Book Review: Kettl's System Under Stress on Homeland Security
This paper presents a critical review of Donald Kettl's System Under Stress: Homeland Security and American Politics (2nd ed., 2007), which examines how the U.S. political system responds to the stresses of providing homeland security in the wake of 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina. The review describes the book's structure, method, and central argument — that strong individual leadership is essential for effective disaster response and coordination within a complex federal bureaucracy. The reviewer evaluates the validity of Kettl's evidence, the exploratory nature of his thesis, and the book's strengths and limitations, including its failure to probe alternative explanations and deeper structural critiques of the American political system.
- Introduction: Context, scope, and purpose of Kettl's book
- Description and Overview: Book structure, method, and key statements on leadership
- Evaluation of Method and Thesis: Assessment of exploratory approach and emerging thesis
- Data, Validity, and Conclusions: Evidence selection, logical validity, and supported conclusions
- What Others Have Said: Mixed reviews noting limited new insight for experts
- Summary: Strengths and Weaknesses: What the book does and does not accomplish
- Overall Significance: Final judgment on the book's value and limitations
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review follows a clear evaluative structure, moving systematically from description to analysis to judgment, which gives readers a well-organized understanding of both the book's content and its merits.
- The reviewer supports evaluative claims with direct quotations from Kettl, demonstrating close reading and allowing the evidence to speak for itself rather than relying on paraphrase alone.
- The critique section is balanced — acknowledging the book's accessible strengths while pointing to substantive gaps, such as the absence of alternative explanations and comparison with deeper scholarly critiques like Peter Dale Scott's work.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of the evaluative book review format: it distinguishes between description (what the book says) and evaluation (how well it says it), organized into discrete labeled subsections. This structure prevents the common error of summarizing a book without critically assessing it, making the review genuinely analytical rather than merely reportorial.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction that contextualizes the book and its author. A descriptive section covers the overview, method, book structure, and notable quotations. An evaluation section then assesses method, thesis, data validity, and whether conclusions are supported. The review concludes with a summary of strengths and weaknesses, brief engagement with other reviewers' opinions, and a final judgment on the book's overall significance. This mirrors a standard academic book review format appropriate for graduate-level coursework.
Introduction
This review covers Kettl's (2007) System Under Stress: Homeland Security and American Politics, published by CQ Press in Washington, D.C. (151 pp.). The book is relevant because it addresses the need to assess the status of the Department of Homeland Security in light of the various stresses it encounters. It frames that discussion within the scope of 9/11 and the disaster of Hurricane Katrina by asking what happened, why the government apparently failed to protect its citizens, and what lessons have or have not been learned from these disasters.
The author states in his Preface that from 2002 to 2003 he worked "with the Century Foundation as executive director of its Project on Federalism and Homeland Security" (p. x). His background on homeland security issues is primarily academic, though the book's organizing metaphor is drawn from cardiology: just as a stress test tells how well the heart works, Kettl's purpose is to examine how well the nation's defenses are working. The 2007 edition is the second edition of the book, rewritten in the wake of the Hurricane Katrina disaster, and is intended for students of American government, public policy, public administration, intergovernmental relations, and homeland security.
The historical context shaping the work is that of disaster — namely, the 9/11 terror attacks and the organizational failures of the Department of Homeland Security and FEMA to respond appropriately to Katrina. The scope of the work includes an assessment of the impact of 9/11 on the nation and the response of its leaders; system-wide breakdowns that allowed the attacks and what gaps were subsequently plugged within the intelligence community; the problems of federal bureaucracy that made coordination fail at Katrina; the political system's attempts to prevent disasters that can never be fully eliminated in terms of risk; the tension between security and civil liberties; and how the political system can respond to "such crushing strain" (p. ix). This scope is somewhat large for the scant 150 pages the text occupies; nonetheless, the author's approach is deliberately exploratory, and the aim is to raise questions more than to answer them definitively.
References
Kettl, D. F. (2007). System under stress: Homeland security and American politics. CQ Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.