Leadership Models, Ethics, and Organizational Culture
This paper examines the relationship between cultural style and ethical leadership across three interconnected areas. First, it analyzes how an organization's cultural values determine what is perceived as ethical in a leader's exercise of power, influence, and authority, using Enron's aggressive culture as an illustrative case. Second, it surveys the leadership models most widely accepted as ethical across diverse social cultures, identifying transformational, charismatic, and servant leadership as particularly cross-culturally resonant. Finally, it argues that servant leadership — grounded in empathy, altruism, and genuine responsiveness to employee needs — is the most effective model for shaping inclusive and broadly accepted organizational cultures.
- Cultural Style and the Ethics of Leadership Power: How organizational values define ethical leadership behavior
- Enron as a Case Study in Culture-Driven Ethics: Enron's aggressive culture justified extreme management practices
- Leadership Models Accepted Across Social Cultures: Transformational, charismatic, and servant leadership compared
- Servant Leadership as the Optimal Culture-Shaping Model: Servant leadership recommended for inclusive culture-building
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a concrete, well-known corporate scandal (Enron) to anchor an abstract argument about culture-relative ethics, making the theoretical claim immediately tangible.
- Maintains a clear three-part structure — diagnosis, survey, recommendation — that gives the argument logical momentum and a satisfying resolution.
- Grounds the normative recommendation in cross-cultural inclusivity rather than a single cultural standpoint, which strengthens the paper's universalizing claim about servant leadership.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of a negative example (Enron's culture-justified misconduct) to sharpen a positive normative argument. By showing how cultural values can sanction ethically problematic behavior, the author creates a clear standard against which more universally ethical leadership models can be measured. This contrast technique is a strong tool for evaluative academic writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by defining the relationship between cultural style and ethical perception, then applies that framework to Enron as a case study. It broadens outward to survey leadership models with cross-cultural ethical acceptance — transformational, charismatic, and servant leadership — before narrowing back down to a defended recommendation. This funnel-and-focus structure efficiently moves from concept to evidence to conclusion.
Cultural Style and the Ethics of Leadership Power
Ethical leadership models function as tools for shaping organizational culture. Moreover, these models can produce that effect while preserving the diversity of the social groups — and their cultures — represented among a company's employees. Cultural style effectively determines what is perceived as ethical in a leader's use of power, influence, and authority in two distinct ways.
First, cultural style forms the basis of an organization's values. The relationship between values and ethics is a critical one: what a company prioritizes and holds dear directly influences the ethical standards it upholds. Thus, when a leader acts in accordance with the prevailing company culture, the vast majority of decisions made with that power and authority will be perceived as ethical within the constraints of that organization.
Enron as a Case Study in Culture-Driven Ethics
A compelling example of this dynamic is found in the analysis of Enron's company culture and the behavior of its leaders. Under the leadership of Jeff Skilling, Enron maintained an admittedly aggressive company culture (McLean and Elkind, 2013, p. 70) that was used as the basis to justify a number of practices that organizations with different cultures would never have sanctioned.
For example, Enron conducted performance reviews in which it routinely dismissed those who finished in the bottom percentages of those rankings. The mandatory firing of employees based on relative performance — rather than on specific instances of misconduct or incompetence — is certainly an extreme exercise of power, influence, and authority by upper-level management. Yet because Enron's culture was aggressive, this practice was deemed not only ethical but necessary to drive productivity and competitiveness. Because Enron's values were rooted in hyper-competition, such a practice was considered ethically consistent with its overall cultural style.
Leadership Models Accepted Across Social Cultures
One of the most widely accepted leadership models regarded as ethical across a broad range of social cultures is transformational leadership. This model tends to be ethically acceptable across cultural boundaries because it is centered on motivating followers from a genuine, people-oriented perspective. Transformational leaders compel followers to embrace a vision of positive organizational change through qualities that are often intangible. The model is built on getting followers to genuinely believe in what the leader is working to accomplish, and to channel that belief into the transformation of how the organization operates and performs. Because this motivation is tied to resonating with employees' own social and cultural values, it is generally perceived as ethically sound.
Charismatic leadership produces a similar effect. This style is grounded in the positive, magnetic attributes of the leader personally. Charismatic leaders must effectively model the characteristics they wish to inspire in their followers — their personalities must be attractive, energetic, and visionary. They are only perceived as such, however, if they genuinely appeal to the core values of their followers' social cultures. Servant leadership is another widely accepted model, predicated on leaders actively attending to the needs of their employees in order to motivate them to achieve organizational objectives.
References
McLean, B., & Elkind, P. (2013). The smartest guys in the room. New York: Penguin.
Spears, L. C. (2010). Character and servant leadership: Ten characteristics of effective, caring leaders. The Journal of Virtues and Leadership, 1(1), 25–30.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.