Hydraulic Fracturing: Benefits, Risks, and Political Bias
This paper examines hydraulic fracturing (fracking) from multiple angles, exploring whether political affiliation influences the fracking debate and how bias from both Democrats and Republicans distorts objective discussion. The paper surveys the negative impacts of fracking — including wastewater disposal, chemical contamination, and uncertain long-term environmental consequences — alongside significant positive effects such as economic growth, reduced energy costs, and the United States' emergence as the world's largest natural gas producer. The paper ultimately calls for rigorous, unbiased, and replicable scientific research and urges both sides to pursue compromise rather than entrenched, ideologically driven positions.
- Introduction: A Polarized Debate: Extreme rhetoric from both sides hinders rational fracking discussion
- Political Bias and the Fracking Divide: Democrats and Republicans split sharply on fracking policy
- Negative Impacts of Hydraulic Fracturing: Wastewater, contamination, and long-term environmental harms examined
- Positive Effects of Hydraulic Fracturing: Economic growth and energy production gains from fracking
- Conclusion and the Case for Compromise: Calls for unbiased research and bipartisan compromise on fracking
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper maintains a genuine attempt at balance, explicitly acknowledging bias on both sides of the fracking debate rather than simply advocating one position.
- It draws on a range of sources — academic journals, policy publications, and industry reports — to support both the negative and positive claims about fracking.
- The call for compromise and unbiased research in the conclusion gives the paper a constructive, policy-oriented conclusion that moves beyond the usual partisan framing.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses source triangulation — citing peer-reviewed journals, government data, and policy commentary — to build a multi-sided argument. Rather than relying on a single type of evidence, it layers quantitative data (e.g., the $74 billion economic gain figure) alongside qualitative scholarly concerns about long-term environmental risk, demonstrating how to weigh competing evidence responsibly.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a framing introduction that establishes the rhetorical extremes on both sides. It then interrogates political bias as a lens for understanding the debate before presenting the negative and positive impacts in separate, clearly labeled sections. A concise summary section synthesizes the evidence and advocates for compromise, making the argument arc easy to follow despite the complexity of the subject.
Introduction: A Polarized Debate
Hydraulic fracturing can be compared and contrasted in sharply different manners; rhetoric on both sides can go over the edge, and oftentimes such extreme rhetoric ensures that any type of sane or rational discussion is rendered virtually impossible. Opponents have gone so far as to call hydraulic fracturing an "abnormally dangerous activity" (Rinaldi, 2015, p. 388), while proponents often argue that additional "EPA controls would cause energy prices to skyrocket, slow the development of natural-gas fields, and block enormous economic benefits" (Hobson, 2009, p. 19).
Both sides of the issue seem to make strong points in order to support their positions. Few and far between are the calls for objective and trustworthy research, such as the one in America magazine that asks opponents and proponents to at least agree that the science behind fracking should take into account the complexity of the situation as well as the repercussions for the future (Fracturing, 2014). Ironically, the call for objective research is rendered almost farcical when it goes on to suggest that having the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) conduct the research would result in anything but a strong bias toward halting any type of fracking — even if the agency took into consideration the enormous economic benefits provided by hydraulic fracturing.
What this paper seeks to determine is whether there is bias on both sides as determined by individual or group affiliation with either the Democratic or Republican political parties. Additionally, the paper examines both the negative and positive effects of fracking and considers how fracking can be economically beneficial while also resulting in fewer negative effects on the environment.
References
Christopherson, S. & Rightor, N. (2012). How shale gas extraction affects drilling localities: Lessons for regional and city policy makers. Journal of Town and City Management, 2(4), 350–368.
Environmental Protection Agency. (2010). Scoping materials for initial design of EPA research study on potential relationships between hydraulic fracturing and drinking water resources. Retrieved December 7, 2015, from http://yosemite.epa.gov/sab/sabproduct.nsf/0/3B745430D624ED3B852576D400514B76/$File/Hydraulic+Frac+Scoping+Doc+for+SAB-3-22-10+Final.pdf
Fracturing logic. (2011). America, 204(11), 5.
Hartman, K. (2015). Economies of shale. State Legislatures, 41(6), 28–32.
Hobson, M. K. (2009). EPA, states tangle on hydraulic fracturing. National Journal, 12/5/2009, 19.
Rahm, D., Fields, B., & Farmer, J. L. (2015). Transportation impacts of fracking in the Eagle Ford Shale development in rural South Texas: Perceptions of local government officials. Journal of Rural & Community Development, 10(2), 78–99.
Rinaldi, R. (2015). Fracturing the Keystone: Why fracking in Pennsylvania should be considered an abnormally dangerous activity. Widener Law Journal, 24(2), 385–.
Steliga, T., Kluk, D., & Jakubowicz, P. (2015). Analysis of chemical and toxicological properties of fluids for shale hydraulic fracturing and flowback water. Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, 24(5), 2185–2196.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.