Skip to main content
Book Review Undergraduate 1,549 words

Kingdom of Matthias and Alcoholic Republic: A Comparative Review

~8 min read 6 sections History · American History
Abstract

This paper offers a comparative review of two history books examining distinct segments of early American social life. Paul E. Johnson's The Kingdom of Matthias chronicles the rise and fall of a utopian religious cult led by the self-proclaimed prophet Robert Matthews during the Second Great Awakening, while W.J. Rorabaugh's The Alcoholic Republic analyzes widespread alcohol consumption in America from 1790 to 1840. The paper evaluates each author's narrative approach, use of primary sources, and broader arguments about American society, finding that both books present controversial yet well-researched perspectives on how ideas and social forces shaped early American culture.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Two Visions of Early American Society: Two history books, two social movements compared
  • The Kingdom of Matthias: Religion, Charisma, and Utopia: Matthias cult origins, beliefs, and controversies
  • Johnson's Narrative Method and Use of Sources: Johnson's narrative structure and source analysis
  • The Alcoholic Republic: Drink, Culture, and Social Order: Rorabaugh's study of American drinking culture
  • Rorabaugh's Argument and Evidence: Statistics, clergy accounts, and social divisions
  • Comparative Analysis and Conclusions: Both authors' shared rigor and social relevance
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper maintains a clear parallel structure, moving from one book to the other before bringing both together in a comparative conclusion, making the argument easy to follow.
  • It evaluates not just the content of each book but also the authors' methodological choices — narrative ordering, source selection, and reconciliation of contradictory evidence — demonstrating analytical depth beyond simple summary.
  • The paper grounds each book in its historical context (the Second Great Awakening, the temperance era) while noting the relevance of both works to contemporary readers.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates comparative historiographical analysis — assessing two works side by side not only for their historical content but for how each author constructs an argument, selects and weighs evidence, and frames a segment of American social history as representative of broader cultural truths. This technique is especially visible in the final section, where the similarities in scholarly rigor and social relevance between Johnson and Rorabaugh are highlighted.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens by situating both books within the broader question of how social ideas shape communities. It then devotes separate sections to each book — first summarizing its subject, then evaluating its narrative method and evidence. A brief comparative conclusion brings the two books together, noting shared strengths and parallel contributions to understanding early American society. The Works Cited section follows standard citation practice.

Essay 1,549 words

Introduction: Two Visions of Early American Society

Human beings interact and react with each other and with their environment, often on the basis of certain ideas that gain ascendance at a particular time and place. The society of a given era gains its shape from prevailing ideas about how society should be organized — what should interest its members and how people should relate to one another. Two such societies are addressed by the authors of two history books detailing particular social movements and their outcomes: The Kingdom of Matthias by Paul E. Johnson and The Alcoholic Republic by W.J. Rorabaugh.

The Kingdom of Matthias: Religion, Charisma, and Utopia

The Kingdom of Matthias tells the story of a real effort to create a utopian society in mid-nineteenth-century America, headed by the Prophet Matthias, whose sect was a rival to the Mormons under Joseph Smith. The attempt Matthias made to found his own kingdom was bound up with his visions of a kingdom of heaven on earth. Matthias was notorious before that time and had been put on trial for murder and theft in New York, though the jury did not convict him. A self-declared Jewish minister, he sought to create a kingdom to replace the American republic, which he saw as having failed to live up to its promises of union, freedom, and equal rights. He claimed to be a direct descendant of Jesus and of Matthias the Apostle, and he stated that he embodied the souls of these and other prophets, thereby possessing everlasting life as a reincarnation of those souls. He gathered followers and set out to create his kingdom.

The Kingdom of Matthias emerged during the religious revival known as the Second Great Awakening. The leader's real name was Robert Matthews, and the kingdom he founded would likely be deemed a cult if he attempted it today.

The basics of the cult are summarized by Richard C.S. Trahair, who notes how the kingdom, also called Mount Zion, was founded at Sing Sing, New York, and scandalized the world: "The community members would cavort naked, marry spiritually, and freely exchange sexual partners."1 Clearly, the free love aspect of the cult was one of its most controversial elements and contributed to the way it was isolated and later persecuted.

4 Sections Hidden · 800 words
Johnson's Narrative Method and Use of Sources250 words
Paul E. Johnson shapes this story by beginning after Matthias is acquitted of…
The Alcoholic Republic: Drink, Culture, and Social Order220 words
A very different sort of social order and social analysis is evident in W.J. Rorabaugh's Alcoholic Republic. The author examines the history of drinking in…
Rorabaugh's Argument and Evidence180 words
The image of a nation of drunkards did not originate with Rorabaugh; rather, he derives it from the hyperbole of the clergy of the time — clergy who railed against the evils of drink and kept the issue alive through tales of supposed alcoholic debauchery in a society that, in their view, valued freedom over morality. Rorabaugh draws much of this material from excerpts of sermons and…
Comparative Analysis and Conclusions150 words
Rorabaugh writes well, as does Johnson, and both books are readable, make coherent arguments, and are fully referenced and carefully reasoned. Both books address a segment of the larger American social order,…

Works Cited

Johnson, Paul E. The Kingdom of Matthias. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994.

Rorabaugh, W.J. The Alcoholic Republic. New York: Oxford University Press, 1979.

Trahair, Richard C.S. Utopias and Utopians: An Historical Dictionary. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 1999.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Kingdom of Matthias Alcoholic Republic Second Great Awakening Utopian Community Temperance Movement Religious Revivalism Social History Primary Sources American Tradition Charismatic Leadership
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Kingdom of Matthias and Alcoholic Republic: A Comparative Review. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/kingdom-matthias-alcoholic-republic-comparative-review-26307

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.