perception, however, is that while mature age workers are less likely to be injured at work than their younger counterparts, when they are injured their injuries tend to be more costly, more prolonged, and more severe. In fact, there are a number of reasons that make it more difficult for mature age workers to receive workers' compensation than for younger laborers. The Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 prohibits incapacity benefits for laborers aged 65 and older, meaning they are not eligible for payment for time away from work due to injury. Such payment has traditionally been the largest component of workers' compensation costs.

References

Hendrick, B. (2010). Younger people have more workplace injuries. Retrieved from

Graham, B. (2009). Maryland women's workplace injuries focus of new attention. Retrieved from http://ifawebnews.com/2009/06/16/maryland-womens-workplace-injuries-focus-of-new-attention/

Kelsh, M. A., & Sahl, J. D. (2006). Sex differences in injury rates in electric utility workers. American Journal of Epidemiology, 143(10). Retrieved from

Canadian Women's Health Network. (2005). Preventing work-related injuries: Health hazards. Retrieved from

Mitchell, O. S. (1988). The relation of age to workplace injuries. Monthly Labor Review. Retrieved from

Greenhouse, S. (2009). In workplace injury system, ill will on all sides. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/02/nyregion/02comp.html