Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,421 words

McNaughton Rule, Durham Rule, and the Insanity Defense

~8 min read 5 sections Law · Criminal Law
Abstract

This paper traces the historical development of the insanity defense in American and British law, focusing on three major legal standards: the McNaughton Rule, the Durham Rule, and the US Federal Rule. It examines the origins of each standard and analyzes how landmark cases — particularly those involving John Hinckley Jr. and Andrea Yates — shaped public perception and legislative reform. The paper also considers how different states apply the Model Penal Code and discusses the ongoing tension between legal formalism and scientific understanding of mental illness in criminal proceedings.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction to the Insanity Defense: Origins of the McNaughton Rule and insanity standard
  • Major Legal Standards for Insanity: Durham Rule, Federal Rule, and Model Penal Code
  • The John Hinckley Jr. Case: Hinckley's assassination attempt and insanity acquittal
  • The Andrea Yates Case: Yates postpartum psychosis defense and conviction
  • Public Outcry and Legislative Reform: Legislative backlash and insanity defense reforms
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It grounds abstract legal standards in concrete, well-known cases, making complex doctrine accessible and memorable.
  • It traces a clear historical progression — from McNaughton to Durham to the Federal Rule — showing how each standard emerged as a reaction to the limitations of its predecessor.
  • It balances legal analysis with social commentary, noting how high-profile verdicts drove legislative change rather than purely legal reasoning.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper uses case study analysis to illustrate doctrinal evolution. Rather than defining legal rules in the abstract, it anchors each standard to a specific historical moment or trial outcome, demonstrating how law develops in response to real-world events. This technique is especially effective in legal studies writing, where doctrine and precedent are best understood through their application.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens by establishing the origins of the McNaughton Rule, then moves chronologically through the Durham Rule and the US Federal Rule. It transitions into two detailed case studies — Hinckley and Yates — before concluding with an analysis of the public and legislative backlash triggered by the Hinckley verdict. Each section builds on the previous one, linking legal standards to real-world consequences.

Essay 1,421 words

Introduction to the Insanity Defense

The name McNaughton derives from the son of a Glasgow wood turner who suffered from the delusion that a conspiracy was being organized against him — that Catholic priests had sent spies to harass him. It is from these encounters that the McNaughton Rule came into being. The rule is grounded in understanding the difference between right and wrong. It serves as a test of two concepts: "knowing right and wrong by oneself in the course of their actions" (Asokan, 2007). The idea of uncontrollable impulses was not considered a significant factor. This rule became the standard test applied by juries after hearing medical testimony. As a result, there was a presumption of sanity unless the defense proved otherwise. Both the United States and the United Kingdom adopted the McNaughton Rule, and many states continue to use it to handle cases to this day (The 'insanity defense' and diminished capacity, 2017).

4 Sections Hidden · 800 words
Major Legal Standards for Insanity290 words
The Durham Rule
The John Hinckley Jr. Case210 words
Hinckley became obsessed with the 1976 film Taxi Driver, in which Jodie Foster plays a child prostitute and Robert De Niro plays Travis Bickle, a character who plots to assassinate a presidential candidate. Hinckley watched the film repeatedly and developed an intense fixation on…
The Andrea Yates Case190 words
Yates had a documented mental illness history. She had been diagnosed with postpartum depression a few months after…
Public Outcry and Legislative Reform110 words
The verdict in Hinckley's case sparked widespread public outcry. Many believed that the insanity defense was a legal loophole that…

References

Asokan, T. (2007). Daniel McNaughton (1813–1865). Indian Journal of Psychiatry, 223–224.

Biography.com Editors. (2017, April 28). John Hinckley Jr. Biography.com. Retrieved from https://www.biography.com/people/john-hinckley-jr-17171774

Cassel, E. (2006, July 28). The second Andrea Yates verdict. Retrieved from CounterPunch: http://www.counterpunch.org/2006/07/28/the-second-andrea-yates-verdict/

Dunham, N. (2016, June 20). Andrea Yates, in a mental facility, watches videos of her children — 15 years after she drowned them. Retrieved from People Crime: http://people.com/crime/andrea-yates-15-years-after-drowning-five-children-in-a-texas-mental-facility/

Francone, E. (2016, July). Insanity defense. Retrieved from Cornell Law School: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/insanity_defense

Nau, M., McNiel, D., & Binder, R. (2012). Postpartum psychosis and the courts. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 318–325.

The Insanity Defense Among the States. (2017). Retrieved from FindLaw: http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-procedure/the-insanity-defense-among-the-states.html

The 'insanity defense' and diminished capacity. (2017, May 26). Retrieved from Cornell Law: https://www.law.cornell.edu/background/insane/insanity.html

WGBH Edu Foundation. (2014). A case of insanity. Frontline.

Yoong, G. (2012, April 11). Top 10 most notorious insanity defense cases. Retrieved from Listverse: http://listverse.com/2012/04/11/top-10-most-notorious-insanity-defense-cases/

Key Concepts in This Paper
McNaughton Rule Durham Rule Insanity Defense Criminal Responsibility Mental Disease Postpartum Psychosis Model Penal Code Legal Reform Diminished Capacity Federal Insanity Standard
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). McNaughton Rule, Durham Rule, and the Insanity Defense. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/mcnaughton-durham-rule-insanity-defense-2168341

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.